7 ms·
Notorious Airbnb squatter may be the dev behind two flailing Kickstarter games
- aikah 12y agohttp://edition.cnn.com/2014/07/23/travel/airbnb-squatters/ http://edition.cnn.com/2014/07/23/travel/airbnb-squatters/ a cnn story too,an interesting one. So the guys ran 2 scams on kickstarter and is now scamming an airbnb host... well not really ,since he is just using the law against his host. > Eviction procedures in California can be lengthy and complicated, often taking three to six months to evict a tenant. http://www.businessinsider.com/airbnb-host-cant-get-squatter-to-leave-2014-7#ixzz38R6v3hoU http://www.businessinsider.com/airbnb-host-cant-get-squatter... > On day one, after the guest checked in, he called her and complained about two odd things, Tschogl says. He didn't like the tap water (complained it was cloudy) and he didn't like the gated entry to the condo complex. He asked for a full refund, according to Tschogl. She had a bad gut feeling about him, she says, so she agreed to a refund. This guy is really ... EDITED:controversial expression.
- DanBC 12y ago> I would be the owner i would not ,care.I would break the door and a few windows.and camp in front of the condo/house,while waiting for the guy to leave. It's probably really important that owners don't do this - renters (even terrible renters) have some legal protections and intimidation is a quick way to increase the legal costs and possibly end up in jail. EDIT: Wait, did you put "nut case" in after I posted? I missed it before. Please would you consider using different insults? The person you're insulting doesn't care less about being called a nut-case, but by using such language you are subtly adding to the stigma faced by people with mental health problems. It's already harder for those people to get jobs or to rent homes, and one of the reasons is that people fear "unpredictable behaviour", and that fear is to some extent caused when we use terms to describe poor mental health to people who are displaying poor behaviour. This is a gentle request and you're free to ignore it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Steko 12y agoThe owner is doing exactly the right thing here: turn the media loose & Airbnb will hopefully cover her losses. The scammer - Maksym Pashanin - is essentially trading what was left of his reputation for just a few thousand bucks. Heroin's a hell of a drug. Edit: added scammer's name in case he uses some bullshit right to be forgotten on other articles.
- zem 12y agothe fact that he's using the law doesn't make it any less of a scam
- fataliss 12y agoI'm pretty interested in the output of this lawsuit. But i think that Air Bnb, as it's kinda their business, would have spot such a big loophole in the law if staying 30d in a rental indeed gave people rights over the house-owner, no? I guess the guy is just trying to stay for free until the case is closed and cops are putting him out.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lgierth 12y agoI guess Airbnb got hacked, eh.
- wdewind 12y ago"Disrupted."
- 7Figures2Commas 12y agoIt's called disrupting the disruptor.
- dictum 12y agoMoving fast and breaking the social contract.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lingben 12y agokickstarter is scammer heaven
- aikah 12y agoTotally.I wonder if someday backers could sue the plateform itself after a fraudulent kickstarter, right now this website is running faster than the law.
- lotu 12y agoHonestly I expect that could kill Kickstarter. Backers can sue the creators and there is at least one lawsuit that has been brought by the New York Attorney General.
- makomk 12y agoNot only that, they don't give a fuck because they get a cut no matter what and have carefully disclaimed all liability. For example, remember how they made a big deal about changing their rules on hardware projects to protect backers after several scams made the news in a big way?[1] They've now quietly removed all those restrictions to make it easier to list scams, er, projects[2]. After all more projects equals more dosh for them! [1] https://www.kickstarter.com/blog/accountability-on-kickstarter https://www.kickstarter.com/blog/accountability-on-kickstart... [2] http://www.bit-tech.net/news/bits/2014/06/04/kickstarter-renders/1 http://www.bit-tech.net/news/bits/2014/06/04/kickstarter-ren...
- aikah 12y agoIMHO Most backers are "religious" , in the sense it's spare money for them and they get some satisfaction in backing an idea,i really believe only a tiny minority of the backers really want a concrete product in the end ,otherwise I cant believe how some ridiculous projects could be backed 10xtimes the initial money asked. For businesses,backing something can be good PR too,a lot of business do it ,no matter what the outcome is. People like me that are too paranoid or skeptical to give free money would never back anything to begin with.
- josu 12y agoAm I the only one who thought about the McPoyle Brothers upon seeing the picture?
- darren884 12y agoWhatever happened to physically grabbing someone and violently throwing them out of your house?
- McGlockenshire 12y agoSee the previous coverage for the long version, but the tl;dr is that renters that rent for more than 30 days are protected as tenants by California law, including (normally proper) long drawn-out eviction proceedings.
- darren884 12y agoDoes that not mean you could live in the house too with a nice guard dog?
- thirtyseven 12y agoThey probably could sue you for tenant harassment.
- edwardhotchkiss 12y agoPlease see: Pacific Heights (1990)
- Nursie 12y agoNo, not if that was not under the original terms of the lease. You may own the building but in the eyes of the law it is the tenant's home and you can't throw them out onto the streets without due process.
- joeframbach 12y agoDo you think Airbnb should make it difficult or impossible to put a room for rent for more than 30 days, then?
- baddox 12y agoCalifornia tenant law contains a lot of examples of when your house isn't your house.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gerner 12y agoIn some ways, this is the dark side of disrupting established industries: legal protections aren't in place yet; it's not clear what recourse people caught in never before seen corner cases have. We (e.g. HN folks) are quick to applaud people with new ideas that are shaking things up (e.g. Airbnb, Uber, etc.) I suspect this is the sort of scenario detractors (e.g. Seattle City Council re: Uber) are worried about. Terrible situation, clearly. Still, important to see some of these scenarios actually play out. And it raises all the right questions: what should Airbnb do going forward? what should legal protections be going forward? should someone have seen this coming? and should they be held liable for it? (edit: typo)
- _delirium 12y agoI'm not sure these are "never before seen corner cases". This kind of stuff is pretty much Landlording 101, and it's standard practice for someone engaged in renting a property to know about eviction laws. This person wasn't even engaging in what you might call the new, casual-sharing-of-personal-possessions style of rental, where someone rents their own personal apartment out occasionally while they're on vacation. She was just doing the old-school landlord thing: she bought an investment property she did not live in, and was renting it full-time for profit. That is a line of business in which you can buy and read books, customized to your state, telling you exactly the basics you should know about!
- pstuart 12y agoBut Airbnb, as a service, should at least filter/advise for knowingly stupid things like renting out for such an extended period.
- chimeracoder 12y agoIf they're going to that effort, then why can't they filter for knowingly illegal things, like short-term rentals in cities in which this practice is illegal? I don't see them doing either one anytime soon, since it presents a major PR/deniability problem.
- uvTwitch 12y agoCould the homeowner not simply have her power shut off to hasten the removal of these pests? If they're game developers, they'd be dependent on electricity.
- maxden 12y agoThere is a sms exchange here [0] where he does in fact say he does require electricity, and if they cut it off, he will press charges for blackmail and damages. Unfortunately it seems it will only be resolved with a lengthy eviction process. It is also interesting that there problems within the first few days. [0] http://www.businessinsider.com/airbnb-host-cant-get-squatter-to-leave-2014-7 http://www.businessinsider.com/airbnb-host-cant-get-squatter...
- fancyketchup 12y agoI wonder if a whole-house version of a lamp timer would be useful in this situation? Suppose there were a device that turned off power on a schedule, and which could only be reset from inside the apartment. Power would turn off automatically 12 hours after the lease terminates to "save power in an unoccupied unit." That way, the owner isn't turning off power to constructively evict, but the power is off all the same.
- edwardhotchkiss 12y ago"Pacific Heights", 1990 starring Melanie Griffith, Matthew Modine & Michael Keaton. SF based movie showing Michael Keaton abusing renters rights and even having the home owner arrested after turning off his electricity. Fantastic film, these guys (definitely scumbags) unfortunately might be in the legal right. Very unfortunate.
- URSpider94 12y agoHarassment of a tenant, even a tenant whose tenancy is under dispute, is a crime in California. Disruption of power is specifically covered under the law. See http://www.ocf.berkeley.edu/~asucrla/Harassment%20by%20Your%20Landlord http://www.ocf.berkeley.edu/~asucrla/Harassment%20by%20Your%...
- sergiotapia 12y agoThere's legal and then there's moral. These scumbags lack basic human tact. I wouldn't ever think of doing something like this to somebody even if I were in the legal side of the law. I hope they get what's coming to them in spades. Airbnb should do everything in their power to help out this poor owner or it will set a dangerous precedent for future hosts.
- lotu 12y agoI'm not sure that it is legal to stay in an apartment after you lease or rental ends. It is just also illegal for the owner to force you out without going through a really complicated and lengthy process.
- skeoh 12y agoI hadn't heard of Confederate Express but their demo looks like a game I would totally play. Shame it's a scam.
- TheMagicHorsey 12y agoWhat we must have is a network that enables a peer-to-peer trust rating for individuals. Sort of like Yelp, but for people. No doubt such a system would be a huge privacy problem for people as people would say that negative reviews reveal their private facts, or that those reviews are defamation. However, if the network is decentralized, then it might be possible to keep it running even in the face of opposition from state actors. If we have a peer-to-peer rating/reputation network in place, it would allow people to bypass the elitist inside networks (old boys clubs) to raise capital from investors based on mass positive reputation. Rascals and scammers like these failed Kickstarter bros would be shut down after a single scam ... they would not be able to rent or scam another person after a single scam. Implementing a centralized reputation system would be a good first step. I understand why Yelp and other established companies don't want to be in this business. Its a liability/privacy nightmare. Imagine the first time some innocent girl in high school is unjustly called a slut, and is defamed by her own school as part of some bullying clique. I believe the network can ameliorate if not outright prevent such clique abuse by enabling users to rate reviewers based on the reviews they have given. If you abuse people with your reviews and ratings, it can damage your own ratings.
- andyfortson 12y agoThere's a startup that's trying to do this: https://myrepp.com/ https://myrepp.com/. Not sure why they're not using this case as an opportunity to get some press.
- avalaunch 12y agoI'm pretty sure they don't allow users to rate one another though as the OP is suggesting. Instead it looks like you can create an account for yourself, verify who you are, and run criminal/sex offender checks against yourself. Then you can share your Repp profile with others (when selling on Craiglist, for exampe) so that others know you aren't a psychopath (or at least not a convicted one). It wouldn't really have prevented the squatter's issue unless the squatter has a criminal record.
- gcarre 12y ago
- thekevan 12y agoThis is a bit of a tangent, but what would there be to stop the woman who owns the condo to start signing 28 day leases with hundreds of other people? Imagine if dozens of good citizens showed up to the apartment at once, with a key, any time they wanted. They could just hang out and of course they also had a lease and a legal right to be there, so the original two couldn't do much, could they? That would make it much less attractive to those squatters. Could it really be that easy?
- _delirium 12y agoThat would be illegal in any jurisdiction I know of. I'm renting my current apartment; obviously my landlord cannot rent it out to someone else while I still live here. Now you might say: but what if you're living there illegally? Well, I'm not, say I! Now we have a civil disagreement over property and a contract, which is a matter for the courts to decide. If the landlord alleges I no longer have a right to use of this property, despite possessing it in fact (e.g. because I am weeks or months late with my rent, or the rental has otherwise been legally terminated), they can get an order that I be evicted, which the police would enforce. There will be some kind of process, where I would have a chance to reply, for example by giving evidence that actually I paid my rent on July 1, and the landlord is mistaken in his allegations. If I lose and am evicted, then after that, the landlord can re-rent the apartment. But before that, they cannot.
- thekevan 12y ago"That would be illegal in any jurisdiction I know of. I'm renting my current apartment; obviously my landlord cannot rent it out to someone else while I still live here." Right, you probably have a lease. If you had a squatter's lease--or a de facto lease--couldn't she just allow more squatters? I don't think what you say has direct bearing on this situation because you both entered into a specific agreement. There is most likely the precedent of you paying the landlord money, which shows you both agreed to a set of conditions. Since these guys are squatters, they probably default to a default "lease" as defined by law. So the fact whether they are there illegally as held by the landlord doesn't even enter into it.
- S_A_P 12y agoI think along with the eviction route I would start trying to get them arrested for the kick starter scam.
- choochootrain12 12y agoSurprise they are Russian. What's up with the stereotype of Russians and online scams? Pardon, I have not been to Russian but have seen videos of all their vehicular carnage. Those videos make Russia seem like a bunch of narcissists who don't follow the rules of the road. Is it that different of a culture then say the US?
- choochootrain12 12y agoHey i confess I am ignorant here and interested in gaining insight!
- damian2000 12y agoIf I was the owner, I'd be looking at all the possible ways I could to make their stay less comfortable - music at all hours of the night, faulty hot water system, power outages. Not very ethical, but what these guys are doing isn't ethical either.
- URSpider94 12y agoThat is clearly illegal under California law. In addition to exposing the landlord to civil damages, it's also a pretty clear way to get your eviction suit thrown out. As I posted in another comment, see http://www.ocf.berkeley.edu/~asucrla/Harassment%20by%20Your%20Landlord http://www.ocf.berkeley.edu/~asucrla/Harassment%20by%20Your%... for the details of the law.
- cvg 12y agoThe most interesting part of the article, for me, is that they moved the nexus of their corporation from two tax free states to California. I doubt they realize the tax and legal implications of being residents rather than just visiting CA on holiday.
- bane 12y agoMy god, Airbnb is such a huge liability time-bomb. All it's going to take is some tenant slipping on a wet bathroom floor or some other nonsense. I hope they've squirreled away a huge legal defense fund from their last fundraising round. edit searched and found these, tip of the iceburg http://www.sfbg.com/2014/04/29/lawsuits-target-airbnb-rentals http://www.sfbg.com/2014/04/29/lawsuits-target-airbnb-rental... http://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/airbnb-legal-trouble-sharing-economy http://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/airbnb-legal... http://ny.curbed.com/archives/2014/06/18/airbnb_might_have_just_won_a_huge_landmark_case.php http://ny.curbed.com/archives/2014/06/18/airbnb_might_have_j... http://ny.curbed.com/archives/2014/06/10/stabilized_tribeca_tenant_may_lose_home_after_airbnb_scandal.php http://ny.curbed.com/archives/2014/06/10/stabilized_tribeca_... http://www.fastcompany.com/3027798/the-secret-to-airbnbs-freakishly-rapid-orgy-response-scenario-planning http://www.fastcompany.com/3027798/the-secret-to-airbnbs-fre...