6 ms·
Mississipi is richer than Europe
- brazzy 17y agoWhen did HN become a forum for country dickwaving?
- cwan 17y ago(in response to the earlier comment that was "when did HN become a forum for politics" prior to edit - though I think this still applies) I'd agree that topics like this clearly straddle the line but they're also of interest to at least some of us - especially given the underlying question of what policies help/hurt us and create wealth? Some politics are unavoidable given their impact on startups. It's also a pretty interesting factoid especially in the aftermath of the financial crisis that provides a bit of perspective where nearly every country is doing some introspective as to how it happened and when at least the US is about to adopt some policies that you could call European.
- tptacek 17y agoWhat a weird response. It is, to say the least, counterintuitive that, when PPP-adjusted, Mississipeans have greater buying power than Germans. It either suggests that something is wrong with the author's naive methodology of ranking countries, or that something weird is going on in Germany.
- desu 17y agoHm, the problem with PPP is that it's very unclear what it's measuring. Someone with a wal-mart nearby has a higher "PPP" than someone without it. Definitely Americans have access to a lot of cheap crap; it would not surprise me if an average income earner in the Mississippi could indeed buy more random junk each year than your average German. Purchasing power and quality of life, though, are two very different things. The idea that your average "Mississipean" has a higher quality of life than your average German is laughable. Intuitively, I would have thought Germany was higher overall than the USA, quite a lot higher.
- tptacek 17y agoSo, if that's true --- and I live in a major US metro, I'm not a Mississipi booster --- you should be able to provide some metric justifying it. What about Germany makes it better than Jackson?
- davidw 17y agoI thought it was a pretty rational response if you're not interested in seeing this site filled with flame-bait like this.
- gojomo 17y agoI think it's easy for Americans -- especially the educated and cosmopolitan-minded -- to idealize other countries. Speaking as one, we're most likely to see their wealthy, urban, tourist-friendly areas. We're most likely to interact with foreign elites who travel here or work in international businesses. We only pay their internal higher prices -- from their smaller and often more-oligopolistic domestic markets, and higher taxes -- on brief trips where we are price-insensitive, as tourists or corporate travelers. That most people in admirable, 'rich', developed countries live simple, frugal lives -- by American standards -- can thus be surprising, even though it shouldn't be.
- davidw 17y agoSome of us Americans live in foreign countries and are well past idealizing them, but take them for what they are; both things that are, in our opinions, way better than the US, or much worse. It's a complicated enough matter that I could talk about it all night over a bottle of wine. Suffice it to say, however, that "Mississippi is richer than Europe" is stupid flame-bait. It's more or less on the level of snotty Europeans who think Americans are dumb. Couldn't we leave silly pissing matches like that to other sites? Pretty please?
- gojomo 17y agoThe same statement can be flame-bait or a spark for thoughtful discussion, depending on the presentation and participants. Stated without nationalistic puffery, "According to a respected economic measure (purchasing-power parity), Mississippi produces more, per-capita, than almost any country in Europe", among the right audience, is a very interesting thing to talk about. Let's choose to see it as an invitation to subtle discussion among respectful participants, rather than patriotic pissing.
- m_eiman 17y agoDoes PPP take into account things that are paid for with taxes (to a greater degree) in the EU and by insurance fees in the US, e.g. healthcare?
- david927 17y agoExactly. PPP is calculated in such a way that makes such gigantic jokes like this possible. You simply have to travel to see how funny it is. Has that person been to Mississippi, and has he been to Switzerland or Norway? I mean, come on.
- tptacek 17y agoI was waiting for someone to debunk this, but I have to ask --- everyone in Jackson has a Wal-Mart within a 5 minute drive, and the average home purchase price is $129,000. It isn't possible that people in Jackson have approximately the same standard of living as Germans, at a much lower price?
- barrkel 17y agoOf all the European countries I've been to, Germany is the country that most reminded me of the US in terms of road patterns and layout, car orientation, big marts / malls with a lot of choice - far more choice than the average UK supermarket, in which it's unusual to see more than about 4 choices for any given commodity. For context, I'm Irish and currently living in the UK, working for a US company and regularly visit the Santa Cruz area; I've been in Paris, Barcelona, Seville, Lisbon, Sicily, much of Italy, Amsterdam, Vienna, Prague, Bucharest, Budapest, Sofia, Athens, Lausanne, etc. I know my German girlfriend and her friends disagree with my perception - they see UK & Ireland as being quite different from the continent.
- dkarl 17y agoLet's not blithely discount the judgment of all the people who pay twice as much for the same house elsewhere.
- 17y ago
- barrkel 17y agoOn the face of it, this comparison seems pretty absurd. I haven't been to Mississippi, but I have been to many European countries, and can attest that Germany is pretty rich on the face of it, personal incomes aside. I wonder how such comparisons value public goods, and how well their basket of goods (for PPP weighting) is balanced.
- tptacek 17y agoWell, where in Germany have you spent serious time?
- barrkel 17y agoRoughly in order of time spent, Neumünster, Bochum, Frankfurt am Main / Mainz, Hamburg and Berlin. I've never lived there, but my GF is German, and have been to and fro for weddings, meet parents, various trips etc. I should hasten to add that this isn't an exhaustive list, I've been on a number of train trips too, but I wouldn't count the handful of hours in those places, e.g. Lübeck, Kiel, Flensburg.
- jdburdette 17y agoOne thing to remember is that a country where one person makes $120,000 and nine others make $20,000 has the same per-capita GDP as a country where ten people make $30,000 each. Also, as m_eiman points out, PPP does not account for social costs such as increased greenhouse emissions or declining infrastructure.
- tptacek 17y agoIt's not obvious to me that the infrastructure in Mississipi would be declining faster than the infrastructure in, say, Italy. At the very least, Mississipi is bound to have a much better road system.
- davidw 17y agoItaly's roads aren't that bad, actually (at least in the north). The problem is that they are covered with Italian drivers, and there are an awful lot of them: 60 million in an area a bit smaller than California. (Well, 60 million inhabitants - not all of them drive, but more drive than they ought to)
- tptacek 17y agoI wasn't trying to imply that Italy's roads were bad, just pointing out that US roads are unusually excellent. I picked Italy instead of Germany to avoid a pointless message board argument comparing Germany's often-excellent roads to Mississipi's.
- toretore 17y agoPeople (and by that I mean Americans, sorry) seem to think Germany's roads are an exception. While this may have been true 20 or 30 years ago, in reality they're pretty much the same as or even a little worse than the rest of Europe. An exception might be the EU10, but they're catching up really fast. Also, 20-lane motorways through the centre of a city is not a sign of excellency but rather that of poor planning.
- 17y ago
- tybris 17y agoThis is probably accurate. If I want to make money I go to the US. If I don't want to have concerns over money I go to Europe.
- dimitar 17y agoSomeone forgot to put all the EU countries that have higher PPP than Mississippi like Ireland, Denmark, Austria, Luxembourg, Sweden, Belgium, Finland. Luxembourg a PPP of $~80k which is more than DC which is on top of the US list with its $65k. Better read this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_GDP_per_capita_%28nominal%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_GDP_per_... and this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28PPP%29_per_capita http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28PPP... and make your own conclusions.
- MaysonL 17y agoLies, Damned Lies, and Statistics. Of course, I would bet that median per capita income, or median household income, is substantially lower in Mississippi than in most of the EU15 (The first 15 members). Median household income in Mississippi is ~$29K. see http://crookedtimber.org/2005/06/03/its-the-median-stupid/ http://crookedtimber.org/2005/06/03/its-the-median-stupid/ for some discussion of this topic Also, I would bet that the deprivation index for Mississippi [1] would be higher than for most of the countries he cites, especially for the lowest quartiles. [1] Deprivation index: add up the number of these you can't afford. Adequate home heating, an annual holiday, new furniture to replace worn-out items, a meal with meat every second day, new clothes, the wherewithal to entertain guests at home. The worst off of the countries he cites, Italy[2], has a top quartile deprivation index of 0.5, median quartiles of ~0.6-0.7 (estimating from chart0 and bottom quartile of 2.0. I doubt that Mississippians are better off than that. [2] See http://www.eurofound.europa.eu/pubdocs/2008/52/en/1/EF0852EN.pdf http://www.eurofound.europa.eu/pubdocs/2008/52/en/1/EF0852EN...
- lkrubner 17y agoPPP is bunk. It assumes that currency traders are morons who market trades are unable to correctly value a currency. Why not compare the US to Europe using the market values of the currencies? If you do that, then you realize Mississippi is poorer than any European country. You also realize that all of the US is poorer than several European countries.
- lkrubner 17y agotptaceck writes: "But a 44-year-old schoolteacher might not care about those things." That is the problem with PPP - it depends on making hundreds of such subjective valuations, all of which defy the actual market value of the currencies of the various countries. Why not simply compare the standard-of-living of 2 countries using the fair market value of the currencies? I think such an honest approach is unpopular in the US because such an approach shows how much the US has declined over the last 40 years, relative to other nations.
- electromagnetic 17y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nominal)_per_capita http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nomin... PPP is a very inaccurate measure of quality of life and cost of living. Countries with a bigger income inequality leads to far higher cost of living and much poorer quality of life. So suggesting that having a high PPP is good when the US on the Gini indices (which measure income inequality) rates a 45 and the EU rates a 31 is seriously screwed up and seriously misleading. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gini_Coefficient_World_Human_Development_Report_2007-2008.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gini_Coefficient_World_Hum... Ignorance goes a long way, and Americans (both through blogs and the American media) repeatedly release BS like this, claiming the US is 'better' than Europe for an endless list of reasons. There was one of these racial BS things posted a few weeks about how Europe was worse off than the US because it doesn't have Wal-Mart. Ironically the UK does have Wal-Mart and it's being beaten by Tesco, and Tesco since 2007 has opened stores in the UK to directly compete with the US. Carrefour is the largest supermarket retailer in the world and far out beats the US in terms of hypermarket square footage. Two of the Big Three Supermarket chains are from Europe (Carrefour and Tesco). France also has a huge established systems of Cooperatives that far pre-date the founding of Wal-Mart and who have had hypermarkets long before Wal-Mart even owned a store overseas. The promotion of these articles repeatedly is showing a very disturbing trend in the US posters on HN. I'm unsure if this is a reflection of the US as a whole or not, but it appears to me to be a strong effort by Americans to say "well it was already worse elsewhere, so it's not so bad here" to the economic recession. I find it worrying.
- toretore 17y agoWal-Mart was also in Germany but they didn't last long for whatever reasons and sold their stores to Aldi or Lidl I think.