3 ms·
> Switzerland, Germany, and Singapore all have mostly-private competition-driven systems (more private than the American model, even) I'd call them "social".
by jjoonathan 12y ago
> Switzerland, Germany, and Singapore all have mostly-private competition-driven systems (more private than the American model, even)
I'd call them "social".
They're all two-tier systems. The basic tier is heavily regulated and meets my definition of social: government dictates terms, price, profit margins, and provides funding such that everyone is guaranteed to be able to afford it. It's no more private than your typical govrnment contractor. The supplementary tier is private in name and practice. I agree that this is the best arrangement and I suspect we mean the same thing and are just defining "social" differently.
http://www.commonwealthfund.org/~/media/Files/Publications/Fund%20Report/2011/Nov/1562_Squires_Intl_Profiles_2011_11_10.pdf http://www.commonwealthfund.org/~/media/Files/Publications/F...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_Singapore http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_Singapore
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_Switzerland http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_Switzerland
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_in_Germany http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_in_Germany
> The way I see it, there are two features that really distinguish the American system structurally. First, there's the state-by-state laws and regulations, resulting in effectively 51 different legal regimes.
Agreed. This is a huge problem that needs to be fixed by regulating at least the bottom tier of health care provision at the federal level.
> Second, American insurance is provided primarily through employers
Employer-provided insurance does have a very strong purpose in the free market that adds value vs individual insurance: it dramatically decreases the risk of the bandwagon effect (people with need X pile on to policies that favor need X and sink them). Put differently, it chops off the long tail of P(claim rate in insured population deviates significantly from that of national population). Risk=money, so employer-provided care actually does decrease the cost of providing health insurance. It also increases the effective bargaining power of employees by allowing them to act as a bloc and making it economically viable to actually analyze and compare the nuts-and-bolts of a large number of alternative plans.
Of course, there are other ways to achieve the same thing, but they're all "social": the government can dictate terms for the bottom tier of care (so all insurance plans look the same to someone maximizing personal utility of an individual plan) or the government can outright provide the insurance (no choice = no bandwagon effect).
I agree that the freedom-reducing effects of employer-provided care are decidedly un-American, but I contend that they occur as a direct result of allowing insurance companies the freedom to set different terms in the basic tier of their individual plans.
- beat 12y agoAh, but look at the results! If you accept my contention that the primary distinguishing feature of the American system is the employer involvement, and the demonstrable facts that a: American health care is twice as expensive as the rest of the civilized world, and b: America fails to cover 15% of the population... well, then it seems that employer-based insurance is a significant contributor to the high cost and coverage gaps. So if the purpose in the free market is to add value, it's pretty much a dismal failure. The thing is, though, that employer-based insurance wasn't there for some dream of free market efficiency. Rather, it's a legacy from mid-20th century labor negotiation. Back when insurance was largely nonexistent, labor unions negotiated for it as a benefit, and it became widely accepted practice. This, along with commie-phobia, kept America from adopting a more socialist model. Today, it's a political problem, because unions are actually against eliminating employer-based insurance, as it's a powerful negotiating tool for them. So it's hard for Democrats to attack it.
- jjoonathan 12y ago> well, then it seems that employer-based insurance is a significant contributor to the high cost That conclusion would follow only if employer-based insurance were the only plausible explanation we had to explain the increased cost. Off the top of my head, here are a few alternatives: 1. Pharma lobby has neutered efforts to centralize bargaining for drug purchases for private insurance companies (what is the bargaining power of BCBS Wyoming vs the NHS? Nothing.) 2. Doctor's guild has created an artificial scarcity of doctors by squeezing the training pipeline. 3. Differences in entry-level health plans prevent price competition because the valuation process is too difficult for consumers (allowing insurance companies to differentiate based on ads and such). > So if the purpose in the free market is to add value, it's pretty much a dismal failure. No kidding. Sometimes it works miracles, sometimes it falls flat on its face. Here it has fallen flat on its face. Repeatedly. And we keep throwing money at it hoping it will fix itself :/ > employer-based insurance wasn't there for some dream of free market efficiency. Rather, it's a legacy from mid-20th century labor negotiation. That's the narrative they taught it a health care economics class I took. I don't buy it. Say what you will about the market, but it does not hesitate to tear down economic structures that have outlasted their utility. In particular, if you think that individual insurance plans are more expensive due to cultural legacy rather than due to economics, I invite you to create your own insurance company and undercut the incumbents ;) > Today, it's a political problem Yup. The only real question is how long the circus will continue. ACA was a step in the right direction, but it doesn't go far enough. Time will tell. My fear is that stopgap solution is the enemy of the good solution.