4 ms·
"“If you have everything but land – if you have a population that is displaced – whether that allows you to be a state is a novel question,”" Well, I can think
by gambiting 12y ago
"“If you have everything but land – if you have a population that is displaced – whether that allows you to be a state is a novel question,”"
Well, I can think of our own example - Poland has been forcibly taken and split into three parts during late 18th century, by Russia, Prussia(Germany) and Austria. For nearly 20 years there was no such country as Poland on the map, and people who lived on the lands of former Poland were forbidden from even speaking Polish.
Yet the entire country has survived - we had a government and an army which both operated from other countries, until finally we were given little independence back in 1807 - but even after that Russia has controlled majority of the land here. Fast forward 200 years - Poland is a large country in the centre of Europe, despite having disappeared from every map for more than two decades at one point.
So based on that I would say that yes, there can be a nation without land.
- lmm 12y ago> For nearly 20 years there was no such country as Poland on the map, and people who lived on the lands of former Poland were forbidden from even speaking Polish. Sounds like Poland didn't exist at that time then, if there weren't even people speaking the language. To my mind a more relevant example would be various governments-in-exile. Wasn't there a case during WWII where a Canadian(?) hospital was redesignated as the territory as one of the occupied countries, so that a princess(?) born there could be legally born on native soil?
- pests 12y agoJust because speaking Polish is prohibited doesn't mean it wasn't spoken.
- gambiting 12y ago>>Sounds like Poland didn't exist at that time then, if there weren't even people speaking the language. Of course there were, they just had to do it at home, in secret. My point is, that the entire nation survived even though for two decades they couldn't even identify as Polish in public. And yes, we also had a government in exile during that time. Heck, we also had a government in exile during communist rule in Poland(1945-1989), which based its operations in London.
- lmm 12y ago> My point is, that the entire nation survived even though for two decades they couldn't even identify as Polish in public. How do you distinguish between a nation surviving, and a new nation being founded with the same name?
- gambiting 12y agoWell it's not like the Russians or the Prussians suddenly decided they wanted to start Poland again - it must have been Polish people who wanted that, so I think it's quite clear it was Polish people "surviving" long enough to see their country come back. I think new nation would apply if the people starting it had nothing to do with the original citizens? Like if someone wanted to create a country of Sparta now - it's not Spartans surviving, it's just a new country with an old name.
- GFischer 12y agoYour Sparta analogy has a real-world example in Macedonia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Macedonia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Macedonia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macedonia_naming_dispute http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macedonia_naming_dispute "Citing historical and territorial concerns resulting from the ambiguity between the Republic of Macedonia, the adjacent Greek region of Macedonia and the ancient Greek kingdom of Macedon which falls mostly within Greek Macedonia, Greece opposes the use of the name "Macedonia" by the Republic of Macedonia without a geographical qualifier, supporting a compound name such as "Northern Macedonia" for use by all and for all purposes" "..millions of ethnic Greeks identify themselves as Macedonians, unrelated to the Slavic people who are associated with the Republic of Macedonia, Greece further objects to the use of the term "Macedonian" for the neighboring country's largest ethnic group and its language. The Republic of Macedonia is accused of appropriating symbols and figures that are historically considered part of Greek culture such as the Vergina Sun and Alexander the Great"
- jessaustin 12y agoIt's not clear that modern-day Greeks themselves are closely related to ancient Macedonians. Certainly some of today's Greeks are descended from the Greeks of that time, but they're descended from a hundred other peoples who at that time lived in a hundred other places as well. Just like those who live in Macedonia today. Just like people all over the Earth who have some Mediterranean heritage. (We can probably exclude the Inuits, Pygmies, Aborigines, etc.) Your great-grandfather might not remember migrating from a thousand miles away, but that doesn't mean it didn't happen fifteen generations back.
- arethuza 12y agoApparently the Canadian government didn't have to make the maternity ward Netherlands territory - they simply had to make it "not Canada": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Princess_Margriet_of_the_Netherlands http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Princess_Margriet_of_the_Nether...
- Mvandenbergh 12y agoThe state of Poland didn't exist but Poles as a people, as a group with a distinct culture, language, and idea of themselves as a group did. So when they were able to, the Polish people re-constituted a state in which to live. That doesn't mean that the state of Poland existed in those years. Agreed that governments in exile are a better example.