4 ms·
> Specifically, we’d like the community to help by downvoting comments that make HN an unwelcoming place to anyone. That's only a solution for half of the prob
by minimaxir 12y ago
> Specifically, we’d like the community to help by downvoting comments that make HN an unwelcoming place to anyone.
That's only a solution for half of the problem on Hacker News. The other half is that most submissions about gender/diversity get flagged to death very consistently, which make it difficult to have any meaningful discussion about these topics.
- Permit 12y agoWe have no way to tell if they're being flagged by users or setting off the automated system for detecting flamewars. One of the problems with the topic is that essentially every Hacker News reader feels as though they're qualified to comment on the topic. This translates into massive nested threads that blow up with people arguing the same points. I'm not convinced that discussion of these issues on Hacker News does anything to push the ball forward. I have yet to meet the person who changed their position on the subject due to an internet argument.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- minimaxir 12y agoAbout a year ago, a friend wrote a good post about diversity in hackathons which was submitted to HN and hit #2 quickly, then dropped down to the second page in an instant: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6495950 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6495950 Not many people commented on it. I believe the flame-war detector only takes significant effect when # comments > # points, which is a pretty good heuristic for a flame war that has gone out of control.
- Permit 12y agoHaha it's funny that you've cited that post as I'm complaining that it's getting flagged in the comments... I guess the point is that HN is a black box to us regular users and it's tough to speculate on how and why threads move as they do.
- dang 12y agoFor what it's worth at this late date, that post set off the voting ring detector. No users flagged it and no moderator moderated it.
- minimaxir 12y agoThat clarifies that mystery :P. Thanks!
- nbm 12y agoAny chance of getting some transparency of what automated or manual processes have affected a particular story (ie, on the story comment page itself), possibly delayed by some period to prevent bad actors from realising their voting rings or whatever were discovered?
- king_jester 12y ago> We have no way to tell if they're being flagged by users or setting off the automated system for detecting flamewars. This is the fundamental problem. No matter how a story gets made invisible, once it gets in that state nobody knows how it got there and whether or not it was justified. Not to mention that no matter how those stories vanish, HN (by community or systems) is not facilitating discussion on diversity, sexism, racism, etc. in tech.
- tomjen3 12y agoI have never seen an interesting discussion on that subject where I came away being smarter or having learned something new. On the other hand I have had such discussions suck many hours away. I understand that this is a topic very dear to many peoples hearts, but it seems like one of those things that are just not a good fit for HN.
- dang 12y ago> The other half is that most submissions about gender/diversity get flagged to death very consistently, which make it difficult to have any meaningful discussion about these topics. It isn't user flagging that makes meaningful discussion difficult. It's the discussers, unfortunately, who are doing that. I wonder if you may have cause and effect reversed here. Also, it isn't true that most of these submissions get flagged to death. Some do, but most don't, so in most cases the discussions continue. Moderators also sometimes unkill stories that were flag-killed, precisely so discussions can continue. (An example from last night is https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8083596 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8083596).
- zorpner 12y agoDo people who routinely flag stories about diversity in tech have their flagging privileges revoked?
- dang 12y agoWe don't really revoke flagging privileges much anymore; mostly just for obvious abuse. Are you wondering whether revoking selected users' flagging privileges would change the balance on these stories? I doubt it would. We're talking about a larger-scale response than measures like that can really address. The community is divided in at least two ways: on the issues themselves, and also on the HN discussions about them.
- DanBC 12y ago{That link returns a "no such item" for me. EDIT: Thanks Minmaxir; not sure why I missed something so obvious} I used to flag a lot of these stories as soon as I saw them. I stopped doing that and now I wait until the discussion turns toxic - which it almost always does - before I flag them. I'm not sure that waiting for the conversations to turn awful is a useful tactic. Also, it would be great to know if there was vote-ring style detection on some of these threads. It feels pretty clear that there is infiltration from RedPill like posters who vote and post in groups, but I am aware that this is strongly playing to my biases and perhaps it's just people who happen to agree with each other.
- thrownaway999 12y agoDo you really want a meaningful discussion, or a discussion where PC opinions are upvoted and critical voices are downvoted/banned by dang? There are a lot of us who think that the code you write matters more than the gonads you carry or the color of your skin. We're quickly becoming pariahs as our workplaces become more politicized. I don't know why more people don't understand that equality of opportunity is perfectly compatible with inequality of outcomes. Does nobody read Harrison Bergeron anymore?
- MartinCron 12y agoI don't know why more people don't understand that equality of opportunity is perfectly compatible with inequality of outcomes It's an easy theoretical thing to understand, it would be good to see equality of opportunity in practice.
- Dewie 12y ago> Do you really want a meaningful discussion, or a discussion where PC opinions are upvoted and critical voices are downvoted/banned by dang? I find it funny. Some controversial or just plain stupid opinion gets posted, dang responds to it with basically "I disapprove of this post soooo much, and I'm glad that HN does too, judging by the downvotes. Pats HN on the head". Then a whole bunch of regular users reply with how awesome his reply was for telling the poster that he was an idiot/bigot. I mean, they can of course moderate or whatever in whatever way they want to. I just don't understand why so many are fascinated by it.
- Dewie 12y agoMaybe they are flagged precisely because those topics don't lead to meaningful debates? Take any slightly controversial (or can be spun to be controversial) gender-and-tech issue, submit it to HN: if it gains traction, it will consist of hundreds of posts with two kinds of people who have so little common ground and set of mutual opinions/world-views that they can not do anything but shout past each other. Meaningful discussion? Hardly.