2 ms·
Why wait for Wayland instead of running KDE on X on Android?
by sp332 12y ago
Why wait for Wayland instead of running KDE on X on Android?
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI take it you have run KDE on X on Android on a small memory foot print ARM system? I tried something similar on the Pandaboard (OMAP4, 1GB, VRX) and it was unusable but if you've got a system or perhaps a configuration that makes this work it would be useful for development.
- sp332 12y agoNope, just wondering why Wayland would be any less painful.
- yellowapple 12y agoWayland cuts out a lot of the legacy cruft that X11 has accumulated over the decades, and is inherently much simpler; resource overhead is expected to be much lower on Wayland-based systems. It might not be less painful in terms of getting it to work, but it would be less painful in terms of getting it to work in a resource-constrained system like an ARM-powered smartphone.
- kefka 12y agoThe legacy cruft is easily served by not loading the respective crufty modules. And frankly, I like Xserver support across a variety of devices.
- yellowapple 12y agoThe problem is that the legacy cruft is intertwined in the very architecture of X11 itself. That's what Wayland is intended to correct; it's a redesign to better accommodate things like compositors while not being held back by the need to explicitly support 80's-era graphical terminals and such (though similar functionality should still be possible, since Wayland is - IIRC - network-transparent).
- sp332 12y agoWayland is not network transparent. They say it's "out of scope". You'll have to use something like RDP. http://wayland.freedesktop.org/faq.html#heading_toc_j_8 http://wayland.freedesktop.org/faq.html#heading_toc_j_8
- zanny 12y agoThe X network transparency is already hugely inefficient compared to RDP or VNC. I also really hope when Dalaa 1.0 comes out (soon, please?) someone starts an initiative to make first class networked display / video streaming a reality on it. You don't really need a new protocol, just vnc-dalaa or rdp-dalaa rather than pixel buffer updates. See how Steam / Nvidia streaming works, or Miracast, except substitute hardware accelerated h264 with opencl accelerated Dalaa for a nice open standard.
- sp332 12y agoThe issue for me is that I'll need a working video driver and framebuffer on the remote device, whereas with X I only need to set those up on the viewing end. Theoretically, someone could make a Wayland server that didn't render locally, but no one has made one of those yet.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoNot a question of pain, more a question of performance. The current X server on Android on ARM is really really really slow. The hope is that Wayland will be more performant due to its design choices.