3 ms·
S/he says that government jobs would be those that benefit the community. It's not hard to come up with examples of those kinds of jobs - care for the elderly,
by tomp 12y ago
S/he says that government jobs would be those that benefit the community. It's not hard to come up with examples of those kinds of jobs - care for the elderly, cheap & healthy kitchens (like kitchens for the homeless, but for everyone instead), more repair and maintenance of infrastructure or new infrastructure (e.g. before WW2, German's increased employment by building highways throughout the country), culture and art events, recycling, running non-for-profit stores (for many basic items, the margin of the store is much greater than production costs) ...
IMO, that's much less make-work than advertising, sales and similar (basically, jobs that exist because your product is not good enough to sell itself).
- anon4 12y agoBut who would want a human to do those things if a machine can do it better, faster and more efficiently?
- vanderZwan 12y ago"Let the robots do the robotic work, let humans flourish creatively." - Matthew Taylor https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cDQosiH4VAc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cDQosiH4VAc
- vanderZwan 12y agoThese are also all examples of where adding a layer of bureaucracy to get paid ruins it. From what my parents (both GPs) told me, in the Netherlands we used to have a lot of volunteers helping out family members who needed extra support, and who simply got a fixed amount of extra money per month, no hassle. This had the extra benefit that it let nurses and doctors focus on the more difficult problems that they specifically were trained for. Then the government decided things had to be more fair (we're talking early eighties), so people suddenly had to fill in forms defining exactly how many hours they spent on helping out family to get the amount of money they deserve. Or something like that. The point was that there was this new layer of bureaucratic administration. It was a disaster, and within a few years they rolled it back. By then however, a lot of volunteers had simply given up and stopped helping, and they did not come back. And in the last decade we made the same mistake all over again. What's especially important to note was that under the new rules, people on average would have been paid more for their help - the old compensation was not nearly enough to cover the time and costs of the volunteers. And yet we ended up with less volunteers. Almost all of the examples you mentioned are things people do for other reasons than the money; any monetary compensation should be more of a hassle-free symbolic gesture of appreciation, or it ruins the whole intrinsic motivation. People are irrational like that, and we need to respect that if we want to make this work.
- michaelt 12y agoI've done some voluntary work; sometimes one gets assigned to do work that could be automated at fairly trivial expense. For example, I've been asked to: * Fold letters, put them into envelopes, and manually address the envelopes. * Deliver centrally-printed documents to people a long way from the printer. * Manually sort paper files into alphabetical order. * Sharpen colouring pencils by hand. If "Job Guarantee" employees are effectively free labour, my fear is they'd end up being assigned to do jobs that would only cost a few hundred dollars to automate out of existence. It's my personal experience that doing such jobs manually is pretty unsatisfying (and economically inefficient to boot).
- JetSpiegel 12y agoNo, says the entrepreneur, having the government fix the roads stifles innovation and impedes the god-given right of some megacorp profiting.They should hire a company that in turn will hire the same people who would do the job, except with lower job security and cheaper wages. And people wonder why the public always gets the short end of the stick.
- dllthomas 12y agoThere is a difference between, on the one hand, needing something done and hiring people to do it; and on the other needing to employ people and finding things for them to do.