3 ms·
The article is wrong on a key point. Stingrays don't "force" your cell phone to do anything. Your cell phone reaches out and connects to it of its own accord. T
by nitrogen 12y ago
The article is wrong on a key point. Stingrays don't "force" your cell phone to do anything. Your cell phone reaches out and connects to it of its own accord. The Stingray doesn't reach out and collect private data from your phone. Your phone transmits your private data into the aether at the user's direction.
How do you reconcile this techno-literalist interpretation of Stingray with your techno-intentionalist interpretation of the Aereo decisions[0][1]?
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7945159 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7945159 (referring to Aereo's "contrived" business model that is based on a strict view of the technology's function as a really long antenna cable)
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7944271 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7944271 (referring to Aereo using a "technicality")
[2] Other comments abound, but I didn't want to keep searching.
- rayiner 12y agoThe intention of the statute in Aereo is to cover things that act like cable companies. Similarly, the intention of the 4th amendment is to protect information that people try to keep private. Where I think I disagree with many people on HN is whether it is reasonable to believe that information on the internet as it is structured today is private. It simply wasn't designed that way. Our protocols and services leak private data to whoever exercises a little ingenuity in listening to it. Many leak private data by design (data mining for advertising, etc). In other words, I don't think the folks designing internet technology should get a free ride for 4th amendment purposes, that any internet technology should be considered private regardless of the technical reality. I think you have to concede that data sent in plain text, protocols that don't even try to avoid MITM attacks, services that mine user data, etc, shouldn't receive the same protection as services where real effort is taken to keep data private. I think this is educated by the technology and consistent with the intention of the 4th amendment that the expectation of privacy be objectively reasonable.
- bmelton 12y ago> that any internet technology should be considered private regardless of the technical reality I think that there's a pretty bright line distinction between "I read this message you posted on Twitter" and "I set up this fake cell phone tower to intercept the messages you thought you were sending privately through your cell phone carrier." Similarly, physical locks on doors may be easily circumvented, but that doesn't absolve a burglar of any wrongdoing.
- nitrogen 12y agoI think this is educated by the technology and consistent with the intention of the 4th amendment that the expectation of privacy be objectively reasonable. I thought the expectation of privacy was based on a so-called "reasonable person", not an objective definition of reasonable. Is that not so? Where I think I disagree with many people on HN is whether it is reasonable to believe that information on the internet as it is structured today is private. That disagreement seems to be evidence that there is a widespread expectation of privacy, even if the implementation doesn't perfectly preserve privacy. Especially with regard to the government, I think people could sanely expect privacy to be the default state (even for poorly implemented technology), with narrow exceptions for specific, targeted investigations of small numbers of individuals and well-defined groups.
- tedunangst 12y ago> That disagreement seems to be evidence that there is a widespread expectation of privacy, I think HN at times seriously confuses the concepts of expecting privacy and wanting privacy. Everybody says "I expect this to be private" but if you ask why, it seems the answer is "because I would like it to be private". I think it would help to sit down and explain exactly why one would expect radio waves being broadcast into space not to be picked up by anyone with a radio. (going back to aereo, was the HN consensus not "if they're transmitting their data into space, anyone with an antenna can do anything they like with it"?)
- nitrogen 12y agoI think HN at times seriously confuses the concepts of expecting privacy and wanting privacy. Everybody says "I expect this to be private" but if you ask why, it seems the answer is "because I would like it to be private". That should be enough. I think it would help to sit down and explain exactly why one would expect radio waves being broadcast into space not to be picked up by anyone with a radio. There are already laws that prohibit listening to certain wireless transmissions (e.g. satellite TV), which I'll assume for the sake this of argument is an acceptable tradeoff to society. While technology should be designed to minimize data leakage, laws should be designed to take user expectations into account. If, for example, cellphone UX provides every indication to the user that text messages are sent to a person (not to a network), then laws should treat those messages as private until a warrant is issued, even if they are sent in the clear. ...was the HN consensus not "if they're transmitting their data into space, anyone with an antenna can do anything they like with it"? No, it was "If I can install a very long antenna cable, and/or buy a Slingbox, and watch TV from my home market on my own device, then why can't I pay someone else to run the very long antenna cable and host the Slingbox for me?"