10 ms·
Employment rates for STEM Ph.D.s are down or stagnant across the board
- quizzas 12y agoToo indoctrinated by academia to be employed? Out of touch with corporate expectations? Or those who aren't a fit for employment returned to get their PhD, but only as a delay to the inevitable.
- raverbashing 12y agoPh.D. allowed for some things: - You can deepen your studies and study the state of the art of a given area - You can work in some area with all the support needed (equipment, etc) - Networking However, what's happening is: - The latest journals are a click away - A lot of experiments can be done in a computer setting nowadays - Evolution in some areas do not depend anymore on experimentation, and/or the cost for it has gone down. - Things are getting more complex and interdependent. To build the first integrated circuit you needed to know less about heat transfers and EM interference than today. Hence, I believe even the Ph.D. model is getting challenged, as specialists in a very narrow thing won't take things very far as they once did.
- Jweb_Guru 12y agoI think this is a very simplistic view that only holds for a very few areas of study. The idea that computer simulation is an adequate substitute for scientific experimentation in the majority of the sciences is puzzling to me. Not that models don't help, but there's still far too much we either don't know how to model, or don't have the computational power to model (or we have both, but it would be more expensive than just testing it in a lab). I also don't understand why your fourth point means that specialization is not necessary. Isn't it the opposite--that generalists with shallow knowledge of many fields no longer suffice? People must specialize because the level of complexity in newer technology is extremely high, and to get anywhere it is necessary to focus on a small but very detailed slice of the pie. The only really valid point is that information formerly available in journals is now available online. But I cannot say that I have seen a noticeable uptick in research being done by non-Ph.D.s despite this widespread availability, so I think it's at least premature to conclude that you can develop the same level of expertise as an autodidact.
- raverbashing 12y ago"The idea that computer simulation is an adequate substitute for scientific experimentation in the majority of the sciences is puzzling to me" Depends on the field. Even in natural sciences, there are several research areas not related directly with experimentation. I would say that, for a lot of areas, we have the bases covered, but what's needed are better tools to understand it. Protein folding is one area. The physics are ok, what we don't know is how to make it work for several atoms at once. Data transmission is another. The real changes behind 4G, 802.11N, etc, is not a better radio transmitter only, but better channel estimation, error correction and use of diversity. "I also don't understand why your fourth point means that specialization is not necessary" It is necessary, but not sufficient. If you only focus on one area but don't know how to interface with the necessary surroundings you won't get anywhere. " so I think it's at least premature to conclude that you can develop the same level of expertise as an autodidact." The application of new discoveries and techniques is important as well, and several companies and individuals are doing important work in this area. (Go, Rust, several machine learning libraries, etc)
- erkkie 12y agoI think saying specialization is necessary but not sufficient sums up the trends in many fields. The barriers of entry to having information available are the lowest they've ever been and thus traditional models are being eaten by ad-hoc methods. And that is fine, requires reorientation though.
- Thriptic 12y agoIt is basically impossible to do life sciences research outside of an academic or industry lab, and almost no academic lab will take on someone who is not a student or post-doc. An individual outside of academia would be unable to purchase supplies due to supplier restrictions, would lack access to journals without piracy, would have no access to expensive required analytical equipment, and would be unable to front the costs associated with regulatory compliance in a lab setting. While it's true that progress can be made from a simulation stand point, licenses to these software packages are enormously expensive. Without a university appointment or a well established track record, no one is going to be willing to share clinical data with you. Moreover, without any ability to validate the findings from your simulations in a lab / clinical setting, any results would be of questionable value. Most importantly, it would be extremely difficult for an individual not associated with a university or industry lab to publish their results in a top tier journal.
- raverbashing 12y agoOh I don't disagree with you, life sciences are an area where things will still work as you described for a long time.
- jnbiche 12y ago>While it's true that progress can be made from a simulation stand point, licenses to these software packages are enormously expensive. Can you specify which software you're referring to? For many life science sub-disciplines, there are an increasing number of either open source or low-cost competitors.
- pessimizer 12y agoThat's because the financial services sector sucks all of the air out of the room. Look forward to dismal growth for the next two generations as universities and the people who pay for people to go to universities start to raise entrance standards and prices in order to cut down on the supply. Higher education will get out of the reach of most people again, like it used to be. edit: I think specific marketing/financial/information services oriented programming/engineering jobs will survive well during this period. Other sciences are going to have to rely on stock fads, bubbles and scams to get any investment. edit2: It's sad that we're wasting our best performers and best minds like this. You can't have growth if you produce superior minds and squander their potential for making new discoveries or coming up with innovative designs or methods. China is run by engineers - just saying.
- asdfologist 12y agoWhat does the finance sector have to do with any of this? At MIT, for example, only 2% of PhDs go into finance: http://web.mit.edu/facts/alum.html http://web.mit.edu/facts/alum.html
- kjdbakjdab 12y agoIt seems like our conception of money has been damaged to a point where it's increasingly just a fictitious construct, rather than a means of transmitting value. Basically, money is now arbitrary number whose only purpose is to obtain an even larger arbitrary number at a later date. The way we treat currency is more and more decoupled from reality, and that's a pretty dangerous phenomenon. What's the evidence for this? -insanely inflated valuations for startups that offer trivial services and no revenue -a behemoth financial services industry that makes money off of money, while offering little tangible value -businesses flocking to easy, safe investments that create little value -devaluation of the labor that creates value
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- HarryHirsch 12y agothe overall unemployment rate for doctoral holders is ~2%. Remember that someone who would rather have a regular job but works one day a week at TGI Chillibees counts as employed for statistical purposes. From anecdotal experience the underemployment rate is high - there are plenty of people that would like to have a full-time job but are making do as adjuncts. The adjunct cancer has spread to places that you thought were immune. Look at Vassar College, it's a respectable place. In the Chemistry Department there are ten tenure-track professors, one full-time lecturer, and five adjuncts. Villanova, another respectable institution, is looking to fill three adjunct positions to teach graduate level courses. They do it because they can. There are sufficient pharmco refugee candidates around Philly and Boston from the last round of mergers and acquisitions for the model to work.
- HarryHirsch 12y agoA big employer for chemistry PhDs that no one in the West has heard of is Wuxi Pharmatech, a contract research outfit in Shanghai. They do everything, synthesis, discovery, lead optimization, clinical testing, process development, formulation, the whole pipeline. Meanwhile, pharmaceutical companies stateside have turned into IP brokerages, if you think you have a promising target you buy a startup that has a compound for that and hand it off to your offshore contract firm. Research, where you need PhDs, has been cut savagely, because of the short time horizon Wall Street demands that is totally incompatible with the realities of research.
- refurb 12y agoThis is a great point, employment stats are not the same across all PhDs. Back in the early 2000's organic chemistry PhDs were in very high demand. Salaries went from ~$70K/yr to start to over $100K/yr by 2005 or so. Since 2005 two things have happened: (1) as mentioned above, a lot of off-shoring of basic research has happened, particularly to China and India (not saying this is good or bad) and (2) a shift by the biotech industry away from small molecule drugs to biologic drugs (antibodies and other proteins). The result is that organic chemistry PhDs have been hit pretty hard while PhDs with knowledge areas that support biologic drug development have done pretty well.
- purringmeow 12y agoThat kind of offshoring is definitely bad, IMO. We aren't talking about outsourced PHP web development sweatshops, but incredibly high-tech research. As one poster below mentioned, you are losing institutional knowledge & traditions. That has to have a negative long term effect on your economy.
- refurb 12y agoI don't think it's really all that avoidable. If you can outsource high tech work for less, why wouldn't you? That being said, I've heard that wages for PhDs in China and India have gone up from 30% of that in the US to 70-80%. Combine that with the hassle of outsourcing (knowledge transfer, etc) it's become less advantageous than it was 10 years ago.
- beambot 12y agoI've seen other stats that suggest PhDs (particularly in STEM) actually have the lowest unemployment rates (around 2.2%) compared to any other cohort arranged by degree attained: http://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_chart_001.htm http://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_chart_001.htm
- _delirium 12y agoYeah, the article is a bit misleading in its focus on "employment rates". It's using employment rates on the day of graduation, i.e. people who have an offer lined up before graduating. People who graduate and then interview, starting sometime later, aren't counted as "employed" in these numbers. Ultimately almost all STEM PhDs do end up with a job within a year or so, as the article later acknowledges. Later in the article they quote the unemployment rate for STEM-doctoral holders as ~2%, as you found. I don't think it's therefore a particularly useful analysis. There are a lot of issues with the STEM-PhD job market, but significant risk of unemployment isn't really one of them. Bigger issues are things like whether the opportunity cost is worth it, and the fact that people who go into a STEM PhD really wanting to do research are often disappointed (there are plenty of industry jobs, but many don't really involve scientific research).
- rlanday 12y agoThe fact that Ph.D. holders have the lowest unemployment rate is not at all surprising, given that these people have all undergone extensive selection to be smart and hard-working. This would still be the case even if holding a Ph.D. were completely useless, so it’s not really clear how much the unemployment rate is decreased by actually holding the degree.
- azakai 12y agoThe article mentions that 2% figure. The reasons the numbers are different is the article focuses on new PhDs, and the 2% figure is all PhDs in the market (new and not-new).
- tdicola 12y agoI feel like there's more to this story than what the article and charts show. For example, what's the total number of PhD students over time? Has there been an increase in PhD students relative to demand so that naturally there will be less PhD graduates without immediate employment?
- lutorm 12y agoWell, if by "demand" you mean tenure-track faculty jobs, there's a plot in the article of that. The answer, which as far as I know is applicable across all fields, is that the number of PhD graduates have risen dramatically while the amount of tenure-track jobs are flatlined or even dropping. Unless job demand is driven by exponential growth (like physics during the Cold War), it's simple math to conclude that every professor can graduate one Ph.D. student during his entire career for the job situation to be sustainable. Most probably graduate an order of magnitude more than that. (This of course ignores non-academic jobs and the question whether getting a Ph.D. is a good investment for such jobs.)
- nextos 12y agoIn some areas like biotech, a PhD is almost a union card to work in large corporations doing R&D. Without it, sadly, you won't be taken seriously.
- michaelochurch 12y agoPh.D. bigotry is an artifact of the bad job market, which has just been getting worse for the past 30 years. There used to be BA-level research jobs. There still are. They're just now filled by PhDs. Basic research is pretty much gone. Pedigree bigotry is the natural reaction of a society or subculture in decline. When the future is hopeless and the present is uninspiring, people obsess about the past. PhD Bigotry is a way for the brilliant but passed-over (through no fault of their own) to reminisce about the days when they were young and clueless and thought society-at-large gave a shit about anything other than crass commercialism. Personally, I prefer to bet on the future. Simply due to resource limitations, we'll need to reinvest in basic research if we don't want human extinction (or at least the collapse of civilization). But that is a bet, and we're going to have to demolish some entrenched players in order to have one.
- erikpukinskis 12y agoI agree, Academia is in decline. Sort of. It's in decline the way journalism is in decline, which is to say: there's more of it than ever, and the people who are Getting It Done are thriving in new, 21st century institutions. But people who just want a job "in the industry", whether it is journalism or academics, are going to have a bad time as vast swaths of "the industry" crumble in response to competition that actually embraces the new value system the internet is forcing on all industries. Universities will continue to exist, and will do great research, along with being an excellent babysitter for 18-30 year olds who have the means to purchase a babysitter while they focus on their academics (or not). But more and more research will happen outside of the Academy, because research is useful. And for many kinds of research, there are easier ways to get it done than getting a PhD. And that trend will increase. And the University will lose its place as the de-facto spot for kids and researchers to go.
- iak8god 12y agoDoes anyone know what happened in Physics in the early 2000s? The number "Employed" spikes from ~30% to ~40% in a very short time span and then falls rapidly to ~20: http://www.slate.com/content/dam/slate/articles/business/moneybox/2014/07/140710_%24BOX_Physics.jpg.CROP.original-original.jpg http://www.slate.com/content/dam/slate/articles/business/mon...
- lutorm 12y agoI wish they would draw those graphs in a more honest way. Now it looks like there's a very high time resolution when in fact there's one data point per year and they've done some spline fitting to them... It looks like it's the 2001 data point that has a higher value. I'm not sure what happened in 2001, and without knowing if academic or industry jobs are responsible it's hard to guess, but it would be interesting to see if there was a corresponding uptick in funding for physics research grants at that time.
- analog31 12y agoI'd like to see those as absolute numbers, and preferably un-smoothed. The corresponding "dip" seems to be in post-docs. I got my physics PhD in the late 90's. Anecdotally during that time period, morale about employment was pretty low. As I recall a handful of activist students got the American Physical Society to acknowledge the issue. Physics Today was starting to print articles about non-academic employment, though mostly speculative. Possibly as a result, I saw what seemed like a real push among physics students to pursue industry options, including programming. Many of us were good programmers. My thesis project ran on thousands of lines of code that I wrote for hardware that I designed. And those years seemed pretty good for engineering employment. My impression is that interest in joining the post doc cadre evaporated, and students with any sort of engineering ability grabbed whatever industry jobs they could get.
- yen223 12y agoSpeculation: Dot-com boom, followed by the dot-com crash affected everyone, including academia.
- 12y ago
- mililani 12y agoHas anyone ever looked at how large some of these graduate STEM departments are by the number of students? When I decided to go back to grad school for maths, I realized that doing a Ph.D. would probably be fruitless. How did I determine this? I went to UC Berkeley, Stanford and UCLA, arguably the best math departments in the country based on the NRC rankings and AMS rankings, and counted up their graduate students. There were over 300 students. THREE HUNDRED. Three hundred brilliant minds with brilliant credentials with at least 300 other hundred brilliant competitors. That's not including the grad students at the other more mediocre schools in California like USC, UCSC, UCSB, UC Davis, UCI, UCR, and, god, I must be missing some. Oh yeah, UC San Diego. I was wondering, then, where are all these brilliant students going to go? Surely, there is not enough openings in academia, even at lower ranked institutions, for these guys. I went and checked for job openings in academia for math tenure tracked appts, and yes, there were only 10 jobs out there at the time. I then started piecing together things I saw in my own life's journey: brilliant mathematicians and scientists teaching and researching at second or third tier research universities. A lot teaching at teaching colleges (at my school, SJSU, there are several math professors from Stanford and Princeton teaching there). It was then I realized that doing a Ph.D. in STEM is a pretty piss poor proposition. I would highly discourage most people from doing it, unless you really love research, don't care about job prospects or money, and that's all you want to do in life.
- onetimeusename 12y agoSo did you end up getting the phd anyways? In your experience, did you feel the departments' agendas placed importance on the field or were they more interested in career aspirations or money? My personal experience is that mathematics comes second to research grants and ensuring prestige. I do want to hear from other people though since that was just my own.
- mililani 12y agoNo, I'm actually starting grad school next month. But, I decided against a PhD and will just do a masters in math with a concentration in statistics. My ultimate goal was to teach at the community colleges anyways. I really don't want to do research for the rest of my life.
- bellerocky 12y agoOh hey it's another claustrophobic fixed header covering up content. Horrible.
- Sanddancer 12y agoAdd this to your adblock plus ruleset: slate.com###article_rollup
- onetimeusename 12y agoI would really like to see an alternative to going to grad school for a Ph.D. spring up for people who want to do research, particularly in math which doesn't require expensive labs. The overhead, the poor job prospects, the cost, the obsession with prestige all need to go.
- tdaltonc 12y agoSomething like monasteries of mathematicians. Like the Concents in Anathem.
- onetimeusename 12y agoExactly.
- nagrom 12y agoA PhD in math does, however, require a motivated and interested supervisor. A supervisor who can tach you how to write papers, how to get them published, to tell you where you are wasting your time and to help you over the humps that may otherwise stop you. It needs a supervisor who can introduce you to others in the field, even if they live in other countries or on other continents! That may exist as a culture in Open Source, but does not exist in Mathematics without universities - and I don't know how you make it exist for research that is hard (impossible?) to commercialise. To do solid research requires a lot of time. Even if you don't need any expensive facilities, you still need a home and to eat, etc. If the government decided to fund maths PhDs directly, they'd need a ready-made corpus of people who could decide who gets funding. They'd need people who have published and who have proved that they know what they're talking about. These people would likely gather in central organisations where they could supervise their charges and collaborate on further publications to prove their bona fides. They may even teach lower level courses to bring in some extra money and share their administrative costs with similar worthies in other subjects... You can rail against the cost, the prestige, and the lack of faculty positions all you like. Until your proposed solution is more than "do it at home and put it on the internet!", nothing will change.
- 12y ago
- infocollector 12y agoReaders of this thread: http://we.tl/30KSRwmF0R http://we.tl/30KSRwmF0R - any comments on this talk?
- hyperbovine 12y agoThe economist types who ceaselessly churn out these doom-and-gloom articles about the PhD job market just kill me. Almost every single one unblinkingly equates success with salary. In my field postdocs pay 2-3x what you make as a grad student, while still giving you almost total flexibility to work on the things that interest you, with very little oversight. To a certain subset of people, this is far more attractive than making $150k figuring out how to make people click on ads, or some multiple of that selling your soul to a hedge fund.
- math0ne 12y agoI like the point you are trying to make, but you go a little off the deep end there at the end. There's nothing wrong with pursuing money.
- hyperbovine 12y agoSorry, I did not mean to give offense, but the presumption that there's something wrong with not pursuing money is both a) irksome and b) at the root of a large number of ills in our society.
- nraynaud 12y agoActually yes.
- tensor 12y agoBut neither is the pursuit of money any sort of notable goal. It's sort of like, "oh, well, get in line behind the other hoards of people who also want to be rich." Nobody will care about what you do if this is your goal. On the other hand, if you can tell people "I want to make your life easier by: filling a market gap, changing an industry for the better, making X easier to use, making Y more affordable" then people will care. Thinking more about others than yourself is also probably a good way to actually find a good business!
- mechanical_fish 12y agoDo postdocs ever end in your field, or can you build an entire forty-year career out of a succession of three-year postdoctoral appointments? If you can work as a postdoc forever, can you do this with confidence? Which is to say, what are the odds that you'll wind up washed up at age 34, or 44, or 54, driving the mid-21st-century equivalent of a taxicab, after your PI's grants dry up and you can't find any other PIs who need your possibly-quite-esoteric research skills? Tenure would help, of course. What's the ratio of assistant-professor openings to Ph.D.-level graduates in your field? Getting your own grants might help. In your field, do people who have done, say, five postdocs in a row routinely get awarded grants in their own names? (Full disclosure: I did a postdoc for fun, once. It was fun. There are many worse ways to spend three years of your life. But it was an expensive detour from my eventual career.)
- seanflyon 12y agoIt is worth noting that employment in Eng and CS is up about 5 percentage points from 2010 to 2012 (the last 2 years for which the article has data). Not a huge gain, but I would not consider a 5 percentage points increase (10% increase) to be stagnation.
- findjashua 12y agoI was under the impression that Wall St loves Physics PhDs for quant roles. Is that not true?