3 ms·
Isn't this pretty normal? In the US a judge can bar the press from covering a trial in progress if they believe it could prejudice the jury or create a circus.
by tootie 12y ago
Isn't this pretty normal? In the US a judge can bar the press from covering a trial in progress if they believe it could prejudice the jury or create a circus. They will still be allowed to report everything once there's a verdict.
- bradleybuda 12y agoThis is not true. A judge can bar the media from their courtroom, but they cannot ban coverage entirely.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> In the US a judge can bar the press from covering a trial in progress if they believe it could prejudice the jury or create a circus. No, they can't. In the US, a judge can bar media from proceedings and order people involved in a case (parties, witnesses, etc.) not to comment on it, and can thereby prohibit most ways in which the media would get information about it, but cannot generally order the media not to report on it (rules allowing that have in the past been adopted, and generally been struck down as unconstitutional.) The media are generally free to report material leaked in violation of such gag orders, although the leaker may be subject to sanctions.
- tootie 12y agoYou're right and that's an important distinction, but it looks that's actually what's in this order as well. They are not making it illegal to report, just to divulge the information. If It leaks, it's fair game.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jacques_chester 12y agoAustralian judges typically have more powers to issue suppression orders (especially in Victoria).