3 ms·
It should be factored in. But at the same time, screaming about the badness makes that worse. Refuse to be terrorized.
by dllthomas 12y ago
It should be factored in. But at the same time, screaming about the badness makes that worse. Refuse to be terrorized.
- rayiner 12y agoTelling people how they should feel about other peoples' deaths is generally not going to get you anywhere. People feel what they feel.
- dllthomas 12y agoPeople feel radically different things depending on framing and perspective. I agree that there is limited benefit to yelling "you should feel X," but I also think that everyone yelling "you should feel scared" has contributed to the problem.
- AnimalMuppet 12y agoOK, but making irrational policy based on how people feel leads to bad policy. Let people feel what they feel. But don't make long-term policy based on peoples' emotional reactions to events.
- dllthomas 12y agoI actually disagree, perhaps subtly. Emotional reactions are still reactions, are still a thing that exists in reality, and should be appropriately weighted. But emotional reaction should be weighted in terms of considering it as a consequence, and emotions should be consulted in determining which consequences we (collectively) care about. This is distinct from responding in the short term to a demand for vengeance simply because that's how people feel now (but not distinct from reacting with vengeance if the population will long-term approve of having done so, balancing emotional consequences with others).