3 ms·
I'm sorry but I find this statement totally retarded. Firstly as if anyone is going to be able to know all the doctors names even in this particular case and I
by aaron695 12y ago
I'm sorry but I find this statement totally retarded.
Firstly as if anyone is going to be able to know all the doctors names even in this particular case and I'm sure there's plenty of other epidemics out there right now that are also dangerous.
Secondly there are more than doctors working on this case. Three other nurses also died as per the article.
Thirdly this story is hitting all the major news channels. It's currently top of HN. People are knowing this story.
Fourthly we don't live in a fantasy novel where knowing someone's name means something. Could we on HN at least talk about constructive things not emotive clap trap, we see this ever single day anyway from sites like upworthy.
- michaelbuddy 12y agoFollowing that logic, it wasn't even newsworthy for Reuters to post the article at all right? I mean who cares, it's just emotive BS. I mean it's not like humans respond to stories about humans, and become motivated by their actions, selfless heroic etc. Better to just have news in the form of graphs of incidences with no names associated so we can keep track of it.
- robomc 12y agoSaying that "Everyone should know these doctors' names. We need to make international heroes of these people." is unproductive masturbatory semi-self-congratulatory fluff doesn't also imply that the story itself isn't something that should be reported in the news.
- aaron695 12y agoHow on earth does it follow it's not news worthy? I can not even comprehend that logic? I know I upped the story. But perhaps the fact 3 nurses died before this and it didn't rate as high as this important news (Or OP's comments) you should at least look internally to what exactly the news is and what it means.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoEver heard of Florence Nightingale?
- aaron695 12y agoI've also heard of Mother Teresa Feel free to youtube Christopher Hitchen's round up of her.
- adamnemecek 12y agoHow's that relevant?
- lotsofmangos 12y agoBecause... squirrel! (argument provided for illustrative purposes)
- tedks 12y agoKnowing someone's name doesn't necessarily mean they're a good person.
- adamnemecek 12y agoWhat an astute observation.
- tedks 12y agoBut not an irrelevant one, in this discussion, surely. Which is the point the comment parent was attempting to make, and you, probably because you dislike Christopher Hitchens (which I do as well, but anyway) you refused to acknowledge. I've heard of Florence Nightengale. But I've also heard of Mother Teresa. My knowing even good things about a person doesn't necessarily impact how good of a person they actually were. I remember reading books as a kid with Mother Teresa in them as a totally sanctified figure, but what Christopher Hitchens says about her is probably true, and so she's not worth the respect that I gained for her and carried with me for so long. I think it is an astute observation. For all I really know, Florence Nightengale was just an unskilled doctor-wannabe who ran around Crimea amputating people without cause. People that I think of as good aren't necessarily so. We have to remain skeptical.
- TallGuyShort 12y agoMore deeply entrenching the idea that sacrificing selfish pursuits for the betterment of the human race is a noble ideal is for more constructive than emotive clap trap.
- sliverstorm 12y agoFourthly we don't live in a fantasy novel where knowing someone's name means something. It doesn't do much for the dead person, but the names we chose to celebrate shows the traits we value. We make people heroes to celebrate what they did, because we dream of a world in which anyone would be willing to make the same sacrifices for other people.
- kjs3 12y agoSo...you're a dick. Got it.
- bertil 12y agoI believe the idea was to have those people as heroes replace, say the Kardashian and the Jersey Shore characters in the attention of a large part of the population. The argument in having them known rather than Nobel Prize laureate is usually is that its easier to make strong emotional connexion with drama queens than nerds scratching theory; in that case, the strong emotional connexion seems far easier to get and we could use medical role models. Remembering names is hard, even as little as for -- but most people don't seem to remember the names of, say each Kardashian sister, or even Top Gear hosts: they can still point at "the smaller one". Having quotes, biopics, decumentary, rewards... the usual pagentry would allow people to have attitudes towards adversity that are humane, constructive and varied. One of those nurse could be spinned as the Alpha, controlling, head-strong, devil-may-care head nurse; be known widely for that, and still have a first name that most people can't spell. And another nurse could be more fearful, and go through acceptance of her fate, etc.: nothing really new to the ethico-cultural complex. Someone mentionned Mother Theresa earlier: I doubt anyone can spell her civil name; people still know how loving she was, how opinionated, how indifferent to medical cure she surprisingly proved herself to be and have a complex image of her moral stance. Her influence on reconsidering extensive medical treatment as opposed to simple care at the end of a life is a interesting recent development in medecine.
- aaron695 12y ago3 dead nurses don't beat one sick doctor. HN FTW. Wonder what their names were?
- lotsofmangos 12y agoMbalu Fonnie, Basidatu Sheriff and Princess Iye Gborie. knowing their names means something remember them since you wondered.