11 ms·
Tesla's Model 3
- exDM69 12y agoThe SUV is the perfect "form factor" for an electric vehicle because they are typically large and heavy so the big battery pack will not hurt so much in the weight budget. The Model S weighs in at around 2100kg, when similarly sized cars with internal combustion engines are around 1400-1700kg. The Model 3 has potential to shift the whole market if they can provide a practical electric family car for the average people living in suburban areas.
- pilom 12y agoI completely disagree on the SUV being the perfect "form factor" for electric. At least if the SUV is being used for things like carrying gear for an excursion or off-roading. In those cases, it is a terrible form factor (especially with the gull-wing doors that prevent you from using a roof rack). Off-roading isn't as efficient at regenerative braking compared to stop and go traffic in an urban area. They go to areas not at all served by charging facilities let alone superchargers. They generally need even greater range than urban only cars. All of these things make an electric SUV not the SUV for me. If you just mean the silly way Americans use SUV's (to simply be taller than the other cars on the road) then maybe it is a decent form factor.
- saucetenuto 12y agoWell, they're selling it in America, right? So American behavior shapes their opportunities, even if it is silly.
- Mvandenbergh 12y agoMost SUVs will never see a day of offroad driving in their lives. That's good because most of them aren't suited for it in a stock configuration anyway.
- tormeh 12y agoYeah, the people who actually go offroad use Mercedes Gelandewagen or the less consumerized models from Land Rover and Jeep.
- freehunter 12y agoOr a Toyota 4Runner, which is built for trail use from the factory. So much that they lost sales in the few years they tried tuning it for the road.
- jmartinpetersen 12y agoLots of SUV's are bound to the concrete jungle, I doubt it is an american phenomenon. I see loads of SUV's incapable of going off-road here in Denmark, and I doubt the more southern parts of Europe are different.
- ghshephard 12y agoI don't know if it's "Silly" or not, but you are correct that Americans, in general, do not use SUVs for "Offroading."
- gtaylor 12y agoThough, I think we're starting to see a lot more crossovers appear in the US (as opposed to full-sized SUVs). A crossover doesn't imply off-roading prowess, as one of the common characteristics of a crossover is being built on a car platform. I'm hearing the term more in everyday discussion, and I'm seeing as many or more crossovers than SUVs these days in the US southeast.
- blt 12y agoNo, most Tesla SUV drivers will not go off road. The Model X is a "crossover" SUV with very limited off-road capability. You can tell in photos: its ground clearance is low and it doesn't have large suspension travel. It's going to take sales from the Lexus RX, Mercedes M-Class, BMW X series, etc. Nobody takes those cars off-road. I used to share your disdain for SUVs until I dated someone who drove one. They can be really useful for carrying cargo and the smaller ones get decent fuel economy. That said, I think a lot of SUV buyers are motivated by fear. They feel that collisions are inevitable so they want to drive a big armored box. They want 4WD even here in the Southern USA where it snows 2 days per year. I think a lot of them have kids and it's one more part of the protective worrying parent mentality. Personally I can't stand the handling of tall vehicles.
- rayiner 12y ago> Personally I can't stand the handling of tall vehicles. There was a time when I loved the handling of my 3-series with sport suspension. Now, I just want something that makes my toddler less pukey on these shitty northeastern roads.
- caw 12y agoWhether it's a crossover based on a truck or car platform makes a difference. My girlfriend's crossover is on a truck platform, and handles like one. We recently test drove a newer crossover built on a sedan platform, and it drives more like a sedan.
- cpwright 12y agoOr you use the SUV to carry your kids and stuff around. An SUV is bigger and more comfortable than most cars. - Easier to fit car seats and people in - Seats 8 (as opposed to 5) on the rare occasion that you want to - Has four wheel drive, so handles better in the snow - Has a trailer hitch for your bike rack, which is more convenient than trunk mounted ones. - A roof rack for sheet goods - Enough cargo space for suitcases, moving, or a trip to the home center You can get by with a smaller car, but the SUV form factor provides lots of capability, which is nice to have whenever you want it. I've got one sedan (an Accord) and an SUV (a Pilot), both have their place.
- bitJericho 12y agoThat's what a minivan is for.
- dpark 12y agoYeah, but then you're driving a minivan.
- kbenson 12y agoWhich really isn't that bad. Slightly less ride comfort than some SUVs, but better interior luxuries for the price and much more versatile in an urban environment, with better gas mileage. Really, the worst thing about driving a minivan is other drivers. People have such a perception of minivans being slow and pokey that people will attempt to pass you on the freeway regardless of the speed you are travelling. If you drive a minivan and another vehicle on a regular basis, how other cars treat you is very noticeable.
- bitJericho 12y agoNever had a problem in my area with that. I will say a minivan far surpasses an SUV in usefulness though. I liken a minvan to a pickup truck that you can actually seat people inside of. It's great, you can haul anything you can imagine, beds, freezers, couches, and if you're not busy hauling giant appliances around, you can put the seats in and haul around a bunch of people. The gas mileage is on par with an SUV, and you never get any flack from the police. Who's gonna bother a someone in a minivan? Nobody that's who.
- netcan 12y agoSlight sidetone: The reaction to this comment is really depressing. Obviously exDM69 means 'perfect' in a certain context. IE, does being electric make an SUV better at being an SUV and doing the things that the people who own SUVs, own them for. The comments and voting can't help but be all about how people feel about SUVs in general.
- seanflyon 12y agoPeople are pointing out the difference between what "people who own SUVs, own them for" and what people actually do with SUVs.
- exDM69 12y ago> I completely disagree on the SUV being the perfect "form factor" for electric. At least if the SUV is being used for things like carrying gear for an excursion or off-roading. Most SUVs are driven by soccer moms taking their kids to school. That's the "form factor" I intended in GP. If we would be talking about an off road vehicle, I'd agree with you.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ensignavenger 12y agoI don't consider the Model X a true SUV. Tesla calls it a "crossover" which I suppose is the industry lingo for fake SUV's like the Model X. I can see how it would be a good alternative to a minivan, though. So maybe they should call it a "crossover" minivan? (I suppose calling it a minivan wouldn't be as attractive as SUV.)
- dragonwriter 12y agoA "crossover" is the industry term for what amounts to a station wagon with SUV-like styling. "Minivan" and (non-"crossover") "SUV" are two names for what amounts to a station wagon built on light-truck frames -- with originally somewhat different demographic targeting in the marketing, but eventually the "SUV" class's marketing broadened to subsume the target that minivan marketing had been focussed on -- originally to fit loopholes in passenger safety and efficiency regulations (which have since largely been closed, hence, the emergence of the "crossover", which was a reversion since the expense of the regulatory dodge was no longer particularly useful.)
- personZ 12y agothe silly way Americans use SUV's (to simply be taller than the other cars on the road) Everyone I know who owns an SUV has multiple children. I have four children, and with that a minivan and an SUV. Kids come with a lot of accessories, especially with modern safety requirements of car seats and so on. It is really unfortunate that every discussion about SUVs turns into some sort of oddball moralizing (especially bizarre when they're contrast with minivans, also 5000lb+ vehicles with largely the same fuel economy). SUVs actually have a very practical purpose. They of course use more fuel, generally, though on the flip side that awareness of fuel makes me less likely to take flippant drives (all things tend to equalize, generally).
- dragonwriter 12y ago> If you just mean the silly way Americans use SUV's (to simply be taller than the other cars on the road) then maybe it is a decent form factor. Americans don't really buy SUVs for any rational reason, there was just a period of very intense propaganda directed at creating the idea that they needed SUVs as an attempt by the auto industry to get around US government safety and efficiency regulations from which "light trucks", which SUVs were carefully designed to qualify as, were exempted (Minivans where an earlier focus of the same PR effort, for the same reason.) ("Crossovers" are basically what happened when the original motivation was gone but the industry had already created the demand, so they went back to making passenger autos that weren't built on truck frames, but still had to make them styled like SUVs to sell in the market conditions their own intense marketing efforts had created -- since that was cheaper than doing another marketing blitz to get people to stop wanting things that look like SUVs.)
- Shorel 12y agoIn terms of real usefulness, it is a horrid "form factor" that wastes fuel and space, electric or not. In terms of market, it can be the most successful vehicle for the American market. These are two separate things.
- gambiting 12y ago>In terms of real usefulness, it is a horrid "form factor" that wastes fuel and space I never understood this. I used to drive a Land Rover Discovery 3, which is a SUV. And then I had a rental Open(or Vauxhall, for UK folk) Insignia for two weeks - your typical 5 door sedan, a typical "car" which does not invoke hate in most people. And I could not possibly understand how such a "large" car, with footprint as large as my Land Rover, could be so small inside! It took as much space on the road as my "horrid waste of space" Land Rover, yet it could only take 5 people instead of 7, and probably half the luggage. But if you put these two next two each other, you would be a lot more quickly criticized for driving the SUV, purely because it's an SUV. But both cars had nearly identical length and width - so how is the SUV taking more space? If anything, the Insignia was half as practical as the land rover.
- Shorel 12y ago> yet it could only take 5 people instead of 7 And both of them usually only carry one, the driver. That's the main issue.
- gambiting 12y agoSo what is the solution? Have one small car when you are driving alone,and one huge for driving with family? That works somewhat - but I am fairly certain that the ecological impact of producing two cars is larger than that of driving one oversized one.
- Vik1ng 12y agoheavy so the big battery pack will not hurt so much in the weight budget. Wrong! Very wrong! More initial weight means more batteries needed in the first places, which means more weight and even more batteries because of that. Reducing weight on electric cars is really beneficial: Less weight => less batteries => less weight => less batteries...
- dm2 12y agoI'm sure weight matters a little but torque is what gets the vehicle moving and regenerative breaking puts more back into the batteries with more weight. Aerodynamics seem to be a more critical factor for electric vehicles. You want the vehicle to be able to cruise while using as little energy as possible, and weight doesn't matter as much for maintaining speed. It's the same reason that most modern trains are electric or diesel-electric rather than pure diesel. Many aircraft tow tractors are also electric these days, and they haul some fairly heavy loads.
- morsch 12y agoYou realize of course that regenerative braking puts more* back into the batteries for heavier vehicles only because a lot more was necessary to speed them up in the first place?
- dm2 12y agoI do realize that regenerative breaking does not 100% cancel out the energy required to accelerate the vehicle. The Model X will be ~10% heavier and Musk has stated recently that the range is expected to be ~10% less than that of the Model S. In other words, obviously a heavier vehicle will use more power than a lighter vehicle, that's true with any fuel source, but it's a small difference in this case. They could put a battery pack with 15% more capacity in it and the range would be about the same as the Model S, but they're probably going to use the same battery as the Model S for compatibility and manufacturing reasons.
- eqdw 12y agoThe tyranny of the battery equation?
- cenhyperion 12y ago> The Model 3 has potential to shift the whole market if they can provide a practical electric family car for the average people living in suburban areas. I actually don't think the target audience is families living in suburban areas. That's not the target audience of the BMW 3 series or Benz C class. I think their target audience is young professionals who can't afford a car that quickly costs over $100k but care about driving a practical, electric, professional car.
- dm2 12y agoNot just young professionals but technology lovers who are not millionaires. The car has it's own API and the cost savings verses a normal ICE vehicle could really add up in this newer low cost vehicle. No oil, gasoline, etc.
- rdl 12y agoEven though I could (barely) afford a Model S, I don't want one due to size. I think that is a market; people who like small, sporty, luxury cars, are relatively price insensitive ($40k vs. $60k for the Model III is insignificant to me; I'll keep it for 5-10y and drive 150-200k miles, so fuel/maintenance/etc. savings dominate purchase price), etc.
- dm2 12y agoIt'll be good for towing also. Electric vehicles are excellent for towing, I've seen lots of places use normal electric golf carts to tow huge boats, it's all about torque.
- zarkov99 12y agoThe weight of the model S is pretty much irrelevant in day to day driving. Handling is fantastic. SUVs are more challenging as electric vehicles because for most families they are the default road-trip vehicles and, at least for now, long road trips, as opposed to daily commutes, are a little more inconvenient for electric cars.
- Shivetya 12y agoLets be honest here, if we are having to stay so large to get any real range from batteries then the tech truly isn't ready yet. One reason I haven't been all that impressed with the S is because even as large as it is its only 250 or so miles per charge. Some of the elements in its design are really good, but battery storage isn't prime time when it takes the majority of the car to get so little range. Call me when the tech will take a Focus/Leaf sized EV near 300 miles for around 30k, then I will listen. Right now the only good bet is a range extender, fortunately the two big ones; i3 and Leaf, are affordable by a great many more drivers.
- larrys 12y ago"The SUV is the perfect "form factor" for an electric vehicle because" Don't agree. SUV has big wind drag (not sure if that is the right word for it) which reducing efficiency in gas powered vehicles. I can't imagine that it isn't the same effect in electric powered. (I mean that's obvious, right or am I missing something?)
- kmfrk 12y agoPay- or registration-walled, alas.
- MrBuddyCasino 12y ago"Open in incognito window" did the trick for me.
- kmfrk 12y agoDid the trick. Thanks.
- davidw 12y agoFWIW, The Economist is a pretty good magazine (err, I mean "newspaper"), worth subscribing to.
- bellerocky 12y agoI get that it might be, but if I subscribed to all these news sites, the nytimes, the wsj, the economist, the information, the financial times, I'd be out a lot of money each month for what is basically an "I don't know how to use the icognito tab on my browser"-tax. I want to support these sites but they are too expensive, and it's too easy to circumvent their paywall. I actually subscribed to the nytimes for a month and I felt stupid for it, which is a weird feeling to have about it. The Information has a real pay wall, and it's actually the most expensive out of this list, but if I subscribed to it, at least I wouldn't feel like a jackass for doing so. These companies want the Google crawling and the subscription fees, but it seems like you can only have one.
- ghshephard 12y agoSo, you are saying, if the NYT did not allow casual use, then you would be fine paying for it, but the fact that it allows you to check out the site 5-10 times/month for free, means that you are not okay paying for it. Have you considered that if you are reading the site so often that you need to keep killing your cookies, that you perhaps might be getting some value from the site, and it wouldn't be unreasonable for you to to reward the creators of such great content?
- scragg 12y agoThe $35,000 will be starting after rebate, so $42,500 out the door with zero upgrades. I'm pessimistic they can get that low of a price with 300 mile range, so I'm predicting that is an optional battery upgrade from the base price. There are options you will want like the tech package which is $3k+ on the S. I snagged a 40kwh S before they discontinued it. Had it for a year, never needed to charge anywhere but my home. I get about 135 miles on a charge and it has been more then enough for commutes around the metro.
- NickM 12y agoThe $35,000 will be starting after rebate Citation? You might be right, but I thought I read that 35k was before the tax credit. For that matter, I believe the current EV tax credit is only available for the first X number of EVs produced by a given manufacturer. It's possible the same credit won't be available anymore by the time the 3 comes out. Or on the other hand, there have been talks of raising the credit to 10k and making it permanent. Hard to know what will happen in the next few years.
- johnward 12y agoTesla always advertises the after rebate price. Nothing makes me think they would change that now. You are right that it is possible the rebate won't be available when this launches. I also doubt they can hit 2017 but we will see I guess. If they could do come close to launch, actually hit that price with no rebate, and hit the 300 mile claim I would be very impressed (and in line to buy) but I think all of that is not adding up. edit: according to a post above Tesla said they were not including the tax rebates. So that means you could get into a Model 3 for $27k. I really don't see how they can do that and 300mile range. That's a huge price cut from a model s. Makes me think it's not going to be up to the same quality/luxury feel that the model S has.
- speeq 12y agoSource? This is what they said during one of their earnings calls: Barclays Capital – Question about $35,000 price point – before or after tax credits? Deepak Ahuja (CFO): The $35,000 does not assume that the $7,500 federal tax credit is no longer available, but that the 35,000 Tesla Gen 3 pricing is without any subsidy. Elon Musk: Helpful to have credits, but Tesla is not counting on them. The tax credit applies for the first 250,000 (domestic?) units per manufacturer though, so if you pre-order a Model 三 you might be able to get it for $27,500.
- Aardwolf 12y ago"the car was going to be called the Model E, until Ford said it already had that name trademarked" (...) "We'll have three bars to represent it and it'll be S III X!" 3 also happens to be the '1337' slang variant of E.
- Thiz 12y agoYep. S3X doesn't look bad to me.
- ranran876 12y agoNot to be a contrarian, but there isn't really any reason to believe that the Model 3 will be any better than the already-on-the-market Nissan Leaf. Tesla hasn't really invented any new technology here that would be a game changer. The vague claim of a "closer alliance of Tesla and its battery supplier" isn't going to suddenly double the mileage when compared to the Lead- and it's not like Nissan hasn't been streamlining their production process for the past few years either. The Model S is exceptional in that you can pay a ton of money and get an electric car with a very respectable range. But that doesn't really scale down when - like the article points out - most of the cost is in the battery.
- aetherson 12y agoOn a technical note, you mean range, not mileage. I don't think that anyone is claiming that the Model 3 will have electrical motors that are twice as efficient as the Leaf's motors or anything -- the claim is that it will have batteries that hold more energy than the Leaf's. I think you're right to be at least a little skeptical of the Model 3. For one, it seems like something of a stretch to say that they'll be on-the-market in 3.5 years with a vehicle that will feature batteries from a factory that hasn't even found a site yet. That said, I imagine that the Leaf will have a better range in 2017 as well. It seems clear at this point that better battery tech is the final hurdle for electric vehicles. It doesn't seem completely implausible that with a lot of resources thrown at the problem, they'll be able to lower the cost of increasing the energy capacity of batteries in the next few years.
- matthewaustin 12y agoI disagree with your assessment that Tesla doesn't have any new technology that will improve their efficiency over Nissan. Tesla builds their own powertrains and battery management systems, which are good enough that other automakers license or purchase these components from them. I also believe that Tesla has efficiency advantages due to the high degree of automation they've built into their factories, as well as the lack of dealership markups. Tesla's profit margin on the Model S is excellent compared to many other automakers, which leads me to believe that they will also be able to offer more for less with the Model 3.