7 ms·
The trouble with non-profits
- MaysonL 17y agoOf course, if one looks at the profit-seeking world, one sees multiple examples of organizations blind to feedback: GM springs to mind these days.
- billswift 17y agoTrue, but responding to feedback is a lot harder than being aware of it. And especially so in a larger organization. I'm not so sure that GM's problems stemmed from not being aware of the problems as not being able to respond for various structural, legal, and social reasons.
- req2 17y agoSomewhat related, on charity: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=800663 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=800663
- wglb 17y agoThis is also interesting in how it relates to the study of airplane crashes and the strong, relatively immediate feedback that these provide. It seems that auto safety was much more slow to catch on, and required odd forces to bring the topic to the forefront. This also has an interesting interaction with a small startup essentially searching for the important metric for its survival.
- cwan 17y agoFor profits have the benefit of having profit/positive cash flow as a guide that not for profits do not. These are probably much better metrics for small startups given that success in any stated altruistic endeavours are ultimately going to show up in these two metrics anyway (and must in order for a startup to be sustainable).
- russell 17y agoI take his essay to mean that, if you want results, measure results and hold them to it. Chess experts are experts because they are measured by their results. Political pundits are hit hit or miss because they are not held accountable for their results. Non-profits should be measured by their results, not their process, PR, or grants. Makes sense to me, but quantifiable results are often hard to get, witness the discussions here about how to to tell goo programmers from bad.
- cwan 17y agoHaving worked extensively with not for profits, the biggest problem is the lack of accountability - this has as much to do with governance as metrics. Managers often have a say in the appointment of board members whereas at least power ultimately rests in shareholders in for profits. Then there's the problem of changing missions - take the number of family foundations that would have their original benefactors appalled (e.g. Ford, Rockefeller, etc.) And then another problem with metrics is that there has to be a cost benefit at some point. Obviously some are better than others, but if the cost to measure is as much to achieve, is it worth it? Though this may say as much about the mission as it does about the metric (microfinance is an area where this debate is raging).
- netsp 17y agomicrofinance is an area where this debate is raging Can you show me where?
- cwan 17y agoGoogle "commercialization" and "microfinance" - a debate that's directly related to "social metrics"/"social impact" - you should find a number of forums (consolidated at nabble; but there are also a number of articles that you can find at USAID funded http://www.microfinancegateway.org/ http://www.microfinancegateway.org/)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- 17y ago
- Dove 17y ago> This isn't to say that we should have companies replace nonprofits Yes we should. Charities I donate to are selling me a product just as much as companies I buy from. That the product is a better world--by some measure that seems reasonable to me, rather than a simple benefit for myself, matters not a whit to my decision making process. I don't give without a very concrete understanding of what the money will be used for, any more than I buy stock without a concrete understanding of what I'm buying and for how much. By all means, sell me peace, charity, and goodwill! Perhaps that will motivate you to learn how to produce it, and to convince me that you have done so.
- carbon8 17y agoIt's worth noting that "non-profit" doesn't always translate to charity. Microfinance, for instance, exists as a whole spectrum of quasi-for-profit operations. And on the strictly non-profit side you have things like ROSCAs, one of the foundations of microfinance, which are micro-level, semi-formal, non-charitable "non-profit" groups that resolve a number of different financial issues for participants, similar to tiny credit unions, and are neither charitable nor reasonably mappable to "companies." The whole impetus behind the growth of the microfinance movement is that traditional banking simply can't serve these groups. There are also numerous non-obvious major core issues involved, such as how gender roles have a huge impact on microfinance or why group lending is so prominent. In short, the reason it's not simply handled by companies is because it's just not that simple.
- Dove 17y agoOh, indeed, I'm well aware that there are for-profit philanthrophic ventures and questionably profitable non-profit groups. I don't mean to suggest that it is simple. Indeed, groups that adopt a hybrid, hard-to-classify approach often strike me as the healthiest. I am very fond of certain microloan groups or folks like TechnoServe. But I do advocate approaching philanthropy as a consumer, however the group you're working with is legally classified. Be honest with yourself about what you're buying -- even if what you're buying is a warm fuzzy feeling. Perhaps especially in that case.
- rapind 17y ago
- netsp 17y ago"This isn’t to say that we should have companies replace non-profits..." Actually, that is not necessarily a good thing to just sidestep. A lot of things that non profits work on might work better if they were worked on by companies. A lot of things that companies work on might have to be filled by non profits if companies weren't doing it. Think of second hand stores. They are often run not-for-profit in order to provide cheap stuff to poor people. These compete directly with commercial low cost stores and other second hand stores. If these beat the non profits, there is no societal loss. One of the worlds most celebrated not for profits, the Grameen Bank provides small loans to poor people. It seems very possible that this NGO (and its many imitators) will be put out of business by commercial banks. The UN has started a free online University to help the world's poor. I would take an either-or bet on for profit variants making a lot of progress on this issue commercially. A great way of making non profits more like chess masters is making non profits into businesses. You don't always have to. But if it is feasible, its worht considering.
- fatdog789 17y agoThe difference between a well-run non-profit and a well-run business: the non-profit puts 100% of profits back into its operations, while the business may re-invest the profit or distribute it to its owners. Most states already require non-profits to operate like businesses; indeed, non-profits are expected to operate better than businesses -- most states require non-profits to maintain levels of capitalization that require devilish efficiency and reuse.
- skybrian 17y agoA bigger difference is that the donors aren't the customers. A charity has positive cash flow so long as it pleases its donors, who don't necessarily know what's really happening with the people who receive the charity's services.
- fatdog789 17y agoI don't think you understand quite how the donor-charity relationship works. The donors are the customers. The charity earns money by pleasing the donors. The venue for pleasing the donors is by performing charitable acts. If a donor is pissed, it will force the charity to conform to his/her demands. The recipients of the charity's services are usually an afterthought, b/c they are far more easily replaced than any donor.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- netsp 17y agoDoes anyone have a recommendation for a charity with demonstrable results in improving the lives of people in a measurable way?
- fatdog789 17y agoHomeboys Industries, in Los Angeles, which has been very successful in transforming ex-gangbangers and low-income youth into productive members of society. Legal Aid (anywhere) assists asylum-seekers, wrongfully evicted tenants, and indigents needing legal services. Microfinancing (non-US operations) in India, China, and the Southeast have done so well that the pioneer of microfinancing received a Nobel.
- tokenadult 17y agoNearly any education reform organization that gets parents talking to other parents through channels not controlled by schools. Often parents can do a lot of self-help without public resources as soon as they can compare notes about what works to help children who need help. Setting up an email list and moderating it can be just about free, and often has great effect. One example: http://homeschoolers.org/ http://homeschoolers.org/ Another example: http://www.mcgt.net/index.html http://www.mcgt.net/index.html A third example, with more expensive programs besides the kind of program I just mentioned: http://www.davidsongifted.org/ http://www.davidsongifted.org/ After edit: To relate what I say here to what was said in the submitted article, an organization that gets all of its members talking to one another freely through one-to-many, many-to-one, and one-to-one channels available to all members gets a LOT of feedback that other organizations don't get, and learns what works and what doesn't work.
- aaronsw 17y agohttp://givewell.net/ http://givewell.net/ investigates charities to make sure they achieve demonstrable results, they have a list of those that do. There are also meta-charities like GiveWell and the MIT Poverty Action Lab that investigate other charitable attempts.
- blasdel 17y agoFuck that noise -- if you'd have even bothered to google their name, you'd have found that Givewell are total scumbags: http://metatalk.metafilter.com/15547/GiveWell-or-Give-em-Hell http://metatalk.metafilter.com/15547/GiveWell-or-Give-em-Hel... Summaries: http://mssv.net/wiki/index.php/Givewell http://mssv.net/wiki/index.php/Givewell They got caught out because they were blatantly astroturfing for themselves and slagging 'competing' charities all over the web. Then it turns out that even by their own generous accounting, more than half of their funds goes directly to their own overhead. On top of that, their 'research' is at best based on getting charities to rigorously assess themselves. Their rubberstamp board publicly (in the NYT) pretended to fire one of the founders, but less than a year later he was quietly back at his old position.
- riffer 17y agoThis is extensible well beyond non-profits. The general form is still rough in my mind but it is something like "avoid situations where accountability and feedback mechanisms are not essential parts of the environment"
- chasingsparks 17y agoI would argue that there is a second, equally-important, albeit interrelated, problem with non-profits in general: they are highly risk averse. Many non-profits still operate under a create an endowment and dispense funds to proven -- or at least perceptive -- good projects model. Consequently, there is a "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" mentality, which is to say weak experimentation. I should mention that most of my non-profit experience deals with medical research foundations. Political think tanks are limited by the general impossibility of proving all but trivial problems.
- tokenadult 17y agoAs a board member of two very active nonprofit organizations, and former board member of another, I really appreciate the suggestion to devote attention to demonstrable results. I'll bring that up at our next board meeting for each organization. It's easy to track membership, and reasonably routine to track member satisfaction in membership organizations, and some organizations set policy goals (within the scope of the IRS rules about political activity by some kinds of nonprofits) that are verifiable. But, yes, organizations doing work far from most supporters (e.g., foreign relief organizations or missionary organizations) often can gain funds for years without having to show results. It's regrettable when a willing donor isn't giving money to best effect.
- jseliger 17y ago"But, yes, organizations doing work far from most supporters (e.g., foreign relief organizations or missionary organizations) often can gain funds for years without having to show results. It's regrettable when a willing donor isn't giving money to best effect." Not to be a shill for my own blog again, but the reason so few organizations run real evaluations is that it's really, really hard, expensive, and time-consuming to do. Consequently, funders by and large don't offer real money or incentives for it, and if they don't, there's not much of an impetus to improve, and I describe this basic idea in much greater detail here: http://blog.seliger.com/2008/04/24/studying-programs-is-hard-to-do-why-its-hard-to-write-a-compelling-evaluation http://blog.seliger.com/2008/04/24/studying-programs-is-hard... Furthermore, some funders don't want real evaluations, even if they say otherwise; for example, we wrote a bunch of Community-Based Abstinence Education proposals for various clients, where the main purpose of the evaluation was to try and demonstrate that abstinence-only education works, and I described the problems with that in this post: http://blog.seliger.com/2008/10/12/what-to-do-when-research-indicates-your-approach-is-unlikely-to-succeed-part-i-of-a-case-study-on-the-community-based-abstinence-education-program-rfp http://blog.seliger.com/2008/10/12/what-to-do-when-research-...
- cturner 17y agoThe pool of funds is often not fixed. A non-profit can make themselves more competitive for available funds by providing metrics.
- joanna 17y agoAnother important thing to remember when comparing non-profits and companies is the power of the customer. Companies go bankrupt because the customer has the power to discontinue their patronage if they deliver a product or service poorly (unless there are anticompetitive practices in play - ahem comcast). However, in the non-profit world the recipient of the service or products has very little power to motivate a market. Those who contribute money to non-profits could theoretically be this force, but does someone who wants to invest in reducing malaria really have to invest in understanding the health metrics and do this assessment with each investment? I don't think that is a permanent solution either. No doubt feedback and accountability are vital to making non-profts more successful, but let's challenge ourselves to think of a more systematic way to implement this type of change rather than summing with measurement is needed.
- jseliger 17y agoWhat you're really addressing is the issue of incentives, as economists call it, and so is the original author of the story. I wrote this comment on his blog: To my mind, this isn't news, but that might be in part because I've worked in my family's grant writing firm for so long. The real issue you're discussing is one of incentives: nonprofits don't have much incentive to measure how well they're doing because funders don't demand that they do, or at least don't as a large group. If the funder is federal, state, or local, the funder doesn't have the resources (or the brains) to really measure effectiveness; if the funder is a foundation, the funder probably cares more about the appearance of doing good than effectiveness. I've addressed this point in some detail here: http://blog.seliger.com/2008/01/04/more-on-charities http://blog.seliger.com/2008/01/04/more-on-charities and here: http://blog.seliger.com/2008/01/23/foundations-and-the-future http://blog.seliger.com/2008/01/23/foundations-and-the-futur... . The blow, which I contribute to, deals with the issues you raise on a regular basis, and if you want to learn more about why things are the way they are at the moment, take a look at the archives.
- stcredzero 17y agoCompanies go bankrupt because the customer has the power to discontinue their patronage if they deliver a product or service poorly This definitely happens to many kinds of non-profit! in the non-profit world the recipient of the service or products has very little power to motivate a market. For 501-c3 organizations that provide classes, lectures, and performances, often the opposite is the case. Many non-profits have to be run much like a business. There can be something like a marketplace where the "customer" pays not with currency, but with their time. (And sometimes, both money and time are involved.) Also, very often, the "recipient" of services can easily directly involve themselves with running the organization. (KPFT radio in Houston is an example of this.)
- enra 17y agoThis is why I don't donate. Charities usually don't publish exact reports what's the money is used on and what have they achieved. Building schools doesn't help if you don't hire teachers and get kids attend school and money used on clever guilt marketing doesn't solve ecological problems.
- chaostheory 17y ago"Making a bad prediction isn’t like that... it’s months or years before your prediction is proven wrong. And then, you make yourself feel better by coming up with some explanation for why you were wrong: ...And so you keep on making predictions in the same way — which means you never get good at it." I think this also applies to many macro-economists
- yankeeracer73 17y agoA good book just came out about this very issue: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0470454679/ref=ox_ya_os_product http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0470454679/ref=ox_ya_os_pro...
- baran 17y agoThis is one of the reasons why non-profit companies are flawed. There are no incentives in place for monetary gain. Non-profits are good at raising awareness, not being a sustainable entity. If someone wants to make a difference and change world (especially developing countries), I believe there has to be financial incentives : social entrepreneurship.
- billswift 17y agoIf you can't make money doing something, is there any good evidence that it is worth doing at all? Leaving aside goods with "free" competition from the gov't (schools, roads, libraries, etc). EDIT: Also leaving aside things you do for your more direct benefit, like growing your own food or contributing to open source projects you use.
- cwan 17y agoThere are cases where charity in its more pure forms are important - I do think from time to time that individuals need help as a result of an event that may be no fault of their own. I personally try to be compassionate - but I don't think we should shame/force people to be charitable - and even in implementation, local not-for-profits tend to be far more efficient than government at assessing needs and addressing them. When it comes to foreign relief/charities, it's a really tough call. On one hand, oppressive governments are incentivized to actively show their people at their worst so that they can get more money and in turn collect graft (e.g. Saddam Hussein and baby incubators), but on the other what are the rest of us supposed to do? Let these people die? We play right into the hands of their governments when we don't. Following natural disasters, war/strife, I also personally feel a strong need to help. In these scenarios, there can be no room for sustainable profit because they tend to be unique/unusual events.
- billswift 17y agoI have nothing against helping in emergencies, but Ayn Rand had a good essay on that - emergencies are situations outside of normal operations and the response to an emergency should be working to end the emergency situation.
- daydream 17y ago"But it does mean that if you’re involved in nonprofits (or predictions), you need to be much more careful about making sure you’re doing a good job. Unfortunately, few nonprofits do that." Oh really? So he can cite research that says, for example, that only x% (where x < 50%) of nonprofits with an annual budget of $500k have ever done any sort of evaluation, either comprehensive or more basic? His assertion may be true. But just throwing this out there with absolutely nothing to back it up, in a blog post titled "The Trouble With Nonprofits", is frankly insulting to me. I spent > 4 years working in a technical role for a nonprofit, and I can assure people that measurement and evaluation were very much on the minds of staffers. Everyone (funders, management) was becoming more data-driven, so our organization got a grant to conduct a multi-year evaluation. It was a very positive and necessary process, and the results were very positive. Like Aaron, I definitely recommend some sort of measurable goals for most every nonprofit out there. I don't take issue with his opinion. What I take issue with is the tone of the article. For example: "...but an actual attempt to measure how much they’re improving people’s lives. For most nonprofits, I expect these numbers will be depressingly small. " It can be easy, as young paragons of technology and entrepreneurship, to look over to the nonprofit world and disparage it, to think of it and it's practitioners as "lesser than". I should know; it's the attitude I had before I started working at a nonprofit. Truth is, running a nonprofit can be a hell of a lot harder than running a for-profit. At any stage, you have all the issues that for-profits have - hiring, firing, managing employees, management issues, getting money in the door, technological problems - PLUS a whole other layer. A lot of this other layer comes because of the weak link between financial health and results. Am I accomplishing my mission? How do I measure success? How do I maximize success based on dollar spent? How do I judge where to allocate capital or resources - when maximizing revenue isn't a goal? Why am I wasting my time writing this? Because this article uses a lot of conjecture and one very poor example to make the entire nonprofit sector seem like a bunch of bumbling idiots who don't know how to use spreadsheets. They're not, and it's not fair for this community to see such a distorted view.
- neeson 17y agoI've worked at two social ventures that had non-profits as clients (Web Networks, and most recently Urbantastic.com). There emphatically is something wrong with non-profits. Just because there are some excellent ones (Sturgeon's law applies) doesn't mean that the field at large isn't ill. An anecdote: we had a meeting with a guy who worked at a large company with a philanthropic streak. They provided, free of charge, a "dashboard" for planning, along with free training and tech support to any non-profit that wanted it (it cost considerable money otherwise). It was simple but very powerful, allowing you to do sensitivity analyses on projections to determine which courses of action would result in the best returns - both monetary and any other metric you wanted to put in (i.e. the social goals of the project). It was like he was selling popsicles at an ice rink. We ran into a very similar issue with Urbantastic. We had a web service that was very effective at getting small things done for non-profits: it's called micro-volunteering. There's no supervision required, you just write down what you want and someone always did it. When we founded Urbantastic we thought the challenge was going to be in getting skilled people to help out for free. That was not a problem. The problem was that we'd go up to non-profits and say: here's a machine where all you have to do is post your todo list, and people will cross off items for you. For free. And we never got uptake. People lined out the door offering to help, and almost no one took them up on it. Despite our offers to walk non-profits through it, and despite the recent funding cuts which meant that they needed all the help they could get. I'm not saying that Urbantastic is perfect, but in our pilot cities this was overwhelmingly the result, and I still can't think of any incremental change that we could have done to get the non-profits engaged. A big part of it was that most of them were still uncertain about the whole email thing. It's not an exaggeration to say that some of them didn't know how to use a spreadsheet. With our fancy web 2.0 ajaxy website, we felt like we were giving out iTunes gift cards to the lost tribes of Papua New Guinea. They didn't value it because they weren't even close to being at the point where they could use it. I care about social good - I wouldn't have founded a social venture if not. And twice now I've been floored by the state of the non-profit world. Again, 10% of them are brilliant, but the other 90%... It's a big problem, and it's not going to get better by pretending that it's not there. That world is amazingly backwards. And it's saddening to see such important mandates being handled by such ineffective organizations. My advice to anyone here planning on doing a social venture: drop backwards compatibility with the non-profit world. (one giant caveat: working exclusively with one or two of the few clued-in orgs might work).
- fhars 17y agoThere is of coure a very important problem charities trying to do this kind of measurments of efficiency face. They are in a market for public perceptiom to get donations, and (if we take the numbers the article cites for Oxfam), can you imagine the loss of donations and goodwill after a few newspapers and TV programs run the headline "Charity X spends half their donations on statistics instead of helping people!"? Even if the costs could be amortized over a few years, the charity would be dead by then. Perverse incentive factors, again. (And the news might be right, collecting in depth statistics about the help program might just be a pretext to give a lucrative consulting contract to the director's best friend).