4 ms·
Apple approves Commodore 64 emulator for iPhone
- Tichy 17y ago"The app will not load arbitrary game code downloads nor expose a BASIC interpreter."
- jasonkester 17y ago... but only after they cripple it to uselessness. No BASIC. No loading your own games onto it. 5 obscure games, only one of which I'd even heard of (and I was a C64 kid). This is a sad let down, considering how cool the original app that got rejected was.
- newsdog 17y agoThe iPhone will never be awesome until anyone can sell an app without approval.
- derefr 17y agoAre you sure "awesome" is the word you're looking for? I'd hate to have to run an anti-virus program on my phone.
- noonespecial 17y agoDo you run anti-virus on your mac?
- jstevens85 17y agoThe iPhone isn't a Mac. The iPhone has a higher share of the smartphone market than OS X has of the OS market.
- endtime 17y agoIt's really not hard to avoid getting a virus when installing arbitrary apps, even on Windows, for which nearly all viruses are written - just download reputable apps from reputable sites. Not hard. The iPhone has a full web browser, though, which is a much more likely point of entry for malicious code.
- derefr 17y agoMobile Safari doesn't run any sorts of code, other than Javascript. No Flash, Java or any Mac equivalent to ActiveX—and without hooks to those, the JS can't really do anything either. I suppose you could find a vulnerability in the app itself, but iPhone apps are themselves sandboxed to prevent installing code without getting an elevation prompt (which is what that "Login with your iTunes account" prompt really is.) To your first point, though: I thought you were talking about listing arbitrary apps in the central App Store without vetting them. People trust things that, like you said, come from reputable sites. The App Store is seen in its entirety as a "reputable site," no matter which publisher actually wrote the app. I'm all for allowing you to just surf to an .ipa file and download/install it, but don't allow people to list a trojan-horse "Apple Remote" right beside the actual "Remote" without creating some form of community filtering or known-developer verification.
- edmccaffrey 17y ago> I suppose you could find a vulnerability in the app itself, but iPhone apps are themselves sandboxed to prevent installing code without getting an elevation prompt (which is what that "Login with your iTunes account" prompt really is.) There used to be a site that you browse to in mobile Safari, and it would jailbreak the phone. A potential vulnerability in the app itself is probably what he meant.
- endtime 17y agoExcellent example - thanks. I did mean in the app itself, rather than some kind of plugin.
- makecheck 17y ago...and until anyone can use any wireless network they want (AT&T is why I'm not buying it).
- 10ren 17y agoIt also creates an opportunity for iPhone competitors. Competitors seem inevitable, given that the basic technology is available to everyone. But until those competitors get their act together, why shouldn't Apple do whatever it likes? There's a compelling point here: Mr Jobs knows all about this issue (he and Woz created the PC category... and today a "PC" means a non-Apple computer. That's a comparable ouch to getting sacked from your own company.) It superficially looks like he is repeating the same mistake, as when the IBM-PC beat the Apple. But I seriously doubt that, and I wonder, "what's his strategy this time around?"
- dejb 17y agoI think Apple has a set of philosophies that makes it better suited to be a niche player. Didn't Jobs once say something about not being interested in price conscious users? Allowing non-app store programs would be a technically easy move to make, (unless there were terrible security problems with the platform) but my gut tells me they believe in what they are doing and they'll hold on to the bitter end. Also there are many competitors and there were before they launched. I owned for 2 years before it exists. Somehow Apple managed to rewrite history in the minds of a lot of people.
- SwellJoe 17y agoThe only useful thing about a C64 emulator, to me, is running arbitrary applications. Luckily, I have an Android phone, so the C64 emulator (JME C64) can run anything I want it to...chiptunes, ahoy!
- derefr 17y agoSo, you didn't want the C64 emulator to emulate C64 games, but rather to just do what Apple doesn't want you to do? If you want to run arbitrary applications, just jailbreak.
- dejb 17y ago'C64 games' is a subset of 'arbitrary applications'. You are a member of the set of Apple fanboys.
- unalone 17y agoCan we hold back on namecalling? You made a good point without having to sully it with an attack.
- dejb 17y agoI couldn't resist. The same person had another post of equal logical value in defence of the app store system. It seems like there are some people who see it as their role to defend Mac products and in particular the iPhone no matter what the situation is. It wouldn't surprise me if Apple had a team of paid commentors for this sort of thing. Comments like these have that sort of feel to them. Either way I think that sort of generic, knee-jerk and irational type of post is deserving of a label such as fanboy.
- jstevens85 17y agoI don't think they're defending the system, simple pointing out that the situation isn't as dire as people seem to suggest. Sure, it sucks that you can't run BASIC code, but how many people buying the app would actually make any use out of it? There seems to be a huge number of anti-Apple reactionaries who condemn every little mistake Apple makes, without acknowledging the positive things it has brought to the industry. It used to be impossible for a single person or a small team to make any money out of the mobile market. Apple changed that. Of course, that doesn't justify its app store policies.
- anigbrowl 17y agoThat's not what you want. This is what you want. http://paradroid.ovine.net/index.php http://paradroid.ovine.net/index.php