3 ms·
Judge Learned Hand would disagree with you: "Any one may so arrange his affairs that his taxes shall be as low as possible; he is not bound to choose that patt
by aidenn0 12y ago
Judge Learned Hand would disagree with you:
"Any one may so arrange his affairs that his taxes shall be as low as possible; he is not bound to choose that pattern which will best pay the Treasury; there is not even a patriotic duty to increase one's taxes."
Helvering v. Gregory, 69 F.2d 809, 810-11 (2d Cir. 1934).
"Over and over again courts have said that there is nothing sinister in so arranging one's affairs as to keep taxes as low as possible. Everybody does so, rich or poor; and all do right, for nobody owes any public duty to pay more than the law demands: taxes are enforced exactions, not voluntary contributions. To demand more in the name of morals is mere cant."
Commissioner v. Newman, 159 F2d 848 (1947)
- rosser 12y agoYou're conflating "permitted" and "encouraged". Both of those rulings said that people may arrange their affairs so as to minimize their tax burdens. In no way is that saying one should.
- sparkie 12y agoWay to miss the point. Courts enforce laws, not morals. Just because something is legal does not make it moral.
- parfe 12y agoThis discussion thread started with: >I don't understand the whole "If you behave logically as a business we hate you" sentiment. Yes, companies can legally and rationally reduce their taxes to the absolute minimum. Viewing as immoral the act of taking from society while maneuvering to give nothing back seems completely reasonable. Disliking someone you see acting immorally should be perfectly understandable. HOLY SELECTIVE QUOTING BATMAN! The Supreme Court decided exactly opposite of what you try to covey with your quotes (from the dissenting judge of a lower court): In these circumstances, the facts speak for themselves and are susceptible of but one interpretation. The whole undertaking, though conducted according to the terms of subdivision (B), was in fact an elaborate and devious form of conveyance masquerading as a corporate reorganization, and nothing else. The rule which excludes from consideration the motive of tax avoidance is not pertinent to the situation, because the transaction upon its face lies outside the plain intent of the statute. To hold otherwise would be to exalt artifice above reality and to deprive the statutory provision in question of all serious purpose. GREGORY v. HELVERING, 293 U.S. 465 (1935)
- aidenn0 12y agoI'm disagreeing with viewing as immoral legally reducing your tax burden. I picked a few quotes for that. The IRS goes after (and the courts have supported doing so) those attempting to use loopholes to reduce their tax burden. If the IRS isn't going after the money of corporations doing this, then it likely is within the bounds of the tax code.
- asadotzler 12y agoThe IRS does not go after people or corporations using loopholes to reduce their tax burden so long as those loopholes are legal.
- talmand 12y agoIf items being referred to as loopholes are legal, then they are not loopholes but part of the tax code. I've never liked the term "loophole" when it comes to the law. Either it is legal or it is not. The best I can do in terms of that is referring to the act of a politician inserting an exception to benefit a few as "inserting a loophole". But once that has been placed, voted on, and signed into law it is at that point the law.
- testrun 12y agoThat would be true if everybody concerned interprets that specific law exactly the same. One problem is there can and is ambiguity in natural language, and another is you cannot cover all possibilities in a single bill. In short there are a lot unsaid, and what is said is not always clear.
- talmand 12y agoOne could say the same about the continued use of the word loophole in this context. But I agree, that's part of my point. Just because one person feels it is a "loophole" that has some sort of negativity connected to it doesn't mean that everyone else will feel the same. I agree with you again, that no law can be 100% clear and that's why we have the courts to decide on such things on a case-by-case basis. Until a court decides that the so-called loophole is illegal, then it is a legal thing to do. You cannot hold a person and/or company responsible for what was unsaid in a law nor when what is said is not always clear. If the thought is that the companies in question are not abiding by the law then take them to court, that's what the judges are there. This whole meme that a company is immoral for not following the unsaid spirit of a law is just a result of people not knowing the proper thing to complain about when it comes to such laws.
- skrebbel 12y agoWoa there. So judges define what's moral and what's not now? I believe judges quite specifically help define what's legal. Whether they include a little addendum about morality in their verdicts or not is completely besides the point: This whole thread is about that ethics and law aren't the same.
- lliwta 12y agoThere's a huge difference between not paying the intended amount of taxes, and executing Herculanean acrobatics through (probably lobbying-induced) loopholes. Also, these (implicit) appeals to the authority of judges always confuse me. Judges have political opinions, just like anyone else, and land on both sides.