4 ms·
Hopefully this was all a huge misunderstanding...but we really need to hear from the girl's father, who likely would've been the primary enabler of this given h
by danso 12y ago
Hopefully this was all a huge misunderstanding...but we really need to hear from the girl's father, who likely would've been the primary enabler of this given his relationship to the plagiarized researcher. I mean, I just have to give him the benefit of the doubt for now...that perhaps he helped his daughter with her science project and then was called away to an emergency, or a stretch of focused work, during which point he forgot about the science fair and the story took a life of its own. Because...even if he were being malicious...how dumb would he have to be to think he could gain from this, or get away with it?
Edit: Worth mentioning, but in the NPR piece from yesterday, there's this:
http://www.npr.org/2014/07/20/333192387/sixth-graders-science-fair-finding-shocks-ecologists http://www.npr.org/2014/07/20/333192387/sixth-graders-scienc...
> Her research did not stop there. Craig Layman, an ecology professor at North Carolina State University, confirmed Lauren's results. "He credited a sixth-grader for coming up with his idea," Lauren says ecstatically. Layman's findings were published this year in the science journal Environmental Biology of Fishes. Lauren is mentioned in the acknowledgments.
OK...this science journal has a little explaining to do, too.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jmount 12y agoThe thing is: there is no Solomon/neutral solution to this. Either the original researcher was harmed or not. I feel a need to be fair to the original researcher as well. This entails calling out people who harmed them, or allowed harm they could have stopped to continue. Keeping silent and waiting plays to one side.