3 ms·
> In the second, Flashlight has been promoted from number 10 to number 9, falsely inflating its ranking. This is a concern that goes away in a user-centered de
by snowwrestler 12y ago
> In the second, Flashlight has been promoted from number 10 to number 9, falsely inflating its ranking.
This is a concern that goes away in a user-centered design process. The "ranking" does not matter to anyone but app developers or journalists keeping score. The only reason a user looks at those lists is to find new apps to download.
Consider Google SERPs, which are now highly customized. Who obsesses over whether an item is at #7 or #9? No one but the people who own those links. Everyone else just wants an answer to their question.
- bruceboughton 12y agoThe App Store has search results pages too. Top Charts are not search results pages--they are rankings of apps. Top Charts is a popularity-based browse mechanism. Search is an answer to "what can i play podcasts on?". You could argue Top Charts should be removed from the store or demoted. But you need some kind of browse functionality because people are often not aware that a certain type of app exists to search for.
- snowwrestler 12y agoMy point was not that the lists are the exact same thing as search results, my point is that users don't care about the tiny details of whether a particular app is #7 or #8. If you conducted a survey of App Store users and asked them to give you the numerical rank of a given app ("was it 8 or 9?"), I would surprised if many could remember, and shocked if any cared. Why do users view those lists? As you point out, to browse for new apps. The precise numerical ranking does not help them very much to do that; therefore a user-centered design process should not care very much about how precisely accurate the displayed rankings are. Edit to add: Users have no way to independently verify rankings anyway, so the concept of a "false" shift from 9 to 8 has no meaning to them. They don't know what's false, only what's useful.