5 ms·
My rant including the "little man" was no so much directed at the article in question as it was at the movement in general. But Russels depiction of this hard-w
by mseebach 17y ago
My rant including the "little man" was no so much directed at the article in question as it was at the movement in general. But Russels depiction of this hard-working professional as a victim is condescending. He can provide for his family, but can't in the face of a simple salesman say "no, go away, and if you come back next week I won't be this polite"? This is obviously a contrived example, because the real world don't lend itself well to the point he wants to make.
> the goal of (many) salespeople and advertisers is to make their targets sillier and stupider, and that's seldom in their interests or those of the community / nation / world as a whole.
Obviously there are scammers out there, but the average advertisement/sale caters to the average consumer, and by declaring that the actions of these consumers make them "sillier and stupider" (than what?) and that they don't act in their own interest or "those of the community / nation / world as a whole" is "holier-than-thou".
How do you objectively define the best interest of the "community / nation / world as a whole"? To take a very current example, the current financial crisis is caused in (a large) part by the political system (a democratic president and a republican house -- no-one gets away clean) deciding that is was in the best interest of the nation and its citizens is to lend a lot of money to a lot of people who couldn't really afford it to buy their own home.
- jacquesm 17y ago> This is obviously a contrived example, because the real world don't lend itself well to the point he wants to make. You don't say... I think it is an excellent analogy of the process that goes on between producers, salespeople and consumers. > How do you objectively define the best interest of the "community / nation / world as a whole"? That's a tricky one, but I suspect that the maximum by any definition does not include large amounts of funds spent by people on things that do not benefit them. > caused in (a large) part by the political system (a democratic president and a republican house -- no-one gets away clean) deciding that is was in the best interest of the nation and its citizens is to lend a lot of money to a lot of people who couldn't really afford it to buy their own home. There were many more 'actors' than just a few government officials in the US that together brought about the crisis, equally culpable are the people operating the banks, the people that took on mortgages that they knew up front they would not be able to pay for ('ninja' applicants), foreign banks buying up the debt packages etc. Indeed, no-one gets away clean.
- mseebach 17y ago> I think it is an excellent analogy of the process that goes on between producers, salespeople and consumers. Well, I don't. Care to elaborate? > ...does not include large amounts of funds spent by people on things that do not benefit them. That's circular. How do you define what objectively benefits someone? > There were many more 'actors' than just a few government officials Of course. I singled out the government, because that's an entity we often look to in search for a definition of the common best interest.
- jacquesm 17y agoThe goals of sales people and producers are generally not aligned with the goals of consumers. In an ideal world all consumption would be 'pull'. Consumers would be informed about the available products in a neutral way, would know about the ins and outs of all the products they could choose from and would have an idea of the long-term benefits of the products if purchased. Clearly, we do not live in an ideal world. Most consumption of 'primary needs goods' is still on 'pull' basis, at least it is in most parts of the world. But even there advertising is shaping consumers decisions more and more. Branding and marketing are gaining a bigger foothold than ever before even when it comes to buying everyday needs items such as drinking water, bread, rice, clothing and so on. For other goods 'regular consumption goods and luxury goods' the situation is even more extreme. > That's circular. How do you define what objectively benefits someone? It's not circular, it is recursive ;) But the recursion bottoms out where you run out of funds to buy something that you really need. Most income spent on useless stuff (for instance to feed addictions) goes at the expense of a real need (for instance to feed or clothe children). By having individuals compete with companies that have meanwhile spent upwards of a century honing their skills we are creating a completely uneven battle. Nobody is able to make their decisions about what they need with any degree of impartiality. The best way to describe 'to benefit someone' is to say that their lives have a maximized sense of happiness. So all other things being equal, if you buy the 'wrong' car because a salesman pushed it down your throat somehow then your happiness will not be as high as it would have been had you gone through with what would have been the most rational decision. If you look for a definition of what is in the common best interest I would suggest you look everywhere but to your government, almost by definition it does not have the common best interest at heart. In theory it does, in practice I don't think there is a single government on earth that would be able to make that claim and withstand an investigation into the veracity of that claim. Maybe I'm old and cynical, but where ever I've lived I did not have the feeling the government had my interests in general at heart.
- gjm11 17y agoHe can provide for his family, but can't ... say "no, go away ..."? This is obviously a contrived example: sure, it's a contrived example; mostly the effect of advertising is more subtle than that. This is only a problem for Russell's piece if (1) he's claiming that his example is realistic and/or (2) the more subtle effect is usually in the other direction. I don't think either is true. the average advertisement/sale caters to the average consumer: Very likely. I'm failing to see how you get from there to saying that those advertisers and salespeople aren't trying to make their targets sillier and stupider. Does being an "average consumer" somehow confer immunity to being fooled or manipulated? than what? Than they would have been without the advertising, of course. holier-than-thou: I'm wondering whether you mean by this something different from what I would. To me, calling someone h-t-t means saying that they think too highly of their own virtue; that they're either trying to promote themselves or criticizing other people for faults they have themselves. I don't see that in Russell's piece, nor in the attitude of other later people who dislike advertising. (Nor, in case this is what you mean, does it look to me as if Russell thinks that he himself has especially strong "sales resistance" or that he should be admired for it if so. Though I wouldn't call that "holier-than-thou" in this context even if he did.) How do you objectively define ...: of course I don't, or at any rate I don't claim the ability to know for sure whether any particular action is going to work out well. But if that's a reason for never saying anything of the form "X seems to me not to be in Y's best interests", then I don't see how anyone can ever say anything of that form, and that seems like, well, rather a nuisance. the current financial crisis is caused ...: you're talking about the Community Reinvestment Act, yes? If so, then I'm afraid you have been taken in by propaganda: (1) most subprime loans were not made by lenders subject to the CRA, and (2) CRA loans did not produce a whole lot of foreclosures. See, e.g., http://www.businessweek.com/investing/insights/blog/archives/2008/09/community_reinv.html http://www.businessweek.com/investing/insights/blog/archives... and the other things linked from there.
- mseebach 17y ago> sure, it's a contrived example; mostly the effect of advertising is more subtle than that. This is only a problem for Russell's piece if (1) he's claiming that his example is realistic He may not claim that it's realistic, but on the other hand it's not exactly presented as fiction. My point is that I don't think he'd be able to arrive at the same conclusion without exaggerating like that, because the subtle effects of advertising doesn't have such damaging effect. > (2) the more subtle effect is usually in the other direction. What you're saying is that most people more often than not are influenced to make decisions that are not good for them or their families? I don't agree. Most consumers might make sub-optimal decisions (to the extend that it's even possible to define the optimal decision, which I don't agree it is) some of the time, but the question remains if there's any evidence at all that they'd make better decisions without advertising. > Does being an "average consumer" somehow confer immunity to being fooled or manipulated? No, but empirical evidence suggests that people at large don't systematically make bad decisions. Since the charge against advertising is that it causes that, my conclusion is that the average consumer isn't being fooled or manipulated on any significant scale. > than what? Than they would have been without the advertising, of course. I think advertising on a grand scale sharpens the awareness that there might be a better (for however you define better) solution for a problem you have than the one you're currently using. > h-t-t When someone claims that advertising makes consumers act against their own interest, they necessarily concluded that there is a better choice for the consumer in the given situation that the consumer should have picked over what he did, and that this lapse of reasoning was caused by advertising. I do think that yes, that is thinking "too highly of their own virtue". I don't think anyone has any right to tell me that the good feeling I get from buying expensive brand-name clothes from a fancy store in a fancy location from a staff that "manipulates" me into feeling good about my purchase (case in point, the Ralph Lauren store in Georgetown, DC). I know I can get perfectly functional clothes cheaper other place, but I like the experience. > But if that's a reason for never saying anything of the form "X seems to me not to be in Y's best interests", then I don't see how anyone can ever say anything of that form, and that seems like, well, rather a nuisance. There's nothing wrong with saying that, but there's something wrong with picking a fight on behalf on someone else, saying that. And there's something wrong with legitimising reckless actions by blaming it on advertising. > CRA You may very well be right (even though the business week column isn't exactly unbiased). I don't have my facts sufficiently in order to debate that point.
- Quarrelsome 17y agoHave you done sales? In my experience your "targets" in consumer sales are comprised to two categories: Smart people, where you drop the act and give them the data they want (they probably wont buy unless you do a fine job at NLP or "Liking") and the rest. With "the rest" it is recommended as "best practice" to use the techniques of NLP, Reciprocation, Consistency, Social Proof (the salesman's favourite), Authority, Liking and Scarcity. ALL of these tricks are tricks. They are all ways that make the target more likely to buy the product without improving the product. You can play on someone's emotional weaknesses to make them buy shit. Fact. There is no "they're not being forced to buy". If you know the tricks and they don't you will be able to influence them. Hell, I might even be able sell to you (someone smart) if I could place you in a Consistency trap and you're on a first date with someone you're trying to impress. These are the kind of sales the article is talking about and I completely agree with the writer. They don't generate wealth and they probably don't improve the economy.
- mseebach 17y agoYes, telemarketing. I didn't receive any particular training, but it was clear that the tactic was keep talking, so they'll agree to buy it to get rid of me. Yes, I was the piano salesman from the article. :) Except -- I wasn't pushing a piano at the cost of a family vacation. I was selling a $5 for three issues ($25 off cover) re-subscription to a computer magazine. Experiencing how hard it actually was to push this offer gave me quite a bit of faith in humanity. 5 our of 6 said no and hung up before I got through my scripted pitch. There's a certain sentiment against sales here. But where is that anger when someone is talking about their latest A/B test here? An A/B test is a test to find out which of two alternatives is better to make a visitor do what we want that visitor to do. Since the need for the A/B test, we can conclude that the visitor doesn't take that action be default. Thus, we're doing this design to manipulate the visitor to take an action that's not in his best interest? Because if it was in the his best interest, he should be doing it anyway, without the optimization, right?
- plinkplonk 17y ago"But where is that anger when someone is talking about their latest A/B test here? An A/B test is a test to find out which of two alternatives is better to make a visitor do what we want that visitor to do. Since the need for the A/B test, we can conclude that the visitor doesn't take that action be default. " If you do an A/B test you aren't actively disrupting me when I am doing things totally unrelated with what you are selling and impinging on my time. Telemarketing does. With A/B testing at best you are trying to optimize your website (and indirectly and mostly unobtrusvely impinging the time and energy I choose to put into using your website). The difference is between trying to optimize layout in your store for when I do walk in vs calling me when I am playing with my children. Telemarketers are active nuisances and in my (politically incorrect) opinion should be lined up against the nearest wall and shot out of hand. What I'd pay money for is an Eliza like "voice bot", clever enough to waste telemarketers time to the point where the whole idea of telemarketing becomes economically infeasible.
- gaius 17y agoObviously there are scammers out there, but the average advertisement/sale caters to the average consumer If a person needs or even just wants a thing, then they just go out and buy it. The purpose of advertising is to persuade people to buy things they don't need and had no preexisting want for. The latter is the interesting case. Sometimes advertising can be used for good to inform people that new solutions to their problems are available, e.g. a new technology (no-one wanted say a microwave oven before they were invented). But often it's not.