4 ms·
This is where I really prefer the European model[1] - you heat the whole house with hot water. You make hot water with cheap natural gas. If you're lucky enough
by Swizec 12y ago
This is where I really prefer the European model[1] - you heat the whole house with hot water. You make hot water with cheap natural gas. If you're lucky enough, you can even use geothermal.
Then you use insulation. This especially is something that feels nobody in the US has heard of. At least in California.
As a result, your radiators are turned down to 2 out of 10 all day (heating turns off automatically overnight), and you have to sometimes open a window when it's -13C outside so you don't sweat.
Now I don't know how much people spend on heating when they live in a house house, but my apartment's heating bill this winter was about 30 euro a month[2] and I had to keep all my radiators turned off because the one in the bathroom couldn't be regulated. So that alone was enough to heat everything to extremely comfortable levels.
tl;dr don't heat with air, insulate your fucking house, and install modern windows
[1] Could just be where I'm from, but it seems fairly common in Europe and not at all something I've seen in the US
[2] I think my gramps spends about 2k euro in October to pay for natural gas that heats his house until some time in April. So about 300/month for a ~10 bedroom house because he's got a house that's way too big.
- adestefan 12y agoThis is common in the Northeast and Midwest. Also, if you're in an apartment your place might be so hot because you have a neighbor that has cranked the heat. I used to be able to keep the heat off in a place I lived at because the person that lived below me had their place like a sauna.
- vacri 12y agoCrappy insulation is the norm here in Australia as well, which is more of a problem down south where it gets cold in winter. I used to work with a Scot who highlighted the issue, saying that in a Scottish house, the insulation was good enough that you could basically heat a room with a candle. I once asked him if there were any wooden houses in Scotland, he replied "Yes, we keep our lawnmowers in them".
- Swizec 12y ago> I once asked him if there were any wooden houses in Scotland, he replied "Yes, we keep our lawnmowers in them". Austro-hungarian empire outlawed wooden houses in the early 19th century. Hence we still don't have any, and if you live in a wooden house[1], you are considered to not have been able to afford a proper house and thus looked down upon. [1] becoming common with drywall construction methods. Particularly because it's cheap and fast.
- pjc50 12y agoThere's another historical difference between Scotland and the US here: the US has a near-unlimited supply of wood, while Scotland was mostly bare of trees by the 18th century. Much cheaper to build walls from local stone and save the imported wood for the floors and roofs.
- yxhuvud 12y agoWhat is wrong with wooden houses? It is quite possible to apply insulation to those as well as it is to any other house.
- legohead 12y agoits done that way in Russia as well, at least in the city. the downside is they have to turn off the hot water occasionally to do cleaning, which means no hot water for 1-3 days. in village homes they use pechkas [1]. a giant radiant heater that uses firewood and sits in the middle of the home. most are adapted so that you can use them to cook too. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_oven https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_oven
- x0x0 12y agoIn moscow, they do this in what is (nominally) summer for almost 2 weeks. I thought the water would be chilly, but if I took brisk showers I'd be ok. The first time I tried I nearly gave myself hypothermia -- no exaggeration, I was under a blanket unable to stop shaking for 10 minutes -- and figured out why I saw kettles in people's bathrooms when I was a guest in their apartments. Thank god for the gym which was in a different area of the city.
- curun1r 12y ago> Then you use insulation. This especially is something that feels nobody in the US has heard of. At least in California. In defense of Californians, most of us rarely, if ever, turn on a heater and most homes here don't have AC. Our heating and cooling costs are a small fraction of those of you who live in places that have seasons.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> > Then you use insulation. This especially is something that feels nobody in the US has heard of. At least in California. There's lots of poorly insulated homes in California, either because they are old or cheaply-made, or because they are in places that have milder weather where it is less necessary. But there are also lots of well-insulated homes in California. > In defense of Californians, most of us rarely, if ever, turn on a heater and most homes here don't have AC. Our heating and cooling costs are a small fraction of those of you who live in places that have seasons. As a Central Valley resident, I think you may be falsely generalizing from "the Bay Area" to "California". Even cheap homes in the Valley usually have AC, even if its not central AC.
- _delirium 12y agoI don't think it's only the Bay Area. I've lived in parts of California that between them add up to about 70% of California's population, and not one of them had A/C prevalent, from San Bernardino County to Santa Cruz County.
- x0x0 12y agoMy 2 bed apartment, with both people working from home pretty regularly, and floor-to-ceiling windows on one side, costs < $30/mo for electric + gas except for 2-3 months in the winter, when it rises to $60 or so. Though we have no tv and no a/c. (last bill: 5.8 kWh/day) Given those costs, it's very difficult to get a return on better insulation or insulated windows.
- dredmorbius 12y ago"most homes here don't have AC." That really depends on where in the state you are. Coastal cities, generally, more so. Inland, even within the SF Bay Area or Los Angeles, you'll find a lot of AC, and in the Central Valley it's a huge determinant of load and peak load.
- maxerickson 12y agoForced air heat is a lot more common in the U.S. because we are further along on adopting air conditioning. If you put in ducts for AC, it's cheaper to use those to distribute heat. Upscale construction does seem to be adding radiant floor heat. Houses are generally pretty under-insulated though.
- dirkf 12y agoAir is a pretty bad transport agent for heat compared to water. To heat a house (and especially poorly insulated ones) the air either has to be rather hot or flow pretty fast. The former is not very comfortable because of the large temperature gradients and it can cause a 'scorched dust' smell. The latter is also not very comfortable when you're in the flow path, it's noisy and the increased flow of air in the room means more heat is escaping to outside. It can work for well insulated and airtight houses but I'm not a fan (pun not intended) because you're tying two different functions (heating and ventilation) together.
- _delirium 12y ago> You make hot water with cheap natural gas. If you're lucky enough, you can even use geothermal. In Denmark it's getting pretty common to produce it via trash incinerators. They produce a kind of heat that is apparently that not great for electricity generation, but pretty good for district-heat production. So much so that the price of unsorted municipal garbage in both Denmark and Sweden has risen in the past few years, because it has become a valuable energy source.
- dredmorbius 12y agoCHP (combined heat and power) or district heating, typically, though I'm not sure which applies in your case. Most areas which have implemented a trash-to-energy program pretty soon run out of high-grade suitable trash and resort to imports. Entropy always wins.
- peeters 12y ago> you heat the whole house with hot water As others have said, try cooling a house with rads. It's not like North America is oblivious to radiators; they were very much a standard way of heating houses before the popularity of AC made forced air a much more logical choice. > Then you use insulation. This especially is something that feels nobody in the US has heard of. At least in California. If you only know about the completely unrepresentative California, why expose your ignorance by projecting to all of the U.S.? And further, why bother calling it "the European model"? Obviously the way houses are built, insulated, and heated in a country like England or Norway is going to differ wildly from how it's done in say, Greece. Even within California the climate differs so much that there are 4-5 different building codes for insulation. But in general, the minimum code for insulation in California is around half that of states with colder climates (e.g. R30 for ceiling in California, R50 for Wisconsin).
- Swizec 12y ago> And further, why bother calling it "the European model"? Because I've seen radiators and decent insulation in literally every house I've ever been in anywhere in Europe. Warm places like Greece and Portugal included. Differences are mostly attributable to the age of a house rather than its location. But arguably old stone houses (200+ years) in hot places have the best insulation in that they are simply built with 1m+ thick walls and super tiny windows. Insulation. It works. For both hot and cold. Granted, the moderner your building and the thinner walls and more cement it uses, the likelier you are to need AC in summer. In old buildings you get enough cooling by just airing the house overnight and keeping everything closed during the day ... unless of course you have a big computer in your room. Then you're screwed.
- carlob 12y ago> As others have said, try cooling a house with rads. It's not like North America is oblivious to radiators; they were very much a standard way of heating houses before the popularity of AC made forced air a much more logical choice. I've always found the popularity of AC in the US bizarre, every single European who've traveled to the US in the summer and had to spend extensive time inside complained about the cold and quickly switched to long sleeves and trousers.