4 ms·

> purely algorithmic proof-of-identity Is that what's presented in this paper? https://github.com/maidsafe/MaidSafe/wiki/unpublished_papers/SelfAuthentication.

by sedachv 12y ago

> purely algorithmic proof-of-identity Is that what's presented in this paper? https://github.com/maidsafe/MaidSafe/wiki/unpublished_papers/SelfAuthentication.pdf?raw=true https://github.com/maidsafe/MaidSafe/wiki/unpublished_papers...

wyager 12y ago
No. Proof-of-identity means proving you are a unique human. I.e you're not a bot, and one human can't claim to be multiple humans. It is not possible to have proof-of-identity on a distributed system without having a trusted centralized identification service (which maidsafe claims to have solved, yet offers no evidence).
- dllthomas 12y ago
  I don't know if this matches academia, but in my usage "identity" means that a user can prove they are the same user ("A user can establish that they are identical to another user.") What you're looking for is demonstrating uniqueness ("A user can establish that they are identical to no other user of the system"). I think that is a part of "identification", as you say, although my usage of "identification" might include mapping to other information (govt. records or similar). I don't know which of these MaidSafe is assuming - the first is not hard, UI notwithstanding. The others are.
- nwh 12y ago
  Yes, as far as anybody seriously believes this is completely impossible. Their "solution" will likely be not one at all. There's several comments floating around that MaidSafe has saved all of the people who bought MasterCoin and didn't have anywhere to dump it due to the markets being too shallow. I'm inclined to believe that's more the purpose than anything.
  - pdx 12y ago
    They started coding 6 years ago.
    - nwh 12y ago
      They had the "IPO" in April. Just because the same is the same doesn't mean the target is the same (see Ripple being bought out and turned into a pump and dump).
deleted 12y ago
[deleted]

4 ms·

> purely algorithmic proof-of-identity Is that what's presented in this paper? https://github.com/maidsafe/MaidSafe/wiki/unpublished_papers/SelfAuthentication.

by sedachv 12y ago

wyager 12y ago
No. Proof-of-identity means proving you are a unique human. I.e you're not a bot, and one human can't claim to be multiple humans. It is not possible to have proof-of-identity on a distributed system without having a trusted centralized identification service (which maidsafe claims to have solved, yet offers no evidence).
- dllthomas 12y ago
  I don't know if this matches academia, but in my usage "identity" means that a user can prove they are the same user ("A user can establish that they are identical to another user.") What you're looking for is demonstrating uniqueness ("A user can establish that they are identical to no other user of the system"). I think that is a part of "identification", as you say, although my usage of "identification" might include mapping to other information (govt. records or similar). I don't know which of these MaidSafe is assuming - the first is not hard, UI notwithstanding. The others are.
- nwh 12y ago
  Yes, as far as anybody seriously believes this is completely impossible. Their "solution" will likely be not one at all. There's several comments floating around that MaidSafe has saved all of the people who bought MasterCoin and didn't have anywhere to dump it due to the markets being too shallow. I'm inclined to believe that's more the purpose than anything.
  - pdx 12y ago
    They started coding 6 years ago.
    - nwh 12y ago
      They had the "IPO" in April. Just because the same is the same doesn't mean the target is the same (see Ripple being bought out and turned into a pump and dump).
deleted 12y ago
[deleted]