5 ms·
I worked for a company who provided a SaaS to a few private entities but also some very large state agencies, including an entire branch of the government. I re
by pc86 12y ago
I worked for a company who provided a SaaS to a few private entities but also some very large state agencies, including an entire branch of the government. I remember sitting in a meeting with my boss and the owner of the company, while we sat on the phone with someone from the procurement department of another agency while they crafted the bid to only allow us to compete. It was disgusting and they did nothing to hide it. The state employee (who knew the company owner socially) even mentioned the competition by name, along the lines of "if we require ______ then ______ won't be able to bid, right?"
- justinpaulson 12y agoSo you immediately reported this to other government officials?
- dm2 12y agoWhistleblower protection hasn't been around for very long, and I'm not sure how it applies to private companies. The "official" process is likely a very difficult set of hoops to jump through and you're not going to be promoted in that company more than likely, and fired at the first opportunity.
- pc86 12y agoThis was many years ago and it was state not federal. I asked an attorney friend if I had any obligation to do anything (as well as if I would have any protection if I did) and was told that if I needed the job to keep my mouth shut. Unfortunately, I did and this was my first professional job out of college. Morally I made the wrong call by not speaking up even though truthfully I don't know if what happened was actually illegal at the time or not.
- beering 12y agoCompetitors can bid, but will have generally worse answers for the specially crafted requirements. The competitors can either say "no, we don't do that" and hope that the committee doesn't mind, say "yes, we could do that" and see if the agency will pay extra for that special req, or say "yes, we do that" and build out that feature if they win the bid.
- danielweber 12y agoEh, once i was at a startup where we were selling our mostly COTS software to a government agency, but they had to put it out for a bid. They basically lifted our marketing material into the req and said "software must do all <X> and cost $<Y>." We had a competitor who had copied a bunch of our stuff, including our typos, but they were missing one essential feature. Yet they still got the bid somehow. A mystery for the ages.
- pc86 12y agoIn this case, the bid specified company requirements (e.g. number of employees, past projects, etc) that immediately narrowed the field to 2 or 3 firms. Add in special consideration (the owner of the company I worked at was a woman and my state gives preference points to woman-, minority- and veteran-owned businesses) and it was about as close to a no-bid contract as you can get.
- rockdoe 12y agoNow consider the situation that the government official knows your company can deliver on time and in budget, with little fuss, and your competitors are known to underbid, over-promise, deliver very late or never and discuss endlessly over contractual fine language when they start failing. It's absolutely disgusting that he'd craft his bid to the supplier he knows isn't taking shit, right?
- conanbatt 12y agoThe road to hell is paved with good intentions. Thinking it will turn out better is not a good justification of corruption, specially because in the end, it doesnt turn out better. The lack of accountability and transparency in these kind of expenditures are common in all governments around the world and its the classic way to stiff taxpayers out of their money.
- rockdoe 12y agobecause in the end, it doesnt turn out better. <citation needed> So what's an administrator to do in that situation? Take the "best" bid, see the project go over time, see the contract and specification disputes start, see the costs go up, and end up with a 300M failure after 6 years? What you call "corruption" and "a lack of accountability or transparency" I would call "exercise best judgment and experience" to save the taxpayers their money. Basically, a procurer doing his job. You would have some point if software were more amendable to requirements specification and bidding, but the entire industry is still terrible at it, so it's a bad process, because it doesn't actually promote "accountability and transparency" at all.
- pc86 12y agoI think we have different ideas of what a government procurer's job is. It's not a government employees job to craft a bid in order to prevent specific private companies from being able to apply. Saying you want a staff of 10 FTEs because $ILLOGICAL_REASON is still illogical but certainly not the least illogical thing in the government procurement process, for sure. Saying you want a staff of 10 FTEs because $FAVORED_COMPANY has 12 and $COMPETITOR has 8 is absolutely corruption. Short of envelopes full of cash I don't know how you get more corrupt than that. And to your earlier comment, you are assuming both > your company can deliver on time and in budget, with little fuss and > your competitors are known to underbid, over-promise, deliver very late or never and discuss endlessly over contractual fine language when they start failing. This may very well be the case in other examples of this going on, but I can assure you neither point was true in my case (but is obviously specific to me, the plural of anecdote is not data, etc).