3 ms·
Well, had it been my choice between a nuclear war where 90%-95% of the population of the UK would have died in optimistic scenarios and surrendering to the Sovi
by arethuza 12y ago
Well, had it been my choice between a nuclear war where 90%-95% of the population of the UK would have died in optimistic scenarios and surrendering to the Soviets (and yes, I am fully aware of how badly they treated people in their own country and the countries they controlled) I know which one I would have chosen.
- mseebach 12y agoBut that wasn't what the choice was. It was between maintaining the capability of such a nuclear war to deter aggression, and not maintaining it and surely having been invaded by the Soviets. For the madness that MAD was, for all intents and purposes, it actually worked.
- arethuza 12y agoThat pretty much would have been the choice if, for whatever reason, a shooting war had started - which it nearly did on a number of occasions. Of course, deterrence based on MAD is the least worst idea - but once shooting actually started, what is the rational thing to do?
- mseebach 12y agoThat's the point of deterrence. It didn't start. The moral thing to do if it started would have been to not fire the missiles. But any leak or hint of such an intent would have had disastrous effect on the deterrent, and is thus an extremely dangerous idea for any leader to actually entertain. One can hope that leaders would have privately decided against and that the letters of last resort were sealed and destroyed for that reason.