4 ms·
I just edited my comment to double down due to downvotes, but this ruling will ultimately damage the US more than Argentina. If we establish that it will be imp
by pessimizer 12y ago
I just edited my comment to double down due to downvotes, but this ruling will ultimately damage the US more than Argentina. If we establish that it will be impossible to restructure debt if you issue your bonds in the US, we've established that there's no reason to issue your bonds in the US.
edit: it's important to keep in mind that 93% of bondholders have agreed to the restructuring. The courts look like they're saying that the decision must be unanimous. That's completely unworkable.
- blowski 12y agoI actually downvoted you because the world `holdup` made it sound a bit inflammatory. Having read the links, I see where you're coming from, and changed to an upvote. This is certainly one of those topics that sensationalists will try to reduce to easy answers, when it's clear there aren't any.
- pessimizer 12y agohttp://www.cepr.net/index.php/blogs/the-americas-blog/argentina-vs-the-vultures-what-you-need-to-know http://www.cepr.net/index.php/blogs/the-americas-blog/argent... Here's another link. edit: and another - http://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2013/12/19/the-real-facts-on-argentinas-sovereign-debt-restructuring-a-rebuttal/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2013/12/19/the-real-fac...
- chimeracoder 12y ago> Having read the links, I see where you're coming from, and changed to an upvote. How do you change a vote on HN? Any time I upvote or downvote, both arrows disappear, so I always assumed they were permanent.
- blowski 12y agoGood point. I thought I did - perhaps I'm thinking I'm on StackOverflow. I thought I clicked 'back' so the arrows were there. I don't remember. Even if I haven't actually changed it to an upvote, then it deserves it.
- pessimizer 12y agoIt doesn't matter:) I've got plenty of internet points; I just appreciate your thoughtful replies.
- smackfu 12y agoIt's a difficult situation because a lot of these bonds have been resold at a steep discount. Someone who paid ten cents on the dollar for a bond has much different financial incentives than I may have as an original buyer... should the fact that there are more of them mean they can screw me over?
- rahimnathwani 12y agoWhy should the price I paid for the bond give me different incentives? It's only the future cash flows scenarios which are relevant to my decision-making. What I paid is a sunk cost, and doesn't affect my possible actions or payoffs in the future. (I'm assuming that I wasn't bankrupted due to the price I paid, and that I am a professional investor rather than an emotional gambler)
- estebank 12y agoWell, not passing judgement for or against, but these holdouts _also_ bought the bonds at less than face value.
- rahimnathwani 12y agoThere _is_ reason to issue your bonds in the US (e.g. governed by New York law). Investors trust that the bond contract will be honoured because, if not, it's likely to be enforced by the courts.
- PeterisP 12y agoWell no, if we estabilish what you say, then we've only found out that US jurisdiction is friendly to creditors and less friendly to debtors, and nothing else. It doesn't mean that there's no reason to issue your bonds in the US, on the contrary - it means that if you have a debt-reputation problem but feel safe in your ability to repay, then you'll want to issue your bonds in US to 'put your money where your mouth is' and get a better price. Or, in cases like Argentina, the potential investors will say 'either US jurisdiction or no deal'.
- berns 12y agoJudge Griesa decision shouldn't be solomonic. He decides based on a contract. His role is not to favour one part or the other.The percentage of bondholder that accepted the restructuring is irrelevant. Also, something that is not usually mentioned is that an appeals court upheld the judge's decision.
- bradleyjg 12y ago>I just edited my comment to double down due to downvotes, but this ruling will ultimately damage the US more than Argentina. If we establish that it will be impossible to restructure debt if you issue your bonds in the US, we've established that there's no reason to issue your bonds in the US. Every country in the world knows that it is going to be easier to restructure if you issue bonds under local law. No one selects New York law for its bonds out of some naive inertia. Argentina specifically went out of its way to select New York law and deliberately put in a pari passu clause because it had a history of defaulting on debt, and it thought it wouldn't be able to raise money, or at least not at the same rate, if it issued bonds under local law. I can't think of any possible reason to relieve a country of obligations that were deliberately and knowingly undertaken to tie its own hands in order to make its debt more credible. If you want collective action on restructured debt put in a collective action clause. If you want a sweetheart interpretation of your debt clauses issue it under local law. Every country that is issuing debt knows these things, they aren't rocket science. The reason they sometimes choose not to is because they want to pay a lower coupon and/or be sure that the whole issue will be purchased.