4 ms·
I don't understand why S&Ps rating matters, except for in the cases of US state or federal investments where some of the ratings agencies have been written into
by pessimizer 12y ago
I don't understand why S&Ps rating matters, except for in the cases of US state or federal investments where some of the ratings agencies have been written into statute. Everybody is as familiar with the Argentinian situation and how it has developed as S&P is, and they have the ability to make their own judgements about whether they want to buy Argentinean bonds.
The danger to Argentina is that the US government has declared that they're holding hostage the bond payments that Argentina has agreed to and wishes to make.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 12y agoThe S&P isn't New York law. I don't understand what you're saying.
- opendais 12y agoI deleted because the other people explained far better before I could explain. xD
- sz4kerto 12y ago> I don't understand why S&Ps rating matters Because it's part of many private contracts and financial products. (E.g. 'in case the S&P rating of entity X drops below Z, then [...]').
- pessimizer 12y agoThanks. Is this generally something that's written in to qualify for doing business with the state, or something that private investors look for?
- arjunnarayan 12y agoBoth. A lot of large institutional investors (like pension funds) have statutory limits on the percentage of the portfolio that can be allocated to riskier investments. Risk is sometimes defined by the S&P rating.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoThe background behind the rating agencies is that there are thousands or even millions of investment portfolios out there, with many of them fulfilling very important risk management functions. Pension funds, health insurance, all other forms of insurance, Banks, even many big companies who aren't technically in the finance industry. Most of them need some form of "low yield safe investment". But it is hard to define what is safe. That's where rating agencies come in. An insurance can promise to abide by such an agency, and that removes a lot of oportunity for bad judgement on the part of individual fund managers. You may argue whether these agencies are doing a good job at this, but most proposals to get to a better system involve some way of increasing the power of governments or individual fund managers.
- pessimizer 12y agoI didn't realize how common that was outside of government. Thanks.
- crdoconnor 12y ago>You may argue whether these agencies are doing a good job at this, but most proposals to get to a better system involve some way of increasing the power of governments or individual fund managers. Ratings agencies are unaccountable private entities. Every time they are challenged they invoke the 1st amendment - i.e. their right to lie. Yet the law enshrines their privilege through regulation of investments (which are forced to rely upon their opinions). There's absolutely no way the government would be any worse. They are at least accountable to their citizens via voting. Ratings agencies are accountable to nobody. They've also used their weight to bully, too. S&P downgraded the US even though it made absolutely no sense because there were moves made to prosecute them for mis-rating CDOs before the credit crisis.