5 ms·
I don't recognize the situation you described. In my school system, if a book had excess damage (beyond normal wear and tear) then the parents had to pay damage
by dalke 12y ago
I don't recognize the situation you described. In my school system, if a book had excess damage (beyond normal wear and tear) then the parents had to pay damage fees. That is, the kids are "answerable to their parents for the cost."
Eg, from http://kennedymiddleschool.weebly.com/textbook-replacement-costs.html http://kennedymiddleschool.weebly.com/textbook-replacement-c... : "The parent, guardian, or other person having custody of the student to whom the instructional materials are issued shall be liable for any loss, abuse, or damage in excess of that which would result from normal use of the materials."
The same holds for library books. Eg, http://www.christina.k12.de.us/pulaski/library/ http://www.christina.k12.de.us/pulaski/library/ "Please be aware that if your child takes out a book and either loses it or damages it, the school district requires that the book be paid for or worked off. This can affect whether or not your child receives a report card."
Also, textbooks can last for many years. http://www.rcsnc.org/departments/curriculum_and_instruction/textbooks__professional_library/textbook_damage_fees/ http://www.rcsnc.org/departments/curriculum_and_instruction/... for example uses a 5 year depreciation schedule. Wouldn't your proposal mean either that parents are paying about 5x more than they should, or introduce new overhead costs of creating a secondary market for parents to sell used textbooks to other parents?
- mschuster91 12y ago> Also, textbooks can last for many years. Which is part of the problem. Shit, in 2008 my geography books still included maps of the Soviet Union!
- MrZongle2 12y agoGranted, geography books that are 17 years out of date are a problem but the solution is cheap: the teacher can photocopy a modern map, pass it out to the class and simply say "the book is outdated, here are the countries you'll be tested on." Schoolbooks may be ridiculously expensive, but given their longevity they pale in comparison to laptops. Even if a laptop is well-treated by students, the maintenance required for an average-sized school is ridiculous. And that's assuming that operating systems don't have to be replaced or licenses have to be renewed.... The photocopied map workaround sucks, but at least it works. A broken laptop doesn't.
- toast0 12y agoWell, the mountains and other geologic features are still there, just the political boundaries have changed, and features may have been renamed.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Wouldn't your proposal mean either that parents are paying about 5x more than they should, or introduce new overhead costs of creating a secondary market for parents to sell used textbooks to other parents? Well, sure, but think of the benefits for textbook publishers. It'd be like extending the college textbook market down into grade school.
- dalke 12y agoThat does seem one of the consequences of Common Core. I was aghast to see my niece's math book where every single subsection contained a reference to the corresponding CC requirement. Which means that whenever CC changes -- poof! new textbooks are needed.
- anigbrowl 12y agoWhere I'm from (Ireland/UK) students buy their own books, but they're much much cheaper than the US. I think the price of grade school textbooks is high because it's school districts doing the buying. College textbooks are also a lot cheaper, eg I'd expect to pay about $30-40 for a typical textbook from a major publisher like Pearson or similar. I got a hell of a shock when I moved to the US and found college-level textbooks to be 3-4 times more expensive than what I was used to.
- dragonwriter 12y agoSince both college and grade school texts are more expensive in the US, as you report, it seems more likely that there is a common cause for the difference in book prices rather than the price difference for grade school texts being due to school districts buying them.
- anigbrowl 12y agoMy (under-researched) theory is that by the time people get to college, they've already been acclimatized to the idea that textbooks should be very expensive by 12 years of grade school, so most of them passively accept the egregiously high prices. Part of my interest in this stems from my surprise at learning that my wife saved a few thousand $ by buying almost all her college textbooks from the UK, despite the high shipping fees. Too bad this wasn't an option for law books :-/
- anigbrowl 12y agoFor subjects one is interested in, I don't think that the books' utility ends with the academic year. Also, I don't think the secondary market costs are very significant, it's not hard for parents in the same school district to find each other. I used to sell some used books to a neighbor whose child was 1 year behind me in school when I was growing up, though I kept some other books for subjects I particularly liked. As I mentioned in another comment I grew up in a place where textbooks are much, much more affordable - I believe that a lot of this has to do with parents being exposed to the actual book prices every year, rather than the books being purchased at the institutional level and the costs passed on to taxpayers.
- dalke 12y agoI don't recall wanting to revisit most of my school books. Certainly not my elementary or jr. high school books. I did in college buy a used copy of a different version of the American history textbook I used in high school. So I think the utility is rather small. Here's a report on school text books in Ireland: https://www.education.ie/en/Publications/Education-Reports/School-Books-in-Ireland-Cost-to-Parents.pdf https://www.education.ie/en/Publications/Education-Reports/S... It's from 1993, and exists because curriculum changes in the 1960s-1980s meant that the books, which in "the early part of the century served students for generations, in some cases up to the 1960s", were now more freely selected by the teachers, while the parents pay the bill. Some quotes: "Between 50% and 80% of books sold in certain subjects may be recycled. The volume of recycled books in circulation makes the cost of the annual book bill to parents difficult to estimate." "It is the conclusion of this Report that book rental schemes offer the most practical method of curtailing the cost of school books to parents in Ireland." Related to this thread: "Students were found to treat books with vastly different degrees of care within areas, schools, and classes, whether they owned the books or rented them." So no, ownership isn't a key factor in how the books are treated. Oh! Here's a more recent report ( http://www.barnardos.ie/assets/files/Advocacy/2012-School-Costs-Report.pdf http://www.barnardos.ie/assets/files/Advocacy/2012-School-Co... ), with details about the current cost breakdown. Regarding books, "[t]he majority of parents are spending ... over €250 for a secondary school pupil." "An ongoing criticism by parents has been the inability to pass books on between siblings due to new editions being prescribed by the teacher." "The reliance on workbooks as a pupil resource is also often criticised by parents as being wasteful and expensive because they cannot be reused. " This suggests there is a non-trivial overhead to the secondary school book market in Ireland. (The hope is that the new the Code of Practice for the publishers may change that a bit.) Even more info: http://www.labour.ie/elenasecas/news/13983441786294822.html http://www.labour.ie/elenasecas/news/13983441786294822.html from April 2014 reports that "20% of primary schools do not currently have book rental schemes" and that a new €15m School Book Fund will provide seed capital to start them (the 1993 report talks about the need for such a fund). As a result, they expect to "see the average book costs per child fall from about €100 per year, down to just €20." This fits with my estimate of a 5 year depreciation schedule. All of these suggest that purchasing books in Ireland is not "much, much more affordable". However, I can't find equivalent numbers for other countries, so I could be wrong. Still, I get the idea that it isn't as rosy as you paint it. BTW, why do so many Irish schools require a school crest on their uniform? How do they justify that extra cost?
- ams6110 12y agoAnd when the parents or custodial guardians don't have any money? When a family is getting free lunches, you can bet they aren't going to pay for damaged books or computers.