30 ms·
So technically is it illegal to sing happy birthday at a family gathering? That's amazing. Almost seems like censorship?
by mrfusion 12y ago
So technically is it illegal to sing happy birthday at a family gathering? That's amazing. Almost seems like censorship?
- SEMW 12y agoIllegal, in the sense of a criminal offence? No. Breaching copyright is not a crime, except in a few circumstances (which vary from place to place, but often include e.g. commercial exploitation). It's generally a civil wrong. And it's probably not even a civil wrong. The acts restricted by copyright are limited and enumerated. E.g. you generally need a copyright licence to perform a work in public, to communicate it to the public, to lend it to the public, and of course to copy it (among others). In most places, you wouldn't need a licence to sing it at a private family gathering. Though IANAL.
- weego 12y agoThis would be a civil issue where you owe the copyright owner a fee. It is up to the owner to enforce use. It is literally nothing like censorship.
- catshirt 12y agowhere does copyright law draw the line? i ask because i have heard that specifically, it is illegal to recite happy birthday for commercial purposes. so, to use it on your YouTube video, for instance. but as far as i'm aware, Lady Gaga is well under copyright but i'm not breaking any laws by singing along when it's on the radio. so i don't see why it would be unlawful to sing happy birthday in a private setting, copyright or not. is my logic or information flawed?