4 ms·
Net neutrality is less of a hot topic in the wireless world compared to wired. In wired world, the carriers were granted monopoly to dig the trenches, and the
by prostoalex 12y ago
Net neutrality is less of a hot topic in the wireless world compared to wired.
In wired world, the carriers were granted monopoly to dig the trenches, and the fact that they now abuse that monopoly without giving access to other players is what riles people.
Wireless world is fairly fragmented - carriers are separate from equipment companies, which are separate from tower operators. Anybody can buy up some equipment and tower space and just start offering mobile voice+broadband. Or start on MVNO to piggyback existing infrastructure and expand from there.
- twistedpair 12y ago> Net neutrality is less of a hot topic in the wireless world compared to wired. Really? Unless you can participate in the multi-billion dollar spectrum auction, you can't use any of those towers or disparate device providers. The right to use a large block of spectrum in a given geographic area is a monopoly of sorts for that carrier. Given the capital and scale needed to enter the market, it's no wonder we have so few wireless carriers to choose from.
- superuser2 12y agoIt would be very expensive for me to start a chip fabrication plant, but that doesn't make the industry a monopoly. Just one that requires a lot of capital to enter.
- ZenoArrow 12y agoCapital that you'll never get as the market is far too risky for any sane investor, and far too much money for an individual to have spare. Semiconductor manufacture isn't a monopoly now as there's more than one player, but you're fooling yourself if you believe it's something more than an oligarchy.
- prostoalex 12y agoYou mean oligopoly?
- ZenoArrow 12y agoYes.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Net neutrality is less of a hot topic in the wireless world compared to wired. That's actually not all that true. While both the 2010 Open Internet Order and the more recent NPRM for a new version have provided looser rules for mobile broadband, (fixed wireless has the same rules as fixed wired broadband), its been on the FCC radar, and a number of big players pushing for more full neutrality than the current NPRM offers for fixed broadband have also been advocating for the same treatment for mobile broadband as fixed rather than two separate models. > In wired world, the carriers were granted monopoly to dig the trenches, and the fact that they now abuse that monopoly without giving access to other players is what riles people. In the wireless world, companies rely on exclusive monopoly licenses to spectrum, so its an ongoing -- not merely historical -- monopoly on which they rely.
- prostoalex 12y agoGood point on spectrum, but it's artificial scarcity set by the government policy (or lack thereof).
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Good point on spectrum, but it's artificial scarcity set by the government policy No, its not. The particular mechanism for managing scarcity may be a policy choice, but the scarcity is pretty fundamental.
- opendais 12y agoThe scarcity isn't artificial. High powered broadcasts on the same chunk of spectrum directly interfere with each other. That is why you can't have two FM radio stations on 106.7.
- jjoonathan 12y ago> High powered broadcasts... FM radio stations on 106.7 are not even close to comparable. Cellphone towers do not use frequencies and powers that travel nearly as far as those employed by radio stations. >The scarcity isn't artificial. Nope, it's artificial. The next generation of base stations performs beamforming for physics-based channel sharing in addition to CDMA ("algorithm-based" channel sharing). Beamforming effectively allows you to employ a sizable number of "virtual antennas", each aimed separately at individual receivers. With multiple base stations it's an even more effective strategy because you can create signals that constructively interfere at a point rather than along a line. Everyone gets their own spatially-localized signal and can transmit their own spatially-localized signal because the same trick works in reverse for reception. So no, there isn't fundamental spectrum scarcity. Perhaps there are too few beamforming base stations installed, but that's a problem to be solved through investment in new technology, not by allowing carriers to impose business models that de-commoditize bandwidth.
- fleitz 12y agoTower space yes, frequency no.
- baddox 12y agoIsn't the regulation pretty similar in the wireless world? Wired providers get monopolies to dig trenches, but don't wireless providers get monopolies (or oligopolies) to use certain parts of the wireless spectrum? I'm pretty sure anybody can't just buy equipment and start broadcasting.
- Istof 12y agoIt is regulated by the FCC and some frequencies can be used by anybody in the US (but they might not be suitable for a cellphone company) http://transition.fcc.gov/oet/spectrum/table/fcctable.pdf http://transition.fcc.gov/oet/spectrum/table/fcctable.pdf ...
- wpietri 12y ago> Anybody can buy up some equipment and tower space and just start offering mobile voice+broadband. That's surprising to me. How can the FCC charging billions for mobile spectrum licences? [1] It would seem to me that there are government-granted monopolies for both wired and wireless. [1] http://www.networkworld.com/article/2307154/network-security/fcc-s-wireless-spectrum-auction-fetches--14-billion.html http://www.networkworld.com/article/2307154/network-security...