3 ms·
>I suspect, but cannot prove, the wikipedia number is more likely to be correct. The Wikipedia number is not correct, because even a single blast has long term
by TheOtherHobbes 12y ago
>I suspect, but cannot prove, the wikipedia number is more likely to be correct.
The Wikipedia number is not correct, because even a single blast has long term consequences, and in a full scale war, the consequences are more significant than the initial damage.
Even if the blast was just one a of a handful, survivors would have to contend with fallout from other detonations, followed by nuclear winter, followed by years of famine, mutation, cancer, and other diseases.
In a full scale war, nukes are targeted at nuke power plants, so there would be even more fallout - enough to sterilise many parts of the US.
Initial casualties would be a small percentage of the eventual total.
Even a limited exchange in a distant part of the world would have global consequences. See e.g.
http://phys.org/news/2013-12-nuclear-war-civilization-famine.html http://phys.org/news/2013-12-nuclear-war-civilization-famine...
- lotharbot 12y ago> "in a full scale war, the consequences are more significant" The specific point being discussed was a local disaster -- a 9 megaton bomb which was damaged by somebody dropping a tool on it -- not an all-out war scenario. Which is why I responded the way I did. In that scenario, I don't see any realistic case in which the entire state of Arkansas would be "wiped out". Possibly fallout would have rendered a fraction of the state uninhabitable for several weeks, and possibly some long-term effects would render a smaller fraction of the state uninhabitable for much longer, but the whole state "wiped out" is just sloppy journalism.
- acqq 12y agoNo, see the answer from aeturnum: use the online calculator, enable falout. You'll have to zoom out the map: the area of the effects is approximately as big as the state. http://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/?&kt=9000&lat=34.7464809&lng=-92.2895948&airburst=0&hob_ft=0&ff=50&zm=7 http://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/?&kt=9000&lat=34.7464809&l...
- lotharbot 12y agoI did in fact already run this scenario. The fallout area is large if you set the threshold low enough. But from what I understand, the largest rings do not render the area uninhabitable by any means. Perhaps the smallest inner ring does. Fallout is also generally a short-term effect -- weeks, not decades. Also be aware that fallout from an underground blast (as in a silo) is going to spread much differently from fallout from an airburst.
- acqq 12y agoContrary to what you assume, the fallout increases in the underground burst compared to the burst in the air as the surface is reached see: http://fas.org/nuke/intro/nuke/effects.htm http://fas.org/nuke/intro/nuke/effects.htm
- lotharbot 12y agoI'm not trying to assume. I'm trying to research. I read that page, and several others. From what I understand, the local fallout (ie, within a few mile radius) is much higher in subsurface bursts, but the longer-range fallout is substantially less. Thus, I am unconvinced by the argument that the longer-range fallout would "wipe out" something the size of Arkansas.