10 ms·
Polygon sat down with one of the creators of Dwarf Fortress
- dpeck 12y agoDwarf fortress will crush your CPU because it isn't, and likely never will be, multithreaded.
- hyperbovine 12y agoOdd considering that several of the CPU-intensive procedures described in the article (rejection sampling of terrain, generation of independent feature fractals) are easily parallelized.
- Amezarak 12y agoThose take place during worldgen though, which is a one-time event that occurs before gameplay. Where most players actually experience CPU problems (and it matters) is during gameplay. The world is effectively frozen after world creation (though I think the latest version does allow for events to still go on), but what has historically been the source of performance problems is dwarves and animals pathing, large numbers of items, and water/lava flow. Even though you can generate these huge regions, the average fortress is built on a pretty small map.
- pekk 12y agoDoesn't that mean that DF will only "crush" one core rather than all of them? Is it really a big concern how well DF will scale? It's a game, it is made to be played. It isn't really meaningful to criticize games for whether they are multithreaded or not.
- dpeck 12y agoYes, it will crush a core. It actually is a concern as DF in game (dwarf mode anyway) does a huge amount of pathfinding for the little buggers and other creatures. Not to mention item tracking and other bits. This means that once your fortress gets somewhere around 200 dwarfs you start getting into FPS death because it doesn't scale. So it actually as is a problem, and development of the game is going against the grain of modern computing. I'm not downing on it at all, DF is Tarns forever project, and a damn good one. He, by design, doesn't owe anyone anything. But the reality of it is that it only gets less and less playable over time and will not be able to reach the mass civilization simulation that many of its players want as more features are added and core speeds remain relatively unchanged.
- Lockyy 12y agoThis is the only thing that disappoints me about Dwarf Fortress, my CPU has gotten more and more powerful over the years and despite that my FPS crashes faster and I have to drop to smaller and smaller worlds every release.
- Scuds 12y ago> He, by design, doesn't owe anyone anything. A commercial game would have a tutorial mode and other bells and whistles to make it more approachable. Thing is, I have one hour a day before sleep to screw around, so is it Bob's Burgers or Dwarf Fortress?
- dpeck 12y agoI'm confused by what you're getting at here
- skaevola 12y ago> A commercial game would have a tutorial mode and other bells and whistles to make it more approachable. Does Jackson Pollock have a tutorial? Duchamp? The beauty in Dwarf Fortress is that it doesn't cater to the lowest common denominator. It's the vision of Tarn and Zach Adams manifested without the filter of commercial interests. Nobody's opposed to a tutorial (and there are plenty of community created ones: http://dwarffortresswiki.org/index.php/DF2014:Tutorials http://dwarffortresswiki.org/index.php/DF2014:Tutorials ). Commercial games are like corporate art. A company would never create a game like Dwarf Fortress. Alternately, you can spend your hour before bed watching reality television.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- thebelal 12y agoBack when I was hacking on DF ~4 years ago I believe it was actually the item tracking that was ruining performance in big forts. The main loop had to touch every item in the game every frame, including things like every rock mined by your dwarves. You can usually get significant speedup in big forts just by destroying all the spare rocks (I think the best way to do this in-game was put them under a bridge and then close it on top of them). I ended up having more fun hacking on DF than playing it, but it is an interesting game.
- freehunter 12y agoWhat are you talking about? Of course it's meaningful to criticize a game for how well it uses the resources available. Not many applications are are resource-dependent as a video game. Word can be a little slow, but as long as it recognizes what I type, it's fine. Excel can hang for seconds while it calculates my formula. 3D rendering can take days and that's to be expected. No one talks about frames per second in productivity applications. But look at how much crap WatchDogs got when it came out and people realized it was only using 70% of the available resources on AMD cards. Look at how many hundreds of dollars people spend on video cards and quad/octo core processors to get a little better performance. Meanwhile the workstation on my desk has a Core 2 Duo with 2GB of RAM, and I couldn't care less. If video games shouldn't be developed to high levels of efficiency, what should be?
- hyperion2010 12y agoYa, sadly Toady has basically said "I don't get multithreading, and it is so far down the list of things to do that it might happen in... who knows when."
- fulafel 12y agoMultithreading is a last ditch effort since you can only get your speedup from it once and it will add a whole new level of hard bugs and will dramatically complicate everything forever. For something like df it is much better to work on smarter code first.
- mkesper 12y agoI just wonder why this isn't 64bit? Seems it should profit vastly from being able to use modern amounts of RAM plus better registers.
- erichurkman 12y agoI encourage everyone to check out the game. It's quite crazy, and beginners inevitably lose due to the game's depth and crazy events ("Losing is fun!"). If the ASCII tile sets make your eyes bleed, there are other tile sets of graphics to try out. [0] There's also a very vibrant modding community, including a lot of memory hacking through the dfhack project [1] – even fixing a lot of longstanding bugs in the game, like dwarves taking a pair of gloves and putting both gloves on one hand. There's a full engine to write tweaks in Ruby or Lua, too. [0] http://www.dwarfcorp.com/site/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/df.png http://www.dwarfcorp.com/site/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/df.... native versus http://i.imgur.com/FQaND.png http://i.imgur.com/FQaND.png (Phoebus tiles) [1] https://github.com/DFHack/dfhack https://github.com/DFHack/dfhack
- FreezerburnV 12y ago"beginners inevitably lose" You seem to imply that it's possible to win ;)
- NDizzle 12y agoThe werehedgehog Xim Thogslockawe has come! A giant hedgehog twisted into humanoid form. Now you will know why you fear the night. You will never win.
- speeder 12y agoI dunno now... I used to play more when the fortress always started on a cliff face. But back then people considered "winning" if you triggered the end-game demon... that despite that making you lose too, it was really hard to do... (and defeating said demon with a adventurer later even harder).
- joeclark77 12y agoI would wait for the new release to stabilize, though, and for the third-party tools to be adapted to it. Or just go with the previous release, which is 2 years old.
- 12y ago
- dang 12y agoWe changed the linkbait title to one of the article's introductory sentences that accurately (if blandly) describes the piece.
- na85 12y agoThank you.
- Widdershin 12y agoI appreciate the transparency.
- TillE 12y agoThe truly exciting thing about Dwarf Fortress is that it proves that deep, detailed simulation is well within our reach. It suggests whole new genres of games that have yet to be created; imagine a typical fantasy RPG (or perhaps one that plays more like Mount&Blade) where the entire world is simulated as you play, so every choice you make has logical consequences. The possibilities are endless, and while Dwarf Fortress is a great game on its own, it's really just scratching the surface of what can be done with world simulation.
- Amezarak 12y agoHave you ever played DF's Adventure Mode? It is "sort of" like that now, and I'm pretty sure that's the end goal.
- gagege 12y agoNo, please, if Mount and Blade had the simulated world of Dwarf Fortress, I would never leave my house.
- contingencies 12y agoIn a word, yep. You wouldn't be the only one.
- VikingCoder 12y agoMy favorite cartoon on the subject: http://i.imgur.com/HrO4R.gif http://i.imgur.com/HrO4R.gif
- Natsu 12y agoThere are a lot of games inspired in one way or another by DF out there now, actually. But yes, it's an awesome game where the raws with the plant material properties now have scientific species names that they're based on, and the raws cite references for where they got the numbers. This one, of course, being the most infamous - http://dwarffortresswiki.org/index.php/DF2014:Saguaro/raw http://dwarffortresswiki.org/index.php/DF2014:Saguaro/raw As it was inspired by this 'artifact' - http://imgur.com/EPtgt?tags http://imgur.com/EPtgt?tags
- 12y ago
- coder23 12y agoI think it a loss that a game with such original complexity has the most primitive graphics. Nobody wants 3D acceleration, but an upgrade to a simple 2D with sprites and effects with a better interface, would open it to a wider crowd.
- na85 12y agoYep. Dwarf Fortress players seem to revel in the abhorrent UI. It's not even just the abysmal graphics, it's the arcane controls, too. A sane interface with even the most primitive 2D tile-based GUI would make Dwarf Fortress better by orders of magnitude.
- Lockyy 12y agoIt really does suck how the game has no way to make the tiles easily understandable: http://i.imgur.com/KqHkn4z.png http://i.imgur.com/KqHkn4z.png The UI may be bad and need improvement (personally I find it no more complicated than any other CLI, even if it is a little inconsistent), but you can't complain about the default tile-set being ugly and unreadable and how "even the most primitive 2D tile-based GUI would make Dwarf Fortress better by orders of magnitude" when there is a rich and dedicated group of fans who pour a lot of time into making the game look, in a lot of cases, very nice. And as your sibling poster said, if you really cannot stand the 2d, there is Stonesense for rudimentary 3d graphics.
- zyxley 12y agoTo quote myself from the last time I commented on an article about DF: I will continue to have no interest in Dwarf Fortress until it has an actual UI instead of whatever insane random combinations of controls the developer felt like adding on any particular day.
- Natsu 12y agoIt's on par with using vi, but once you get over the speed bump it actually feels natural and you go through the menus without even thinking about it. Granted, this isn't easy for everyone.
- presidentender 12y agoYou're missing out. I mean, I assume that you're doing other things with your time and enjoying them instead, but Dwarf Fortress is a unique experience well worth a few hours every couple of years.
- jeremysmyth 12y agoA few hours every couple of years? I admire your discipline. If I wait a couple of years to play, I end up losing a weekend or two to a few forts. I have to get my fix by spending a day or two every few months. No other game does that to me.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- grimgrin 12y agoAt least many of these "insane random combinations of controls" follow a pretty OK mnemonic naming convention. b>c to build a chair b>d to build a door b>w>l to build a still (type of workshop, many other things under b>w)
- coolp_jim 12y agoExactly. Which is exactly like games like Starcraft or Warcraft, where there are any number of things you can "do" as a player. No one complained about those games' UI. DF has this and more. Therefore, the UI becomes more involved. I think what this really boils down to is "I haven't played the game and everyone says it's really hard, so I guess I won't try. Instead I'll go online and complain about the UI I've never used."
- codezero 12y agoAre there any good newbie tutorials? I always start it but just get way too lost right away.
- LanceH 12y agoFollow along with some youtube examples of how to start. There are a couple out there with good explanations of moving between the different modes.
- codezero 12y agoThanks, I assume just searching for Dwarf Fortress videos will lead me to a useful starting point?
- XaspR8d 12y agoThe YouTube series by captnduck is noted for being particularly helpful and comprehensive. But I think seeing several people's playstyles is good once you figure out how to not starve.
- hobs 12y agoI would choose a phased approach for a brand new player. Learn about tiles, z levels, and investigating what an object/unit is (navigation and inspection). Learn about designations (how to mine, gather plants, chop down trees) Learn about rooms and workshops (mason, carpenter, bedrooms, dining rooms, offices, walls, doors, grates, stairs, ramps) Learn about farming (underground preferred) Learn about trading (crafts, trading depot) Learn about nobles (bookkeeper and manager to start, followed by broker) Learn about mechanisms (mechanisms and levers, let power come later) Learn about military (squads, commanders, fighting, training, equipment) Explore the rest of the game! If you want any help, comment or email me in my profile, I would be glad to help!
- criley2 12y agoFind a multiyear walkthrough that will take you hours to just play the game according to how a manual tells you. Why? It's like learning Ruby on Rails with Michael Hartl. You follow his instructions to learn more than just mechanics, but the Rails Way of doing things. Same with Dwarf Fortress. You need to learn the DF way of doing things, the DF way of solving problems. Easiest way to learn it is to follow deep instruction for a while. I cannot find the exact tutorial I followed a while ago (and I'm not sure it's even valid for the latest versions) but this wiki ought to help start: http://dwarffortresswiki.org/index.php/DF2014:Quickstart_guide http://dwarffortresswiki.org/index.php/DF2014:Quickstart_gui... Maybe a current DF player can link you to the best multi-year walkthrough :)
- steventhedev 12y ago"Fun" aside, they should take a page from GRRM, and look at what makes popular fantasy fiction so popular, and borrow some elements from there (such as allowing nations to commit atrocities during worldgen). The occasional godly intervention makes things more interesting as well. From a developer's perspective, though, there is a lot of "fun" left in their codebase. They handle massive pathfinding, temperature and fluid mechanics, and other resource intensive algorithms. From what I remember (I last played DF2010), there is a lot of room for improvement, and the community has discovered several "workarounds" that reduce the workload for common structure types (such as a lava pump)
- intended 12y agoI just genned a world where the southern elves were crushed for 70 years by a goblin Civ. 3 queen regents and princesses were put to the sword. The 4 iteration, resulted in Ivis Voidwinds (or something), the new elf princess who promptly went to explore the wilds and tamed giant dingos, lions, polar bears, bears and a host of other animals. In 162 she led an army and attacked the goblin civ, pillaging 3 cities in an unstoppable attack till they signed a peace treaty in 163. In 163 the goblins broke the treaty, at which point she waged war till 250, when world gen stopped. She was victorious in battle and converted 5 conquered sites to Elfdom. She did this all with only 1 kill to her name, she was a high master strategist.
- erikb 12y agoI never got around to really learn to play it, but here and there I gen a world just to see that kind of thing happening :D
- Kiro 12y agoThat opening cinematic is terrifying.
- erikb 12y agoterrifyingly awesome you mean
- erikb 12y agoWhat I hate about the developers is that they live in their tiny little closed source Windows cave. They develop so many cool things but you can probably never use most of it outside of DF. Like how many cool games would we have if the world generator would be an open source C library? How many languages would have been added by other people who actually study language related science if they knew how to. How many people would have developed 3D graphics engines and usable mouse+keyboard menus if there would have been a publicly defined interface to interact with DF. There are actually many cool tools but as far as I know a lot of the time of these developers is drained by having to find out about the API themselves (which might change) and most of them are naturally only working on Windows as well. Think of Minecraft style community + DF on all available operating systems. How cool would that be.
- mobiuscog 12y agoSo go write one ;) Whilst I agree that cross-platform is a nice goal, I'd much rather developers wrote what they want to, and are more comfortable with first and foremost without having to think about multiple platforms or 'trendy' languages, etc. I want developers to write the things they want, and I'll be happy if they share them, rather than writing things they think everyone else wants and not having the same passion. Some people will want to write multi-platform something and have the passion for that, which is great, but I wouldn't ever want to enforce that on any one. If you ever want to see a developer cave, just look at Linux (and the oft-used 'Windows people can build it themselves if they can work it out') Disclaimer: I use all OSes and like them all in different ways. However, when I write software for myself, there's little chance I'm caring about who else will run it. It's coding for pleasure, not money. Edit: I should also mention how utterly AWESOME Dwarf Fortress is.
- erikb 12y agoThe "just write this one program" philosophy always just yields one program at most. The "add software to the community" approach might add only 1/10th of a program, but with thousand people doing it you get 100 programs out of it. Which approach looks more reasonable? Or to give another example how many people can enjoy Game of Thrones because it's written in English? (I'm German and I love it!) If it would have been written in a minority language that is only spoken in one village somewhere in central Asia it might have been more comfortable for the developer, but only few people can ever take joy in it. They don't need to make the program work on all systems or use a fancy new language. They just need to enable the community and make use of development patterns that are flexible. Java certainly is not a fancy new language, and despite it's claim it only really works on Windows well enough out of the box. Yet Minecraft has an open community where even the developers profit from what others add to the game. When the coders of DF die in an airplane crash tomorrow DF is pretty much dead as well and that's the big problem I think. If I invest my whole life to create an awesome piece of work, then it should surpass me in number of years.