5 ms·
If this deal were to go-through, it'd be a massive consolidation of the online real estate industry. Zillow keeps saying otherwise, but local MLSs are going aw
by uptown 12y ago
If this deal were to go-through, it'd be a massive consolidation of the online real estate industry. Zillow keeps saying otherwise, but local MLSs are going away.
- bellerocky 12y agoWhat's an MLS?
- tptacek 12y agoMultiple Listing Services, run by real estate agents, which can't die soon enough.
- spacehome 12y agoGood riddance.
- uptown 12y agoIt stands for Multiple Listing Service. Essentially, it's the database used to manage listing information about a property which has been entered by the realtor handling the sale of a property. In the "old days" you could really only find out about properties for sale by looking in the newspapers, or speaking with a realtor who could search for-sale properties in these databases. There are thousands of them in the United States, and you generally need to have a realtor's license to gain access to your local MLS. MLS's can choose to syndicate their data to third-parties using services like ListHub or Point2 - but usually stipulate that the data must always point back to the listing agent so they stay part of the selling process. Companies like Zillow and Trulia have challenged this model. Increasingly, they've become the de-facto starting-point for real estate research. They've built more-user-friendly interfaces, and surfaced public-records information along with property listings in order to present a more-compelling way to buy and sell houses. Furthermore, they've done this while positioning themselves as advertising companies so as not to upset realtors or make them feel as-if they're being cut out of the process. The big complaint realtors have had with Zillow and Trulia usually centers around two concepts. One is "stale" data. The typical claim is that once data is syndicated from an MLS through a syndicator like ListHub to a site like Zillow things may have changed on-the-ground and the data may be stale. Another complaint is that Zillow's business model is built on the backs of the work realtors have done. They source all the information, and Zillow earns money from redistributing that data. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_listing_service http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_listing_service
- kumarm 12y agoAnd they should go away. Local MLS's are fraud and add very little value to either buyer or seller collecting 6% of total value. When I bought the house, My agent spent total of less than ten hours showing the houses and made 30K with 3% he collects. (He was even absent at final walk through vacationing) I believe Real Estate Agents even got a law passed where you can't be a real estate agent unless you work for someone for year in California. Really? You can be a doctor and do surgery on Patients on your day 1 as a Doctor but you apparently being real estate agent requires some unknown skills.
- smackfu 12y agoIsn't that the fundamental problem with percentage based compensation? It doesn't take that much more work to buy / sell a million dollar home vs. a $300k one, but the agent's income is vastly different.
- ceejayoz 12y agoI'm not a realtor but I'm not sure "It doesn't take that much more work to buy / sell a million dollar home vs. a $300k one" is true. I wouldn't be surprised if it involved pickier clientele with more difficult to accommodate hours, for one.
- smackfu 12y agoMy issue is that you can also have picky clientele at $300k, but you don't get paid any more. Or for instance, compare a client who spends every night checking Zillow for the latest listings vs. one who relies on the agent for new listings. There may be some correlation between home price and effort, but there are other factors that often dwarf that, and those aren't priced in at all.
- JPKab 12y agoIt is a fucking sham! I'm about to make a big move, and it is absurd that the only value the agents I'm talking to are (that a user on Reddit can't provide by telling me about the area) providing is the MLS they have access to. The 6% commission, you would think, would be a price subject to market forces, but due to collusion among realtors, its locked in. Why anti-trust isn't investigating? Lobbying, that's why.
- 3JPLW 12y agoIn my experience, local MLSs are still way ahead of the publicly available online services. Trulia tended to be better than Zillow in my region, but they still lagged weeks behind what my realtor was able to send me. Properties moved so fast that almost everything I sent my realtor from a publicly available data source was already sold. I really hope that this will change.
- pitnips 12y agoI bought my house after seeing it on Zillow. It never showed up on the Keller Williams site my agent set up for me, and he never knew about the place until we asked about it. It was my first home purchase, so he was very helpful throughout the process. I probably won't use an agent the next time I buy, and I definitely won't be using an agent when I sell.
- jpfielding 12y agorealtor's often have 3 days to 'pocket' a listing before they have to put it in the mls. these 'pocketed' listings can be privately shared and thats where realtors keep a little advantage.
- brubaker 12y agoThey are not going away. I hope they do but they are entrenched. Realtor.com, zillow, trulia, those are jokes.