12 ms·
While I believe they saw these numbers, specifically that lowering the price from $15 to $10 lead to a 74% increase in purchases, I don't believe that this is a
by IgorPartola 12y ago
While I believe they saw these numbers, specifically that lowering the price from $15 to $10 lead to a 74% increase in purchases, I don't believe that this is a good general rule of thumb. Here's the problem: there are only so many potential ebook readers out in the world, and they only have so much time. This means there will be market saturation at some point, or at least market movement. This elasticity is there, for sure, but the relationship between price and purchases is not going to stay the same, especially as everyone follows this advice. Basically, everyone will price their books at $10 and the playing field will be level. Then the advice will be to price your book at $7. Then at $5. Then at $2. Then at $0.99 cents. This is the problem we currently see with Apple's App store and the Google Play Store: too many apps, all priced similarly. For most apps, and probably for most ebooks it would almost be better to go in the exact opposite direction: one sale at $1000 is better than 10 sales at $1.
Also, why would Amazon care so much about how others market their content, to the point of trying to interfere? If your content is not worth $15, then nobody will buy it. If you suck at marketing, nobody will know to buy your (possibly great content). Why does Amazon get its hands dirty instead of simply giving you analytics-backed suggestions? Oh, that's right, because controlling the publishers is more profitable for them, and using their market position as leverage against publishers is a great way to do so.
- ashr 12y agoAll I see in your argument is preconceived opinions with speculative statements and nothing to back them up. Sorry but you did not add anything to this discussion, not even in the form of new questions or pointing out flaws in the post's arguments using evidence.
- walterbell 12y agoYes, many are forgetting that one of the primary purposes of markets is ... price discovery. Not price floor&ceiling fixing and restraining.
- jamesaguilar 12y ago> Also, why would Amazon care so much about how others market their content, to the point of trying to interfere? They make $3 on every sale, so obviously it is in their interest to set the price to maximize revenue. Your whole bit about "everyone doing it" and "race to the bottom" is an instance of the zero-sum fallacy.
- bsder 12y agoAnd your evidence that this isn't a zero-sum game, is, exactly, what? All of the evidence points to the fact that people have more than sufficient entertainment options and have set their budgets at a fixed point. It wasn't piracy that killed music. It was the fact that the prime purchasers of music had a fixed entertainment budget and switched to buying video games aka. zero-sum market.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoAnd your evidence that this isn't a zero-sum game, is, exactly, what? Me probably. And all the folk I know with reading habits like mine who have not bothered getting an ebook reader yet, despite having problems seeing the floor for books sometimes. edit - I think Amazon are complete and utter [redacted] over DRM, the 1984 debacle, their general attitude, etc. That said, I think they are probably right that everyone would make more money if the price dropped on ebooks. They are going about it in a very [redacted] way, of course. And even if they are right, their tactics seem pretty [redacted]. But that's Amazon being Amazon. Just because they are behaving like [redacted] doesn't mean that their economics isn't accurate.
- jamesaguilar 12y agoFYI, the book publishers compelled amazon to use drm. Where the publishers allow it, they distribute books free of drm.
- mseebach 12y ago>1984 Isn't the fact that we're still discussing a single screw up that was immediately rectified from 5 years ago evidence that Amazon is actually going about this DRM business in a pretty sensible way? Also, Amazons complete lack of interest in "fixing" the very easy DRM removal process seems to provide further evidence to the same end. Sure, it'd be better if there was no DRM, but there's the perfect world and then there's the world we actually live in.
- 12y ago
- x0x0 12y agoI initially thought as you do: cheaper ebooks cannibalize the more expensive. But remember books are competing with social networking, tv, radio, iphone games, console games, computer games, the outdoors, friends, pot, bars, etc. While a controlled study would be interesting, I bet books can steal some time share.
- chatmasta 12y agoI don't know exactly what you mean by market saturation in this case, as your logic seems to imply that each book has a finite market of N customers, and enough of a subset of them, M, are willing to pay $1000 (or whatever), such that M(1000) > N(5). The error in your logic is that the size of the market for a given book actually depends on the price of that book. There's millions of books out there. Why would I pay $1000 for one when I can get so many others for $5? By lowering the price of books, Amazon increases the market size of each one. There's also some behavioral economics involved, as I would assume people are far more likely to make a $5 impulse purchase (and look at that, Amazon has "one click send to Kindle!") than a $15 one.
- bsder 12y ago> Why would I pay $1000 for one when I can get so many others for $5? Because market data suggests that most people won't switch. They will buy book from "the new, hip writer X" or they won't buy at all. Someone who intends to buy something by Malcolm Gladwell is unlikely to buy something from somebody else just because it's a little cheaper. Amazon wants to maximize sales volume whereas the distributors and authors want to maximize profit. The two are often correlated, but not always.
- chatmasta 12y agoYes, but someone who is looking for a non-fiction book, with no author preference, is more likely to buy a $5 Michael Lewis book than a $15 Malcom Gladwell book.
- fpgeek 12y ago> Because market data suggests that most people won't switch. They will buy book from "the new, hip writer X" or they won't buy at all. Which is why publishers don't care whether or not stores like Amazon discount their physical books. </sarcasm>
- kamakazizuru 12y agoYes - but a person looking to buy the Malcolm Gladwell book - willing to buy it at 10$ - but who can only buy it at 15$ or more - will probably end up then either borrowing it from a friend or in the worst case downloading it as a PDF illegally. Both of which are a lost sale for the publisher and author.
- lotsofmangos 12y agofor most ebooks it would almost be better to go in the exact opposite direction: one sale at $1000 is better than 10 sales at $1 You seem to have not understood what books are for.
- bowlofpetunias 12y agoMaybe Amazon cares so much for the same reason Apple/Jobs cared about the pricing of music: too high a price point encourages piracy. Once piracy becomes an easily accessible and socially acceptable mainstream habit, it's going to be very hard to claw back market share. Right now, ebook piracy is by far not as easy and convenient as video or music. That could change as long as ebooks remain overpriced compared to physical books, and DRM impaired to boot. (Sooner or latter the general public is going to find out the hard way how much DRM devalues their "property".) I dunno about the US, where Amazon is king, but in most countries ebook adaption is stagnating and price is quoted as the #1 reason.
- bsder 12y ago> specifically that lowering the price from $15 to $10 lead to a 74% increase in purchases So, if Amazon takes $5, then whoever provided the book lost money on that deal. (Profit went from $10 to $5 while sales did not double). In fact, if Amazon takes more than about $4, it's a wash (which is actually a loss because some of those 75% more customers would likely have bought the book later at a different price point). If, Amazon takes $3, profit goes up by about 2% maybe 3%, if and only if that 74% increase occurs. If that increase doesn't happen, sucks to be the publisher, but Amazon's profit went up. If Amazon wants to move more Ebooks, why doesn't Amazon reduce the amount they take? Simple, because it doesn't pay in profit. So, Amazon wants somebody else to eat the price drop. Not exactly altruistic. All of the arguments about Ebook (less distribution cost, marginal volume cost, etc.) apply MORE to Amazon than the publishers. The publishers at least have to find authors. Amazon does, what, exactly, to justify taking $3 an Ebook? Um, right, it provides the market domination that is effectively a monopoly to the point that it thinks it can dictate pricing to publishers.
- 2arrs2ells 12y agoYour math assumes Amazon has a fixed fee. Amazon takes a percentage fee.
- nnutter 12y agoYour math/model doesn't make sense. Business is never altruistic. Amazon justifies 30% because they are the gatekeeper to millions of Kindle users.
- mendort 12y agoYou also assume that amazon is free to price ebooks however they want provided that they pay the publisher the right amount. They are not. This is one of the reasons that this conflict has developed. Amazon has traditionally been happy to sell many physical books at a loss. They are not permitted to do this with ebooks.
- bambax 12y agoThere is also the problem of cannibalization which is not mentioned in Amazon's post; it's obvious that some of the people who buy eBooks when they're <$10 would have bought the paper book instead if it were cheaper, or even the same price. So the "total revenue" figure is pretty abstract; publishers (or authors, or distributors, or anyone, really) don't need to consider media as completely separate; what matter is total sales, including paper, on-demand, and ebooks.
- JulianMorrison 12y agoI suspect that books are way undersaturated. The reason is: paper. Dead tree books weigh a lot and waste space. Therefore owning a library is a cost. Costs to move, costs storage space, costs effort to collate and maintain and protect. E-books do not have that cost. Having a hundred e-books in your purse is a normal thing. Having a thousand? Well, it might make sorting through your personal equivalent of a branch library a little more fussy, but it won't weigh more or waste space. People may not have more time, but they can divert time to books, and they can divert re-reading time to new-book reading time.
- romaniv 12y agoTherefore owning a library is a cost. Owning a library has a higher value than owning a library of ebooks: social, decorative, nostalgic, works without power, easy share, can resell, etc. It more than evens out. But there is Steam effect - people will stockpile ebooks they don't read.
- moistgorilla 12y ago> social, decorative, nostalgic This is subjective and not monetary value. The only people that care about social, decorative, and nostalgic value of books are also the people who probably wont resell books. > works without power finding a place to charge your device is easy and ereaders last months without recharging > easy to share, resell Sure but the money you save by reselling a book is probably less than what you save by buying the ebook Space and weight are real, expensive costs. Owning a library has negative monetary value. Owning a library of ebooks doesn't. It's stored on the internet and you can access it from anywhere. Basically, if your books aren't furniture and you aren't sharing your books multiple times a month ebooks provide more value.
- terrywilcox 12y ago“Nowadays people know the price of everything and the value of nothing.” - Oscar Wilde
- mcguire 12y ago