4 ms·
"The stupidity, the submission, the lack of responsibility, the disregard for life." This is absolutely nothing like my experience of life in the military (Bri
by chrisseaton 12y ago
"The stupidity, the submission, the lack of responsibility, the disregard for life."
This is absolutely nothing like my experience of life in the military (British Army). If you people think life in a modern western military is about stupidity, submission, lack of responsibility and disregard for your life you are so incredibly far off I don't even know how to start making you better informed.
My experience of military life was one of mutual respect, shared experience and delegated responsibility and at a level most civilians can't even understand.
You could have taken the squadrons and batteries I was in and put them anywhere in the world and asked them to do anything and we would have made it work no matter what. Try that with a group of civilians without the values the military has and see how far you get.
If you really think the military is like this, challenge your preconceptions and sign up to your country's reserves in your spare time for a year or two. See how far you get with stupidity, submission, lack of responsibility and disregard for people's lives.
- mpyne 12y agoYou were downvoted, but my experience (submarine fleet, USN) mirrored yours. Likewise I wouldn't even know where to begin to describe it, so much of what I learned was tacit knowledge. Though I wouldn't necessarily use the reserves as an example of what the active component is like, at least in the U.S. If you end up at a reserve unit that never deploys then you'd likely come away with a very different experience than going active duty (or active duty first and then falling back to reserves). I'd also say that many people could gain a lot personally from what they'd learn with military service, but you have to have a compatible-enough personality. Most team-based constructs do not work nearly as well if the team doesn't have enough 'chemistry', and the military is no different (which is why we weed out recruits who 'fail to adapt').
- dalke 12y agoI'll assume the parent poster is from the US, where conscription didn't end until 1975. In that case, the authors views are very much shaped by the Vietnam War. See https://libcom.org/history/1961-1973-gi-resistance-in-the-vietnam-war https://libcom.org/history/1961-1973-gi-resistance-in-the-vi... for how the army then was quite different than your military experience: > For soldiers in the combat zone, insubordination became an important part of avoiding horrible injury or death. As early as mid-1969, an entire company of the 196th Light Infantry Brigade sat down on the battlefield. Later that year, a rifle company from the famed 1st Air Cavalry Division flatly refused - on CBS TV - to advance down a dangerous trail. In the following 12 months the 1st Air Cavalry notched up 35 combat refusals. ... Soldiers went on “search and avoid” missions, intentionally skirting clashes with the Vietnamese, and often holding three-day-long pot parties instead of fighting. A co-worker of mine, ex-Navy, said in the 1970s there were parts of the ship where officers wouldn't go alone, for fear of being attacked. I think you can see how that experience leads to different views than yours in an all-volunteer, technology-focused military that isn't sending 10s of thousands to their death in an unpopular war.
- runarb 12y ago> A co-worker of mine, ex-Navy, said in the 1970s there were parts of the ship where officers wouldn't go alone, for fear of being attacked. > Apparently they had a real reason to fear attacks. At least 230 American officers was killed by their own troops in the Vietnam War, maybe many more. It become so common that it is even a word for it: "Fragging". Interesting read at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fragging https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fragging .
- dalke 12y agoSince you found that interesting, you may be interested in the link I posted earlier. Not only does it cover fragging, but also near mutinies, strikes, and sabotage. Nearly 1/4 of the crew of the USS Coral Sea signed a petition against going to Vietnam -- something not mentioned on the ship's WP page nor a tribute page -- and the commander of the USS Constellation had to return to port or risk losing control of his crew and ship. Edit: it's on the WP talk page.
- scotty79 12y ago> You could have taken the squadrons and batteries I was in and put them anywhere in the world and asked them to do anything and we would have made it work no matter what. That's not necessarily a good thing.
- walshemj 12y agoas opposed to country's where the authorities are hopeless? would you really want to live in a failed state?
- scotty79 12y agoFalse dichotomy?
- mikeash 12y agoOne of the features we generally associate with advanced and stable societies is the rule of law, which is essentially the opposite of being able to tell people under your command to do anything and have it be done. To take an example from recent history, when told to go to Cuba and torture captured terrorists for information, those people should have refused to do it.
- walshemj 12y agoYou are totally twisting what they meant to suit your agenda
- mikeash 12y agoIf I am, I have no idea. If you'd like to explain rather than just point fingers, perhaps we could have a discussion.
- cronin101 12y agoHe was stating that they could be dropped of in a remote jungle and given an abstract command such as "turn this bundle of sticks into something habitable" and rely on ingrained problem-solving and teamwork skills to complete the goal. Not that they could be told to napalm a small village and would carry out the order no-questions-asked.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- biehl 12y agoThe problem is not "how far YOU get with stupidity, submission, lack of responsibility and disregard for people's lives" The problem is how far SOME OTHER people in the army get with stupidity, submission, lack of responsibility and disregard for people's lives.
- mikeash 12y agoI find your last paragraph confusing. "If you think the military is awful, sign up!" Why would anyone ever do that?
- mpyne 12y ago> "If you think the military is awful, sign up!" Why would anyone ever do that? So they could prove it for themselves, and be able to explain from a position of authority as to why the military is awful. My experience from the military was far different than what I expected and that's despite having lived my entire childhood with a father who had joined the same Navy I did. If nothing else it helps to understand better that thing you are criticizing, just like we don't typically hold a lot of respect for MBAs with no tech background who think that coding is easy, programmers are replaceable cogs and IT is just a cost center.
- mikeash 12y agoI value not being placed in a position where I have to follow orders or go to prison above adding credibility to my criticisms. I can't understand why you might think it would be the other way around.
- mpyne 12y ago> I value not being placed in a position where I have to follow orders or go to prison above adding credibility to my criticisms. Fair enough, just don't be surprised when people properly reject your uninformed opinions about something that you know little to nothing about.
- gcb4 12y agoyou just confirmed what he said. where do you think? you just follow the same desire to belong by being efficiently obedient. that's exactly what the post you're replying to said. ironically, the short story starship troopers tried to highlight that same point, and it also is seen as enlistment propaganda because that whole thing is so effective in us humans that while you're reading it you fall prey.