3 ms·
"A rate of 15-25% is probably fair to the individual in a nominal sense (more than fair, actually), but it is unfair to the company." I think we are in agreeme
by rahimnathwani 12y ago
"A rate of 15-25% is probably fair to the individual in a nominal sense (more than fair, actually), but it is unfair to the company."
I think we are in agreement on the first part, i.e. that a rate of 15-25% should adequately compensate the individual for both the time value of money and for the large risk of default.
I don't agree that it's unfair to the company. Consider:
- The company has no alternative, cheaper sources of debt financing
- The capital and interest will be deferred until such time as the company has money to pay (e.g. from a Series A) so will not cause any hardship by constraining cash flow
- These IOU are non-participating, i.e. they don't get any of the upside should the company do well.
If you think about it, it's similar to an investment by an angel: you want to compensate for the risk, you don't know when you will be able to return the cash, you don't have a reliable way to come to consensus on valuation.
Perhaps the right way to structure these IOUs is as a capped note with a low coupon (2-5%) but a reasonable conversion discount. That way the equity-like element of the note compensates for the risk, instead of requiring a large coupon on the debt-like part.