9 ms·
Economics is not a natural science
- moron4hire 17y agoTo be fair, I don't recall anyone of import advocating that economics is a natural science. Look at any university course catalogue and it is wedged pretty firmly in the social science department where it should be, along with the other fake sciences like psychology and sociology (though I would have to call it a continuum of fake, with clinical psychology on the "closer to real" end and sociology on the "just making junk up" end).
- fburnaby 17y agoVery true. That's a problem that in principle can be fixed, though. Your "fake" sciences can in principle all be approached using the scientific method. They are actually real sciences. It's just a portion of the practitioners that hurt their credibility. My guess is that it's the inherently complex subject matter that allows politically-charged crackpots and other non-scientists to squeeze their way in and call themselves scientists.
- moron4hire 17y agoUnfortunately, I suspect that there is too much incentive to "make observation fit one's expectations" in these fields. Conversely, what purpose does non-scientific quantum physics serve? Beyond weaseling more research money, pretty much nothing. But making economics and sociology say things that aren't held up by observation can, and most often does, lead to vast political and social change.
- onreact-com 17y agoYeah, most people treat capitalism more like religion than an economic system of choice, especially the disastrous one we have now. A return to the less devastating Keynesian sort of capitalism won't undo the whole mess though. Alternative digital economies of sharing have shown how there are plenty of other viable models of economic organization. It's time to reevaluate the failed system that brought us here.
- kiba 17y agoUnless we can perform alchemy as if we were gods and as well have access to all the raw materials in the world, scarcity will continues to be a factor in the study of economics. That, and digital economies are only suitable to things with the marginal cost of production of nearly 0 or is 0.
- onreact-com 17y agoYeah, of course, but it's how we deal with scarcity that makes the difference. Currently those who have the most power and sometimes fire power have the scarce resources. They are not divided evenly whatsoever and the countries that harbor them in many cases are poor and and chaotic, think Congo e.g. Now that China decided to limit the exports of many crucial resources and the US ceases to be the most powerful economy many people in the West will discover that the current distribution of resources is not at all satisfying. In the current order most people either starve or live on a minimum while a few people are living lavish and wasteful lives. This type of "economics" can't survive in the long run. Let's just hope id doesn't end in a bloody way. Wasting most resources like we do now is not economical at all and telling people that's it's natural market forces that makes people in Africa starve while we get fat is just plainly naive. It's time to rethink the way of life we live based on the exploitation of the scarce resources and other people.
- berntb 17y ago>>In the current order most people either starve or live on a minimum As a percentage, much fewer is poor for every generation that passes -- and a small percentage starve, today. Go back a few hundred years and almost everyone lived hand-to-mouth. Check Hans Rosling's lectures on TED.com for how much better the present situation is. From what I've read, when a country implements serious capitalism and good governance in the last century, there is no starvation after a generation or two. Ah, never mind. Go to one of the places where they discuss things like this. If you insist on quarreling with just me, post the link and I'll try to find the time to come along -- taking one for the team to help the average HN quality... :-) Edit: I do understand where you're coming from. At day work, they are a bit frustrated at me telling them that Asian ginger candy is the answer to human happiness. (And let's not even think about getting started on editors!) I try to realize that I shouldn't proselytize on the web, people will realize the truth in the end... :-) (By the way, I'm not talking about that garbage Indonesian ginger candy I used to love -- there is some Vietnamese variant that hurts, nam nam...)
- thomaspaine 17y agodupe http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=763124 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=763124
- Tichy 17y ago"In fact, thanks to their blind acceptance of a particular theory of the market, most of these concepts end up failing to accurately predict the future. " Failing to predict the future does not prove something is not scientific. For example there are simple cellular automatons whose evolution can not be predicted, even though all the rules they follow are known. Also, what is "the market" supposed to mean? "Now the interesting thing about this money is that it lost value over time. " Oh dear, please tell me that it is not the "Freigeld" craze finally reaching HN :-(
- kiba 17y agoMoney lose their money over time due to the increase of money supply versus productivity. I imagine, if we cut off the printing press, there will be massive deflation.
- Tichy 17y agoYeah, that is why introducing money that is designed to lose value would not be a magic weapon to fix the economy.
- m_eiman 17y agoWe already have money that loses value by design (the target inflation is "a bit over zero").
- Tichy 17y agoBut that is not inherent to the money, is it? It is the policy of the money issuing entity. The Freigeld proponents want money that automatically loses value. Like the guy int he article mentioning that "money" in the middle ages would decay (because it was biological stuff). That's why I worried that he might be one of the Freigeld people.
- m_eiman 17y agoNot inherent in the bills and coins, but in the economic system they're part of. So we could change the system and keep the physical money, of course.
- jrockway 17y agoWhy is every word in the title all-caps except for "Not"?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- arihelgason 17y agoThat's why it's called 'the dismal science' - the first thing we were taught in economics 101 at university.
- andreyf 17y agoWhat is "Natural Science"? A study of a "natural system"? What's a "natural system"? I think what the author means to say, and should have said in one paragraph, is that economics has not yet developed an appropriate language for their models. Economists are still trying to use calculus, which was thought of by physicists do describe physical phenomena, which, when used in economics, is leading to wildly inaccurate models.
- DrJokepu 17y agoAccording to the Oxford English Dictonary: noun a branch of science which deals with the physical world, e.g. physics, chemistry, geology, biology
- andreyf 17y agodeals with the physical world Eek, don't like it. What is "the physical world"? Or rather, what isn't part of "the physical world"? It's just a matter of creating models for phenomena of increasing complexity. Just as biology studies a set of phenomena emergent from enormous amounts of bio-chemical interactions, which are emergent from quantum physics, etc., economics is emergent from the psychology, beliefs, and interactions of people.
- Alex3917 17y agoNo, what he's saying is that our economic system isn't natural, it was designed. He's just delineating nature and culture, a la Terence McKenna.
- christofd 17y agoWell put! The basic models of Econ were built on physics envy. They built models on a fairly artificial set of assumptions that use calculus. Poppycock.
- rwolf 17y agoEvery last one of the economics courses I've taken was smothered in caveats about the underlying assumptions--you could make a drinking game out of it. Fields like behavioral economics address specific criticisms with new theory, making BE even more likely to clearly and consistently note problems with the foundation. I'm okay with econ being a social science (it sure wasn't taught in the Natural Science building at my school!), and I'm okay with being critical of the way its framework extends into my life. I don't understand how anyone can get through the gauntlet of econ warnings with hubris intact.
- dvvarf 17y agoyou know, it's funny. most people would put the start of economic thought ~1776 when Adam Smith wrote the Wealth of Nations. That means it's been around less than 250 years. Sure it may not describe physical processes, but economics does try to model the real world. SCIENCE wasn't too far along 250 years after inception. I mean, we still believed that the world was flat not too long ago. give it time, the data will come. mistakes will be made.
- berntb 17y ago>give it time, the data will come. I'm very much not an expert, but that seemed optimistic. Economy's problem is that it describes a system which contain (more or less) intelligent beings who read up on economic theory -- and the beings then modifies their behavior from those studies... So to get data and build models, it seems there must be some fix point to that function, somewhere...? :-) (To add maiming to injury, those beings change culture and probably basic motivations every generation, these days.) I have respect for economy and economists, they seem to do a reasonable good job from a bad position. But I'm happy I went with other interests.
- reader5000 17y agoHis point is not what the definition of 'science' is. His thesis is that in the late middle ages society operated on a 'mutual credit system' (wikipedia it) of exchange where the merchant classes were independently creating and exchanging value. This mutual credit system was usurped for a centralized currency system where value creation is tightly controlled by the state (i.e. in the form of loans of a monopolized currency; what we have today). Centralized currency discourages cooperation and forces unnatural selfish competition between individuals, to the benefit of the corporate ownership. This unnatural state is reinforced as natural through corporate sponsorship of intellectuals like Dawkins and Pinker (even though if you read them both of these authors works are agnostic on this point). Then he makes an unclear point about how the internet changes all that.
- juvenn 17y agoI do agree that Economics is not yet an reliable scientific subject, i.e. you can not predict future in accurate by doing scientific computations, and I do not think it will. But why natural? The economy involves, most importantly, rational (or not) human being who behaviors accordingly. And these behaviors must connected with the others socially. So, how could we learn the economy without studying these social things?
- yummyfajitas 17y agoFrom the article: The system in which most information transmission takes place today is not a pre-existing condition of the universe. It's not nature. It's a machine, with very particular rules, set in motion by real people with real purposes. That's why it's so amazing to me that scientists, and people calling themselves scientists, would propose to study the internet as if it were some natural system - like the weather, or a coral reef. You can use science to study all sorts of systems, ranging from the oceans to the internet to economics. They don't have to be natural. All that matters is whether you apply the scientific method to the phenomenon you are studying. Many economists do this, so (at least part of) the field of economics is scientific. You might be able to imagine another world in which the laws of economics don't work. Ok, so what? You can imagine worlds in which the laws of physics don't work, it doesn't make physics unscientific.
- CulturalNgineer 17y agoFrom Edge: Comment from George Dyson on “Economics Is Not a Natural Science” By Douglas Rushkoff “How to best transcend the current economic mess? Put Jeff Bezos, Pierre Omidyar, Elon Musk, Tim O’Reilly, Larry Page, Sergey Brin, Nathan Myhrvold, and Danny Hillis in a room somewhere and don’t let them out until they have framed a new, massively-distributed financial system, founded on sound, open, peer-to-peer principles, from the start. And don’t call it a bank. Launch a new financial medium that is as open, scale-free, universally accessible, self-improving, and non-proprietary as the Internet, and leave the 13th century behind. In essence, I agree with the piece and the comment. I also believe that the Chagora model is very close to what they are talking about… (it can function with standard and/or newly created currencies whether localized or not. Especially when combined with methods of geographical localization and scaled anonymity. The practical microtransaction in all areas is essential for proper scaling of civilization and its the political microtransaction (networked citizen lobbying) that is the trigger. P.S. PayPal is a bad model for civilization development. (Chagora is essentially scalable speech and association) If I’m an idiot I’d like to find out soon since things are very tight. I’d like at least a chance to present my case and don’t know where else to go. http://www.Chagora.com http://www.Chagora.com See blog for more... http://culturalengineer.blogspot.com/2009/05/foundations-of-authoritarianism.html http://culturalengineer.blogspot.com/2009/05/foundations-of-...