3 ms·
I don't own an iDevice, but Apple's nonchalant attitude regarding possible exploitable backdoors irks me.
by Alupis 12y ago
I don't own an iDevice, but Apple's nonchalant attitude regarding possible exploitable backdoors irks me.
- coldtea 12y agoThe fact that the other major mobile OSs gets 98% of the mobile malware (according to studies), makes this point about the "nonchalant attitude" rather week...
- drdaeman 12y agoApple is a respectable company who cares about their brand image, so they're obviously allowing only high-profile adversaries' malware on your device! </s>
- bediger4000 12y agoThe attitude you exhibit towards iOS doesn't fly when Linux advocates mention that Windows is the target of 98% of PC malware. And maybe it's true: 98% of the PC malware is targeted at Windows and 98% of the mobile malware is targeted at Android. I certainly take advantage of the Windows malware situation by running Linux, and not running any malware checkers.
- Alupis 12y ago> The fact that the other major mobile OSs gets 98% of the mobile malware (according to studies), makes this point about the "nonchalant attitude" rather week... No it does not. It's not acceptable when any company is nonchalant about any security problem on their device, product or service. And, taking Android as an example, Google is very open about the malware and malicious app problem[1] -- and takes steps to help mitigate said problem. Apple is just straight-up telling users it's not a problem. There is a key difference here. [1] http://en.tempo.co/read/news/2014/03/01/240558528/Google-Admits-Malware-Threats-on-Android http://en.tempo.co/read/news/2014/03/01/240558528/Google-Adm...
- fyolnish 12y agoAre you saying it has been a problem? again, this requires physical access A Mac can be booted in single user mode if one has physical access That seems like a more serious issue.
- Alupis 12y ago> again, this requires physical access The only physical access that is required is for the user to pair with a/some pc -- which then said pc can be used as a vehicle for attack... Other users in this thread have mentioned airport USB chargers wanting to pair with their iDevice, etc. That's not very far-fetched really...
- josho 12y agoI thought this required me to unlock my phone and say 'I trust this computer' before anything else could happen, are you saying that is not the case? I'll yield to the fact that I cannot remove trust from a computer, that seems like a now obvious shortcoming.
- Alupis 12y ago> I thought this required me to unlock my phone and say 'I trust this computer' It does, but only once, and then it's almost impossible to "un-trust" the computer without wiping your phone. Besides, you probably have already "trusted" your home computer -- which could be exploited between then and now and then used as a vehicle for attack. And, as some commenters have mentioned, when you plug into a new device, use an airplane USB charging port for example, the phone may repeatedly ask you to accept a pairing with the other side (the USB charger/device), and an accidental tap on the wrong button can leave the door open.
- thetinguy 12y agoyou can remove trust by changing your passcode.
- yellowapple 12y agoThat 98% figure is caused primarily by users disabling the default-enabled restrictions on third-party non-Play-Store apps, and particularly in the pirated app space. Also, s/week/weak/
- pessimizer 12y agoI think that buying an Apple device is implicitly consenting to have all of your communications monitored and not to have access to your own data. In other words, I don't think this is a big deal, but there's also no need to spread FUD against the people who are specifically pointing it out. edit: It's in the EULAs. I didn't think that I was saying something controversial:) I always underestimate people's level of denial...
- ZoFreX 12y agoI don't know what the situation is with Windows Mobile or any of the other mobile OS's, but with the big two it goes like this: iOS: You get updates for your device for a decently long time after you buy it, even after new devices come out. Android: You stop getting updates (all updates: security fixes are NOT backported) somewhere between 6 months to 2 years after getting your device, assuming it's a brand new product line. If it's not the latest and greatest there's a chance it's already out of date, and won't be receiving any updates at all. Even if you do get updates, depending on the device they may be months or even years after they are released. So, ignoring any other mobile OS's, your choice is "a few known issues and an attitude problem" with iOS or "walking around with well publicised wide-open security vulnerabilities in your pocket" with Android.
- Alupis 12y agoThis isn't an Android vs iOS issue -- I take issue when any company ignores or brushes off a security problem. That does not detract from the current situation at all.
- ZoFreX 12y agoWhat I wanted to highlight is that the "big picture" of security with Apple is one of taking things seriously, not ignoring or brushing things off.
- tripzilch 12y agoOnly if you compare certain aspects of it to certain (other!) aspects of other manufacturers. That was the point. Saying "oh but other manufacturers do other things badly" needlessly polarizes the argument and detracts from Apple's fuck-up, which is the topic of discussion here. Of course not providing security updates after a a relatively short time is a bad thing to do, but how is that even relevant to the backdoors in this article? (edit: changed "Android" to read "manufacturers", as em3rgent0rdr rightly pointed out your complaint doesn't have anything to do with the OS, but the manufacturers providing locked devices with Android OS on it. with Apple/iOS this just happens to be the same party)