Yes, that's an explicit move. That's what I mean by informing the VCS that you renamed a file. It amounts to holding the VCS's hand and means that even trivial

Yes, that's an explicit move. That's what I mean by informing the VCS that you renamed a file. It amounts to holding the VCS's hand and means that even trivial code rearrangements require considerable extra care, or explicit support for that precise VCS type from the IDE. Git and Mercurial autodetect moves, so you can freely use any regular tools you want to manipulate your files (command shell, Windows Explorer, Finder, IDE), and "git add -A" or "hg addremove" will properly record your changes.