2 ms·
A few more reasons raising a quiet/controversial seed round might be a good signal: 1. Publicly raising a large seed round creates a lot of hype when the produ
by chatmasta 12y ago
A few more reasons raising a quiet/controversial seed round might be a good signal:
1. Publicly raising a large seed round creates a lot of hype when the product might not be ready yet, or even before there's any product/market fit. As a founder, that creates a lot of pressure to satisfy the hype, and also might cause you to attempt building a product that satisfies the opinions of the blogosphere, rather than your customers. In contrast, when you raise a quiet round, you can build your product and achieve product/market fit without worrying about the outside world, instead focusing purely on your customers.
2. If no investors are questioning the model, you should be alarmed. Almost by definition, no company seeking a seed round has proven revenue model. Knowing this risk, you should expect some fraction of investors to be questioning it. If none are, then it's likely a signal that they've been swayed by smooth-talking founders who are very good at raising investment, but, as you mention, not necessarily fit or ready to build the business they're hyping.
So if we assume quiet seed rounds help with success, this leads to some questions about YC, which is essentially a loud seed round. Namely: should you announce your YC acceptance before you have product/market fit? Should you go through YC in stealth mode until ready to capitalize on hype?
It seems your observations can tell us a lot about the value, or anti-value, of product hype. The lesson seems to be, in the words of Denzel Washington/American Gangster, "the loudest person in the room is probably the weakest."