5 ms·
The Crisis in American Walking (2012)
- brandonmenc 12y agoWalking burns something like a measly 100 calories per mile. We could double our walking and still not dent obesity. We have a crisis that involves lack of real exercise (which walking, is not) and excessive caloric intake.
- bilbo0s 12y agoI think that depends on the grade. In more hilly terrains... I think walking might burn more. I remember reading a LOOONG time ago, that a person will burn a lot more if their metro stop is Lamarck-Caulaincourt than they will if their metro stop is Odeon. So I could see walking around ... say ... Duke University probably burning a lot more than walking around Rice University. And walking around the University of Wisconsin at Madison all day will be a workout unto itself most likely. I don't think it is just... if you're walking you are not exercising. I think it really depends where you are walking at. Maybe even depends on if you have a backpack or heavy side bag as well. I'm not sure you can make a hard and fast rule.
- philwelch 12y ago1000 calories per week would make a difference. If you lived 1 mile from work you'd burn that from your commute alone.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- beachstartup 12y agoin a walking vs. driving lifestyle, you don't just double your walking, you more than likely 10X your walking. 20X on an exceptionally busy day. i live in LA but my 'moves' app tells me that when traveling to walking cities, on a busy day i burn 600+ calories walking. at home it's around 100. sometimes less. this is quantified via GPS and an understanding of human biology. if you choose not to believe this, you're picking another fight entirely. a delta of 500 calories a day combined with eating just a little less, or of healthier foods is rapid weight loss. it's why people can easily lose weight on a vacation to europe or asia.
- brandonmenc 12y agoI do believe this. What I don't believe is that the average American will ever have time to walk 10x more than they currently do, or that the average obese American is eating only in excess of 500 calories a day. My original comment was harsher than it needed to be. I believe our exercise and obesity problem requires a lot more than just ditching cars to fix. Especially when walking is not a convenient mode of travel for people living outside the largest cities. All things being equal, yes, more walking is better.
- smacktoward 12y ago> Especially when walking is not a convenient mode of travel for people living outside the largest cities. This part is a chicken-and-egg problem, though: we design sprawled-out, unwalkable communities because everybody has cars; everybody has cars because they live in sprawled-out, unwalkable communities.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- zachrose 12y agoMaybe we should just let the cars drive themselves and have a treadmill inside the car. "It feels like you're running at an incredible rate, Harry."
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoAn excess of 500 calories per day would lead to a weight gain of roughly 50 pounds per year. That could lead to obesity in less than a year and morbid obesity in just a few years. Most likely the average obese American is eating an excess of substantially less than 500 calories per day.
- simonebrunozzi 12y agoWrong - walking, or any sort of physical activity, reactivates your metabolism. If you go from 0 to 1 hour of walking per day, your metabolism would burn way more than 100 calories.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoWalking and sprinting and weight training boost metabolism. Doing a lot of jogging actually lowers resting metabolic rate because the body adaptively conserves energy when confronted with such stress. After a few weeks of a daily jogging habit you're in total burning barely more than you were when sedentary. This is why you see so many people pounding away on gym treadmills month after month and still looking squishy.
- dguaraglia 12y agoAny sort of physical activity is better than nothing. I gained some weight in the first month and a half after moving to the San Francisco (blame startup lunch and having no time to look for of a gym for that.) All I needed to adjust to drop the extra pounds was walk home every night. It's a longish walk (about 45 minutes) without a terrible difficulty level (not going through any of the hilliest areas), and yet that was more than enough to keep me fit and happy. Sure, walking alone won't make you gain a lot of muscle or incredibly performant in aerobic exercise, but it's definitely way better than just sitting on your ass all day and driving/shuttling home every day.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y ago> a measly 100 calories per mile Five miles a day of walking is something everybody can do pretty easily. What the heck is measly about 500 calories a day when people eat something like 2500 calories?
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoIt takes hours to walk 5 miles. Walking speed is something like 2 mph; fast walking is 3 mph. No way can I spend 2 hours walking every day. Much rather be biking :)
- WalterBright 12y agoI tried reading while walking. Didn't work out very well, I gave that up before something awful happened.
- Evgeny 12y agoI switched to audiobooks almost exclusively recently. Very compatible with walking and running, and even mild outside exercise such as pullups.
- WalterBright 12y agoI haven't done that out of concern of being unaware of things coming up behind me, like bicycles and cars. What I do do is "front load" my head with the context of a problem that's vexing me, and then while running think about it. I'm often able to come up with a solution that way. I also "write" articles while running, and then just tap them out when I get back.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y ago3.8 MPH is a totally reasonable pace to expect from a healthy adult. That's apparently what I clock walking to work. I think 70 minutes of walking every day at 3.8 MPH is totally reasonable and doable. Two 35 minute walks every day. It's best to make this a part of your commute. I have got shredded doing little more than an hour of daily walking. Don't tell me walking doesn't burn calories.
- jmadsen 12y agoyes, but you don't understand how many miles the avg. person walks in a day who lives in an pedestrian/public transport friendly area. It is far, far more than you think.
- yoodenvranx 12y agoNeed a motivation to go out and walk around? Play Ingress! It's a gps based mix of capture-the-flag and geocaching with a few million players worldwide.
- jessedhillon 12y agoAlso a great tip if you find yourself shortchanging your dogs on their walks.
- wyager 12y agoIt's also a clever way for Google to get people to improve their pedestrian directions (and possibly their WiFi AP location database) for free. Seriously, I was really impressed when I realized that they had gamified collecting GPS data.
- dublinben 12y agoIs it still impossible to get an invite? I requested one as soon as it was announced, and haven't received it yet.
- batiudrami 12y agoGeocaching is another good smartphone-GPS hobby.
- sien 12y agoAustralia is doing well on the walking scales but is a fat country. Australia is #6 on the obesity rank: http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/stats/Health/Obesity http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/stats/Health/Obesit... Pehaps it's all the Pie floaters. Or the quality craft beer. Or the fantastic cheese like King Island Brie. BRB.
- mkl 12y agoOnly if you ignore less populous countries (and that data is quite out of date too). In a more complete and more recent list [1], Australia is 44th! A UN report from last year [2] only has data from 2008 as well, so it seems difficult to make an up-to-date comparison. In [3] there's a 2007 list including overweight as well as obese. Australia is 21st. [1] https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2228rank.html https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/... [2] http://www.fao.org/docrep/018/i3300e/i3300e.pdf http://www.fao.org/docrep/018/i3300e/i3300e.pdf [3] http://www.forbes.com/2007/02/07/worlds-fattest-countries-forbeslife-cx_ls_0208worldfat.html http://www.forbes.com/2007/02/07/worlds-fattest-countries-fo...
- cleversoap 12y agoI'm not even kidding, we are probably just as lazy except it manifests as "I can't be arsed driving" so we take the simplest route and walk for short distances.
- cletus 12y agoI believe that a terrible way to end up is to be essentially infirm in old age or even middle age. The way to avoid this is start healthy habits early. I can't drive because of an eye condition. Honestly, this has been a bane of my existence for most of my (adult) life. In Australia a non-car lifestyle is possible but very limiting. You have to pick and choose where you live and figure out how to get to and from places. In Europe the situation is much better overall. In London you don't need a car but it's still awkward if you need to go home after midnight. The Tube stops. Cabs are crazy expensive. The night bus is a freak show. Going out of London is a problem and expensive. Switzerland on the other hand was (mostly) amazing from a walker's perspective. Living in a rural town sans car might be problematic but you can get pretty much anywhere in the country by clean, reliable trains. I lived in Zurich and got to all sorts of places are Lake Zurich and Lake Luzern for hiking and the like. I now live in New York City. I have visited a number of parts of the US. In most of the US you are utterly dependent on the automobile in a way that residents of other industrialized nations probably can't quite comprehend. I've stayed with friends in the Midwest who parked their car 8 feet from the front door of the their condo, drove to work where their car was pretty close to the office and often got food through drive throughs. They'd probably walk less than 500 yards a day. Most places in the US aren't just pro-automobile, they're anti-pedestrian and anti-cyclist. Things like: - Limited to no public transport - Public transport that becomes unusable at certain hours - Light changes at intersections that may stop a pedestrian for as much as 5 minutes - Allowing cars to turn right at red lights. This is perhaps the most anti-pedestrian/cyclist law of all. The number of times I've been almost wiped out in this situation is insane. - Low density housing. Even some more pedestrian-friendly places like San Francisco still kinda suck (but SF is a lot better than anywhere else in the Bay Area). NYC is a bit of a pedestrian mecca. As someone who can't drive, I've never quite had the independence and freedom I have right now by living in NYC. Reasons include: - Pedestrian-friendly light changes (you never have to wait more than about 30-45 seconds for a light change) - Subway that runs 24x7 and frequently - Cheap cabs - No turning right at red lights. Some visitors to NYC don't realize this is illegal in the five boroughs. So now I live walking distance to work. The downside is that being able to do so is expensive as a single person and the domain of the wealthy for those with more than 1-2 kids. The thing that really boggles my mind is how blase we as a society are to the 30,000+ people who die every year in the US in motor vehicle accidents [1]. This is the same number of fatalities as 10 9/11 attacks every year. The cult of the automobile simply defies reason. There are a couple of points worth making about walking as exercise: 1. Some is far, far better than none. You need some exercise simply for proper functioning of your body; and 2. Walking, and exercise in general, is not the primary solution to obesity. According to a calculator, a 200 lb man burns 120 calories by walking 1 mile in 20 minutes. Not a brisk pace at all. A 12oz can of soda has ~140 calories in it. Now the relationship between calorific intake and weight gain or loss is complex and somewhat controversial in some circles but, generally speaking, if you consume more calories than you burn you will tend to gain weight and if you consume less than you burn you will tend to lose weight. The body makes some effort to maintain homeostasis so minor changes may result in no change at all. Exercise certainly helps but diet tends to be the far bigger problem. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motor_vehicle_deaths_in_U.S._by_year http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motor_vehicle_deaths_in...
- sambolling 12y ago"average 3 foot-per-second walking speed," That's painfully slow.
- teekert 12y agoI was once at a conference in Galveston, Texas. I and some other scientists, mostly from Europe got hungry at 23:00 or so. We walked to the nearby Danny's or Wendy's but it was closed. When we walked away we saw that the drive through was open so we walked in. Strangely, nobody answered at the pole where you talk to the person. Then a car came up, we stepped aside, and someone started talking! So we walked to the car and said, hey that's nice, we thought nobody was there?... And the guy went nuts over that we were trying to steal his order or something... Wow... we stepped back a bit and when he drove on we followed him to the window where we, just as the car left, saw a woman screaming at us that "there is a camera on you!!!" While she smashed the window shut we tried to tell her: "But we have money we just want to eat?" It was one of the strangest experiences in my life. Later on I realized it was quite a bit threatening as well. Later we heard from another colleague that he was questioned by police in a not-so-friendly way about what he was doing (he was walking along the road to check out the beach.) During the trip I took after the conference I saw a drive-through ATM and a drive-through pharmacy. And I spoke to a guy who had been to a drive through funeral! I guess it explains a bit why Google Now doesn't work for me (here in the Netherlands), it keeps pushing me into either public transport or my car while almost all traveling I do is combination of biking, walking and public transport. I once had a student from Bulgaria, for her it was normal to walk to school for more than an hour. That would be considered strange here as well although biking for an hour to school is certainly not unheard of (for kids).
- shmerl 12y agoIt's not even funny, how it reminds me this story by Ray Bradbury - "The Pedestrian": * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pedestrian https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pedestrian * http://www.unz.org/Pub/Reporter-1951aug07-00039 http://www.unz.org/Pub/Reporter-1951aug07-00039
- DanBC 12y ago> During the trip I took after the conference I saw a drive-through ATM and a drive-through pharmacy. The drive through alcohol shops and the drive through mail-boxes where the things I thought were funny. Also, the Outlets at Gilroy, Califoria, have a major road going through the middle. There are only 2 crossing places on that road. And people do think you're weird if you're walking between them. https://www.google.co.uk/maps/@37.0198782,-121.5659382,2724m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.co.uk/maps/@37.0198782,-121.5659382,2724m...
- markitexture 12y agoWalking in Phoenix, AZ is uncommon simply because of massive sunburn exposure...
- markitexture 12y agoIn light of non-existent public transportation infrastructure in most of the USA, it's sad after a car/bike that walking is not only the single alternative, but also looked at with suspicion... Prague, Czech Republic has amazing public transportation, with support 24 hours a day on trolleys and buses. And taxis are inexpensive too. Wow, I'm lucky! ;-)
- matthewmcg 12y agoOur dependence on the automobile takes one solution (human powered mobility) and turns it into two problems (lack of exercise and pollution).
- JustinBlaird 12y agoAuthor claims "average 3 foot-per-second walking speed" - It's almost impossible to walk that slow unless you're injured.