3 ms·
To start with, certain types of insults, when done at the workplace, deny workers their civil rights under various laws, including Title VII. A workplace could
by dalke 12y ago
To start with, certain types of insults, when done at the workplace, deny workers their civil rights under various laws, including Title VII. A workplace could be sued for allow a hostile workplace should this occur. Even if it's the most profitable company in the US. Hence the question cannot be framed as a balance between "largest free collaborative dev known to man .. generated squillions" vs. "make some friends".
To have a real discussion then requires a finer nuance of what "insult" means. Verbal abuse includes "scolding, yelling, swearing, blaming, insulting, threatening, demeaning, ridiculing, criticizing, belittling" (see http://journals.psychiatryonline.org/data/Journals/AJP/3768/06AJ0993.PDF http://journals.psychiatryonline.org/data/Journals/AJP/3768/... ). That paper, which looked at verbal abuse of children, concluded "Parental verbal aggression was a potent form of maltreatment. Exposure to multiple forms of abuse was associated with very large effect sizes [comparable to those associated with witnessing domestic violence or nonfamilial sexual abuse]."
The references for the Wikipedia entry http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Workplace_incivility http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Workplace_incivility is one place to start. For example, the abstract for http://www.emeraldinsight.com/journals.htm?articleid=880458 http://www.emeraldinsight.com/journals.htm?articleid=880458 is:
> Obnoxious behaviour has become endemic in the workplace. Some of the worst offences are: not turning off mobile phones in meetings; leaving a jammed printer, gossiping, and snapping at coworkers. Yet, it is this small stuff that relentlessly grinds down collegial working relationships. Incivility is at the low end of the continuum of workplace abuse. Workplace incivility is not violence or harassment or even open conflict, although it can build up to any of those things. Links between the work environment and indicators of employee loyalty, commitment, and productivity show this is not a “fluff” issue. In addition, a recent study on workplace incivility reveals that rude employees and managers can cost a company millions of dollars a year. This paper will look at a definition of incivility in the workplace, the causes of poor behaviour, the costs to organizations, and what employers can do to help.
You may also be interested in "Sticks and Stones The Philosophy of Insults" by
Jerome Neu.
I bring this up to point out you have not succeeded in being a devil's advocate. My response is not part of a dialog testing the original hypothesis but instead is only criticism in the way you structured your question.