4 ms·
>In the case of QM versus GR we have the very weird situation where we have two theories that are logically incompatible with each other, so we know at least on
by trhway 12y ago
>In the case of QM versus GR we have the very weird situation where we have two theories that are logically incompatible with each other, so we know at least one of them must be wrong
nope. Incompatible are only stretches of the theories into the areas where conditions contradict basic assumptions of the theories.
QM assumes fixed space-time which we know isn't true, so the QM can be true only where the difference between fixed space-time and real one is negligeable, ie. small scale/local effects. (And even at the small scale, assumption of the fixed space-time may be very limiting - who knows, may be powerful forces at local level do "bad" things to space-time too and this would be an explanation for the things like non-separability of quarks or a for a lot of others "strange" effects observed at quantum level).
GR is about real, non-fixed space-time and disregards any forces/interactions other than gravitation. Thus it is not correct when applied at local scales where other interactions overpower gravitation.
Thus stretching GR into small scale just makes a wrong physical theory the same way as stretching QM into GR space makes for a wrong theory too.
- lisper 12y agoWhat you say is true, but it is also true that they are logically incompatible. GR assumes that matter is precisely localized and QM assumes that it is not. They can't both be right (and in fact we know that GR is wrong about this). So, for example, GR predicts that the interior of a black hole contains a singularity at a precise location, while QM (via the Heisenberg uncertainty principle) says that this is impossible.