5 ms·
This feels like overkill. What warning signs do naturally occuring underground deposits of radioactive or highly poisonous minerals have? Any hypothetical fut
by PeterisP 12y ago
This feels like overkill. What warning signs do naturally occuring underground deposits of radioactive or highly poisonous minerals have?
Any hypothetical future large-scale miner would have the technological capacity to detect danger and avoid an ecological catastrophe - it's not like that you suddenly go from soil to stores of uranium, the existane of a facility is rather obvious.
A hypothetical future band of explorers w/o capacity to detect radiation might die, but not cause an ecological catastrophe. Death risk for such far-future explorers exists in any abandoned facility, and is acceptable - deserves no more attention than such risks caused by abandoned firearms/munitions, structural integrity of those buildings, or risks of falling in concealed holes there. A hundred thousand abandoned apartmentment buildings will kill more explorers than such a buried waste storage facility.
- ceejayoz 12y ago> What warning signs do naturally occuring underground deposits of radioactive or highly poisonous minerals have? They're usually not anywhere near as concentrated. > A hundred thousand abandoned apartmentment buildings will kill more explorers than such a buried waste storage facility. They wouldn't be around after 10k years, whereas a secure waste facility would be.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Balgair 12y agoNo, you are think about this the wrong way. You think that people will obviously stay away from it, much as you would stay away from a rotting corpse. Yes, mines may kill a lot of people, but you know that walking in. You mention that any adequate miner will have a Geiger counter. You need electricity for that, and an idea of not only atomic or chemical theory, but sub-atomic theory. I'll remind that the Great Wall of China was built with much much less and is much less than 10k years old. Also, you think that once people figured out that the metal cans buried deep (in what may or may not be a desert in 10k years) cause death quickly, that they would run away. History has proven this many times not to be the case. Disease is a similar threat to people like radiation. It moves unseen, until recently, it's dynamics were a mystery. The cause is death or sever scarring and discomfort in extreme cases, it is debilitating and painful and very confusing. Often times, the cures were random attempts that may have made things worse. What did we do with this threat? Well, the Indians may have a word with you about infected blankets. Or besieged castles that had rotting bodies thrown into them via catapult. Disease has been used as a weapon for nearly forever. What make anyone think that in 7k years another Genghis or Alexander wont use the magic death barrels to invade Nuevo Houston? The issue is that with disease, your crops were still fine, you water was not glowing, your cows would still eat. With radiation, you don't get those things. The disease parallel break down into a plague of Moses type scenario, only it won't go away. And that's if we just devolve into medieval savages again. Imagine what a person with some atomic theory could do with this stuff. The horror is unimaginable. At the end of the day, this stuff has to be very well taken care of/totally forgotten. There are no go betweens really. And since life and history rarely if ever forget about a potential weapon, I got bad news.
- hliyan 12y agoThere is another possibility we should consider: a society that has retained the capacity to operate and maintain technology, but not create or understand it. We seem to be increasingly moving toward such an era -- I don't have numbers, but I think the ratio of people who understand technology versus those who use them has been gradually dropping over the past fifty years, mainly because more and more people are using technology and the technology is becoming automated. A scientifically illiterate society with giant mining machines is not entirely outside the realm of possibility.
- noonespecial 12y ago>We seem to be increasingly moving toward such an era You should visit a Maker Faire. I can't think of anything that restores my faith in humanity quite as much as a day at one.
- mentat 12y agoPump Six is a great story about this kind of future.
- olalonde 12y agoIdiocracy (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idiocracy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idiocracy) is also based on that idea.
- dirtyaura 12y agoI very much doubt that people are less sophisticated about science and technology than any time before. Quite a contrary, the education system has given us laymen discussions in which scientific literature is referred regularly (HN, many popular subreddits, even discussion threads in my Facebook stream)
- Balgair 12y agoDue to a lack of man hours available to teachers, we make up for breadth instead of depth. This is a good thing, as we do not know going forward what we should teach in depth to children. Teaching kids about cam shafts and carburators would be a fools errand, but you only knew that about 5 years ago. However, depth is needed in many areas, we just have to trust people to figure that out on their own, as they are more mobile than an educational system. An example is bit wise operations in computers. Many don't have a clue as to how to use a register in a chip, and we thought we'd never have to again. But encrypting, securely, relies entirely on this and trying to poke holes in it. Now, again, we need the depth there to maintain encryption as a viable idea.
- robotresearcher 12y agoThat's a weird argument. You might fall into a natural crevasse. That doesn't mean that if you dig a big hole you don't need to put up a warning sign.