7 ms·
The NSA's Cyber-King Goes Corporate
- kabdib 12y agoBuy security from a company run by someone who lied to Congress? Um... yeah.
- samstave 12y agoLooking forward to the terrorist hacker false flag that will scare banks into paying this racket.
- droopybuns 12y ago$600k-$1m a month apparently gets you a cyber security company with no website.
- sam_bwut 12y agoxipiter was homepage less for 4 years, they managed fine.
- nodata 12y agoIt's very secure.
- easytiger 12y agoThey will fax you the details.
- contingencies 12y agohttp://goo.gl/GZ4P8m http://goo.gl/GZ4P8m
- 2close4comfort 12y agoI bet they have a killer PowerPoint deck!
- rubiquity 12y agoPretty amazing that the former director of the NSA can start a company in his former employer's space without being sued and yet as programmers we can't get a job anywhere without signing huge stacks of papers that make doing the same nearly impossible, or scary enough to where we don't even bother.
- rayiner 12y agoThe NSA's job isn't private cyber security. Also, non-competes are evil.
- droopyEyelids 12y agoThe point is there seems to be different rules governing people who come from different positions or social classes in our society.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 12y agoThat doesn't sound right at all. CEOs are more likely to be bound by noncompetes than line employees. Equally importantly, the noncompete of a CEO is much more likely to be enforceable. Contractual restrictions on competition probably become more onerous as economic status increases.
- dan_bk 12y agoThe best known example for this are bankers. As a rule of thumb, bankers don't go to jail.
- ihsw 12y agoSuing General Alexander would probably do more harm than good -- this stint in the private industry is likely just another carrot on a stick that he's offering to the world's greatest hackers. "Work for the NSA and you get will leave with a very powerful patent portfolio, and (most importantly) minimal risk of getting sued!"
- incision 12y ago>'What insights or expertise about cybersecurity could possibly justify such a sky-high fee, some wondered, even for a man as well-connected in the military-industrial complex as the former head of the nation's largest intelligence agency?' The same sort of insights and expertise that athletes put into stuff sold by Nike, Adidas or Gatorade. It's an endorsement deal.
- JTon 12y agoI think it's a little more than an endorsement deal. He knows deep inside information into what surveillance programs the NSA operates. I read it as follows: "we guarantee your company's IT infrastructure will no longer be seen as a low hanging fruit to the NSA"
- rayiner 12y agoHe's not a clueless career bureaucrat. He's been in the cybersecurity business for a very long time (from his Wiki page): > Alexander worked on signals intelligence at a number of secret National Security Agency bases in the United States and Germany. He earned an MS in business administration in 1978 from Boston University, an MS in systems technology (electronic warfare) and an MS in physics in 1983 from the Naval Postgraduate School, and an MS in national security strategy from the National Defense University. While the government is often woefully behind the private sector, it's also sometimes several steps ahead.[1] You might not like his views about the right balance between security and privacy, but I wouldn't underestimate the kind of insight Alexander can bring to the table, for reasons that have nothing to do with his political pull with the NSA. [1] Anecdote: I worked on a DARPA project about a decade ago. Commercial implementation of similar technology is probably another decade out. And that was pretty run of the mill stuff, nothing classified. I can only imagine the type of shit you run into at the NSA. The military often just hits a particular pressure point before the private sector does, and they have the money to throw experts at the problem.
- themartorana 12y agoI have no doubt he's smart, but taking from your comment that in this arena, govn't software is often years ahead of private sector software, I don't for a single minute believe his patents are for technology he magically invented "on his own time." I know the article tries to address this, but his "unique insight" can never (especially this soon) be separated from his knowledge of classified information and software techniques. This is, IMHO, incredibly perverse. Edit: clarification.
- geetee 12y agoWiper is a cousin of the notorious Stuxnet virus, which was built by the NSA -- while Alexander was in charge -- in cooperation with Israeli intelligence. Have the Stuxnet creators actually been proven to be the US and Israel? I thought it was still speculation (but almost certainly true).
- DCKing 12y agoThere was a lot of circumstantial evidence pointing to this fact already, and Snowden finally confirmed this last year in an interview with Der Spiegel [1]. [1]: http://cryptome.org/2013/07/snowden-spiegel-13-0707-en.htm http://cryptome.org/2013/07/snowden-spiegel-13-0707-en.htm
- geetee 12y agoAh thanks. I had read about a lot of evidence pointing in the USA's direction, but didn't realize Snowden also confirmed it. Arguably still hearsay, but certainly adds more weight to it.
- DCKing 12y agoIn addition to the Snowden confirmation, there were some press leaks in 2012 that appear to have confirmed it earlier [1]. Apparently there's still some investigations going on within the U.S. government about who leaked it. I'd say it's a pretty clear-cut case who was behind Stuxnet. [1] http://www.wired.com/2013/06/general-keith-alexander-cyberwar/all/ http://www.wired.com/2013/06/general-keith-alexander-cyberwa...
- MisterWebz 12y agoI'm sure he'd charge them even more if it weren't for Snowden devaluing some of the information he knows.
- ihsw 12y agoNonsense, Snowden's revelations give credence to the NSA's capability. One could even say that Keith Alexander owes Snowden a great deal of his notoriety to him.
- easytiger 12y agoWithout Snowden no one would take him seriously Id venture to say.
- wwwwwwwwww 12y agoare you seriously claiming that nobody would take the former head of the NSA seriously if it were not for the snowden leaks? jesus christ, I know HN is a huge circlejerk when it comes to the NSA/surveillance but this is absolutely off the charts. he's the former chair of the most advanced SIGINT agency in the world, which operates under the jurisdiction of the most powerful and politically aggressive country in the world. we're not talking most advanced by a little margin too, it's more like a gaping chasm. are you seriously so out of whack that you think all that counts for nothing?
- AdmiralAsshat 12y ago>"It was those kinds of hackers who Alexander, when he was running the NSA, said were responsible for "the greatest transfer of wealth in American history" because they were routinely stealing trade secrets and competitive information from U.S. companies and giving it to their competitors, often in China." Oh, and here I thought the greatest transfer of wealth in American history was the massive rise in disparity over the last thirty years between the nation's top 0.1% and everyone else.
- ihsw 12y agoThat's consolidation of wealth -- transfer (in this context) implies it leaves sphere of American influence.
- rhizome 12y agoNo, the analogy holds. One is across national borders, the other across economic strata. Here is an article from Forbes describing welfare as wealth transfer: http://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2011/07/15/makers-takers-and-wealth-transfer-in-the-modern-welfare-state/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2011/07/15/mak...
- crazy1van 12y ago> Oh, and here I thought the greatest transfer of wealth in American history was the massive rise in disparity over the last thirty years between the nation's top 0.1% and everyone else. Not all changes in economic status are transfers of wealth. Consider two cases: 1) I physically steal a CD from the record store and sell it. That's a transfer because the store can't sell what they no longer posses. Instead I have sold it. Nothing new is created. 2) I create an album and sell CDs of it. That's not a transfer. I created something new of value and introduced it to the world. I may get wealthy, but the people who buy my CD don't lose value. They exchange one thing of value (money) for another of equivalent value to them (my CD).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bradleyjg 12y agoI wouldn't hire a security company run by the former head of the NSA. Is there any question in anyone's mind that if he was approached by the government to put a backdoor in your company's product or infrastructure, he wouldn't hesitate for a second to say yes?
- dllthomas 12y agoThe government never paid him a million dollars.
- uptown 12y agoHow would you know? The US intelligence budget clocks in around $52 billion. You don't think a few million could be allocated if it was the most-expedient way of making something happen?
- dllthomas 12y agoIf you mean that the government could offer him a million now to expose a client's network, sure, but they could offer that to anyone.
- Already__Taken 12y agoCan't the government use everything they know he has done with them to ban him entirely from the sector? Some kind of conflict or interest or just hang him with something and put out a black mark.
- dllthomas 12y agoYou mean, "You're coming too close to trading classified information, if you're not actually doing so already. Stop it."? You mean they could threaten this to get cooperation, or that they should do this? Anyway. Yes, I think.
- higherpurpose 12y agoHe's most likely using inside information from the NSA. This warrants an investigation and constant monitoring by DOJ (not that they'd actually do anything about it if they saw Alexander selling secret NSA information to companies). As someone else was saying on Twitter - at least Snowden gave back the information to tax-payers for free. Keith Alexander is just trying to profit from it, and only giving it to a few elites.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dragontamer 12y agohttp://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-07-17/how-russian-hackers-stole-the-nasdaq http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-07-17/how-russian-... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Aurora http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Aurora Nope, they target anyone and everyone big. True, there are some DoD names on that list... but Nasdaq, Google, Yahoo, and Adobe are most decidedly not DoD companies.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- phaus 12y ago>These hackers primarily steal from DoD companies right? They target anyone that has proprietary information that they can use to make money. I'm sure there are plenty of DoD targets, but these are outnumbered by private companies with no ties to the goverment.
- breadtk 12y ago> The total figures are way smaller than drug sales. But always overblown in the media Source?
- angersock 12y ago"the greatest transfer of wealth in American history" ...I'm pretty sure that award goes to the enjoyable human beings in the banking and foreclosures industries, followed only possibly by health insurance companies.
- TheMagicHorsey 12y agoWhenever a company starts off by talking about patents, I suspect they are going to claim some trivial shit and troll everyone.
- jemfinch 12y ago"Alexander said that if he determines that he needs to use technology or methods that the NSA has patented, he will pay for a license". Why can the NSA patent anything at all, preventing the public from using the technology it generated with taxpayers' money?
- res0nat0r 12y agoWhy not? It is just like many other companies that invent technologies that might happen to also be funded by the public. See DARPA. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARPA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARPA
- Alupis 12y agoCan I call up the NSA and obtain a license for say... XKeyScore? Probably not... so this is egregious.
- res0nat0r 12y agoNot everything developed by the government is automatically supposed to be available to the public so I guess I don't understand your point.
- Alupis 12y agoThe point is how is it acceptable that a previously-public-servant can have insider knowledge about "secret" government patents and he can obtain a license to use the technology but I cannot? That's absurd and an abuse of power and privilege.
- ObviousScience 12y agoDid it say he was going to use secret patents? Or just that he was going to use NSA patents? Because the NSA maintains a list of patented technologies that they offer to the public on various terms: http://www.nsa.gov/research/_files/tech_transfers/nsa_technology_transfer_program.pdf http://www.nsa.gov/research/_files/tech_transfers/nsa_techno...
- angersock 12y agoAsked why he didn't share this new approach with the federal government when he was in charge of protecting its most important computer systems, Alexander said the key insight about using behavior models came from one of his business partners, whom he also declined to name, and that it takes an approach that the government hadn't considered. It's these methods that Alexander said he will seek to patent. Quite the patriot--and one wonders why Millenials have no faith in the senior .gov folks.
- kelvin0 12y agoI'm tempted to make an analogy with 'protection' money paid by some small businesses to the mafia in order to be able to operate without being 'hassled' ... Of course, it's just subjective image that popped into mind as I read this.
- 616c 12y ago> Alexander is believed to be the first ex-director of the NSA to file patents on technology that's directly related to the job he had in government. I wish purely out of spite this schmuck could be the source of a whole class of new lawsuit by which certain government employees, like projects they work on, are legally required to do public domain work only. Like, their employment at a company becomes caustic so people who works at orgs like the NSA who have access to state secrets dedicate themselves to the cause for life and there is no chance for profit. In short, this is disgusting and I dislike him more than even before.
- drblast 12y agoGovernment agencies about to be inundated with sales pitches from General Alexander's company in 3...2...1... Same thing happened when Admiral Fallon retired and suddenly discovered his long hidden cyber security talent at NeuralIQ. This is a way for these guys to use influence to sell things to agencies they used to run.
- dublinben 12y agoHow can we forget Chertoff, and his lobbying/fear mongering on behalf of body scanner manufacturers. He very transparently used his credentials as former Secretary of Homeland Security to get his client's devices installed in every airport in the country.
- samstave 12y agoAnd Tom Ridge, who joined the board of Savi Technologies/Lockheed Martin to push the use of RFID tracking on military shipments and port security.
- gcb4 12y agoi just read several paragraphs of absolutely nothing. really. how this person considers himself a journalist? or even a blogger? the central argument appears to be patents, yet not even the titles are mentioned.
- pasbesoin 12y agoOk, I didn't read it. But I am of the strong opinion that what is for sale is political expertise and connections, not any particular technical expertise. Perhaps toss in some particular narrow-band legal and program (as a human endeavor, not a technical skill) knowledge. Most "revolving door" activity in DC centers around these areas of expertise and influence (politics, connections, legalese), as far as I have observed from my distant perch.
- nanomage 12y agoI can't wait for the patent paperwork to come out. I see it just showing up in open-source security distros.