6 ms·
Executions should be by firing squad, federal appeals court judge says
- meepmorp 12y agoWhy not something like a guillotine? Properly designed and maintained, I doubt you'd get much in the way of botched executions and it's probably the fastest death you're likely to get. Combine it with some sedation if it's decided that decapitating a conscious person is cruel and unusual.
- giarc 12y ago"I personally think we should go to the guillotine, but shooting is probably the right way to go," Kozinski said.
- meepmorp 12y agoYes, I was wondering why the guillotine isn't acceptable.
- a3n 12y agoI think some religions object to dismemberment.
- kmicklas 12y agoYes and some religions object to the death penalty?
- ajbetteridge 12y agoAnd some religions advocate stoning to death. That doesn't make either position correct. Religion should be left out of these kinds of discussions, among many others, but sadly isn't. Let's not do anything at all, that way we'll offend less people.
- baha_man 12y agoI would guess the main reason is that it would be too gruesome for anyone watching the execution. Also, decapitation seems almost like desecrating the condemned person's corpse, which might be considered a cruel and unusual punishment even for someone considered to be deserving of the death penalty.
- peatmoss 12y agoThere is some ambiguity as to whether guillotine is actually completely instant or painless: http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/1172/does-the-head-remain-briefly-conscious-after-decapitation http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/1172/does-the-head-...
- nawitus 12y agoIt's good time to remind Americans that civilized countries don't have the death penalty.
- koenigdavidmj 12y agoAh yes, the define-civilized-to-exclude-the-US argument.
- joesmo 12y agoAs far as law goes, that's a quite accurate.
- spiritplumber 12y agoIf the idea is to prevent pain, there are many simple methods. Heroin overdose? Carbon monoxide? I'm theoretically OK with the death penalty for heinous crimes, but in practice I oppose it -- the chance of a false positive is way above zero with the current legal system.
- Crito 12y agoIf the idea were a painless "clean looking" death, then a tank of nitrogen, a rubber tube, and a mask are all that you would need. Painless, cheap, effective, and could be administered by anybody so you don't need a nurse to insert the needle. You could pull the nitrogen straight from the air at the facility so you wouldn't even have chemical supply issues (not that local welding gas supply companies would face international pressure to refuse shipments anyway...) That executions are not done that way is all the proof that I need to say that executions are not currently designed to be painless. They are designed to appear clean, but specifically designed to torture.
- nickff 12y agoThe only problem with the 'solution' of abolishing the death penalty is that it makes the real issue (false conviction) easier to ignore, while there will still be innocent people who have to suffer a horrible fate, (life imprisonment not substantially better than death,) for a crime they did not commit.
- Crito 12y agoI'm not sure if that is valid justification enough to avoid abolishing the death penalty, but I think it does touch on a concern I have with the "life imprisonment is cheaper anyway" argument. The reason generally cited for the higher cost of executing somebody is the lengthy appeals process. Why is it that this makes executions more expensive than life in prison? Do people sentenced to life have fewer appeals? If so, why? Do they simply choose to appeal less, or are they not afforded as many opportunities to appeal? Unless they are actually guilty, either possibility is problematic. In the first case, that means that innocent people sentenced to life are giving up on justice. In the second case, that means that innocent people sentenced to life are being denied justice. One of the other common criticisms of executions are that they are final; finding out that somebody was innocent after killing them is useless to that person. However if for some reason people sentenced to life are receiving fewer opportunities to be found innocent since it seems less important or time-critical, are we seeing any real benefit?
- koenigdavidmj 12y agoA bullet to the heart is going to be as fast of a death as you can get. Only a few seconds for unconsciousness to hit because of loss of blood pressure, and with hydrostatic shock[1], it can be even faster. 1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrostatic_shock http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrostatic_shock
- ghouse 12y agoWe're in surprising company: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Use_of_capital_punishment_by_country http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Use_of_capital_punishment_by_co... Studies* show that it doesn't deter crime and isn't cost-effective. What's our rationale?
- viggity 12y agoDoes prison time deter murders? I'm guessing no, considering the death penalty apparently doesn't. Does that mean should we not send murders to prison? My rationale for supporting the death penalty is justice. If you, with malice and forethought end the life of another human being, you don't deserve to live. In practice, there issues with it, but I don't think it should be written off completely, just held to the highest burden of proof provided by the law.
- dllthomas 12y agoThe death penalty does deter murders, just not any more than a long prison term. And a long prison term doesn't deter crime much more than a medium length prison term. The thing that deters crime most dramatically is a high perceived likelihood of being caught. If we moved money away from killing people and into improved policing, we might wind up with less crime. Should we send murderers to prison at all? Of course - it deters crime (and murder is an awfully important kind of crime to deter). Should we send murderers to prison for so long that the marginal increase in deterrence is tiny? Maybe, maybe not - that depends on just what the increase is, just what the costs are, just what the recidivism rate is, and how these things change over time.
- dan_bk 12y agoHow can a modern society still think it is ok to carry out the death penalty? Stupidity like this belongs in the Middle Ages, not our times.
- viggity 12y agoRead about some of the crimes committed by those on death row. Then look the victim's families in the face and tell them that the perpetrator deserves to live.
- jeremysmyth 12y ago...and removal of emotion from sentencing is precisely why we have independent judges and juries in the more civilized parts of the world. The application of justice must be blind and impartial in order to approach being just.
- georgiapeach 12y agoI don't understand why any form of execution -- lethal injection, firing squad, guillotine, or any other -- isn't preceded by a hearty dose of morphine.
- hadoukenio 12y agoRemind me again why execution is a valid punishment? And if you think it's valid, isn't reducing pain by morphine as you say going against the reasoning for being a valid punishment?
- georgiapeach 12y agoPunishments are about a combination of rehabilitation, disincentivization and reducing or eliminating harm to society at large. In cases of capital punishment, the chances of rehabilitation is considered to be effectively zero, so the other two factors are emphasized.
- viggity 12y agoPerhaps because the perpetrator's victims didn't get a "hearty dose of morphine" when they were shot, stabbed, raped, buried alive, burned alive or tortured.
- georgiapeach 12y agoPunitive measures aren't about revenge,
- hadoukenio 12y agoHow American.