7 ms·
A brand new Foursquare, with a brand new logo and look
- diestl 12y agoHow are Foursquare still going? Most useless app ever.
- achompas 12y agoTry using it as a terse alternative to Yelp, its verbose reviewers, and its shady review collusion.
- Major_Grooves 12y agoI've always found Foursquare quite useful from a venue discovery PoV, if not the whole "find where your friends are" angle. I can think of more than a few apps that are more useless.
- waylandsmithers 12y agoI couldn't agree more, but I also at one point thought "facebook, but ONLY status updates? That's dumb." These "pay attention to me" type apps all seem to do well.
- nathos 12y agoThis really isn't what Foursquare is anymore. It's become a rather good location database & discovery platform. I never used it when it was "hot" (~2012), but in the past few months I've really come to like it for finding places (restaurants, etc.) & making lists. Also, their tools for making edits to the DB are quite impressive, and they do a great job of leveraging superusers to moderate those changes.
- pzaich 12y agoI found Foursquare to have by far the best meta-data (compared to Google maps, Yelp, TripAdvisor) when living abroad in Asia.
- minimaxir 12y agoFoursquare's data is pretty good, and their API limits are pretty fair. I've been able to make a list of bars in big cities such as NYC and rank them by rating using Foursquare data. SF: https://www.icloud.com/iw/#numbers/BAJgIU7STmBNBkW_ziOBmn5BYvI8QiEYKWKF/SF_Bars_By_Price_%26_Rating https://www.icloud.com/iw/#numbers/BAJgIU7STmBNBkW_ziOBmn5BY... NYC: https://www.icloud.com/iw/#numbers/BAKlTrL5ohjtIDpPkrOB3UW9GwkqmaziV2GF/NYC_Bars_By_Price_%26_Rating https://www.icloud.com/iw/#numbers/BAKlTrL5ohjtIDpPkrOB3UW9G...
- VLM 12y agoMeta observation: 4sq was a grind game, and aside from the addicted, grind games are the most fun ever, until they're not cool at all anymore and everyone always knew it. So you create an awesome successful grind game. Cool. Next step, either create a new grind game (and hope lightning strikes twice LOL), or find a new line of business to pivot into, or go out of business.
- Major_Grooves 12y agoWhat I don't understand, is that they say they use the super-data from these 50 Million people to give personal recommendations in the new Foursquare app. Now I presume they want to broaden the appeal of Foursquare beyond those people that like check-ins, but does that now mean that the check-ins from Swarm continue to power the recommendations in Foursquare? Is it relevant to use the data from early-adopter-types for an app that is meant to have mass appeal?
- achompas 12y agoThey'll almost certainly use the Swarm data to generate recommendations, but there are other non-check-in features to consider (likes, reviews, review sentiment come to mind). EDIT: Looks like location data as well.
- wylie 12y agoFoursquare has been promising this since the beginning, it's why I keep using it and checking in. Hoping this lives up to the promise, since their current recommendations are pretty static.
- gdilla 12y agoI was so puzzled why a company like Foursquare, which if they didn't invent the check-in, brought it to our lives, and associated their brand with it, completely removed it from their flagship eponymous app and put in a new one called Swarm (which also has its own major annoyances). Shouldn't have this been the other way around? Foursquare is associated with checkins. Now you're trying to transform "Foursquare" into a smarter Yelp? I'm sure it can be a competitive service, but confusing your 100MM strong user base with these changes isn't going to help.
- adora 12y agoif their ultimate monetization strategy is the smarter yelp stuff, then building on the foursquare app makes more sense (trying to reacquire all those users would be costly)
- gkoberger 12y agoThat's the point. Everyone thinks of them as a "useless check-in app"; they decided they had to do something drastic for people to take notice of their (awesome) location discovery platform. Foursquare has huge brand recognition, and it would take a long time to build that up for their new app (which will be the way 4Sq makes money going forward). EDIT: Put the word useless inside the quotes rather than outside — I like 4sq!
- jusben1369 12y agoIt's interesting and I agree with you about their huge brand recognition. Unfortunately, they have a lot of negativity around the brand. Just look at the comments here around "horrible vanity app" etc. I wonder if they shouldn't have left Foursquare as the Check In app and had the "Swarm" equivalent be the new search and recommendation engine. They could have gotten most folks to move I suspect and not have to deal with all the negativity around the Foursquare app. Personally I love a pivot so I hope they're successful either way. I've started using it for discovery when traveling and think it has legs.
- gdilla 12y agoCheck-ins have been valuable to them in so far as data and intelligence. It hasn't been valuable to them as something to monetize off of enough to satisfy investors. Hence the pivot in the hopes of more Yelp like ad revenue. But I wouldn't say check-ins are useless - they do help users in various ways when applied right.
- JamesBaxter 12y agoI think they've really alienated a lot of their users with the app move look at the reviews of Swarm https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.foursquare.robin&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.foursquare... Do the app stores need to get better at transferring users between apps for situations like this?
- uptown 12y ago"Do the app stores need to get better at transferring users between apps for situations like this?" I don't think so. They chose to fragment their user-base. Presumably, they've already got the eyeballs inside their own app to handle the transition. To me - it doesn't seem like something an app store should be expected to accommodate.
- ccozan 12y agoI don't understand the 3.5 starts rating: the first 20-30 pages of reviews are 1, 2 max 3 stars. EDIT: I see now. The rest are non-western comments and ratings a la "good app", 5stars. Totally pointless.
- SuperKlaus 12y agoLook at their facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/foursquare https://www.facebook.com/foursquare People are hating Swarm, haven't seen a single positive comment over there.
- onewaystreet 12y agoA lot of startups make the mistake of doing nothing that will anger their current base of users, but that is not how you grow a company. Facebook is a good example. Almost every move they have made has angered their current users but ended up growing the company (opening up the site to everyone, adding the news feed, etc.).
- UweSchmidt 12y agoNice perspective. Personally, I don't want to feel like I'm part of a "userbase", to be "transferred between apps" when convenient. I guess all that anger and disappointment users express (no matter if they stay like with FB or leave) is due to the fact that they expect someone on the other end who built the app out of passion and maintains it as a service to the community. How am I supposed to become a loyal user/customer, invite my friends to that service and provide all that data if it's all subject to some corporate strategy, if any middle manager can shut it down if the metrics aren't going up?
- uptown 12y agoI'm sure they have data that says otherwise, but unbundling seems like a mistake. You've got a brand that's still not terribly well-known, and you're fragmenting it further. Demote check-ins if it's not the primary-use for most users ... but keep it as one app. I like their recommendations, and I hope they prove me wrong because it's great data that I'd hate to see lost or simply acquired and absorbed by a 3rd party.
- ssmoot 12y agoAfter looking at this post, I kinda want to try out Foursquare as a Yelp alternative. I've never signed up for Foursquare before. So that seems significant. But two apps? Why? Granted I don't check-in on Yelp very often. But if I feel like it, and it wasn't integrated, I'd never do it. It's a missing but seemingly trivial feature for the main Foursquare app and puts me off a bit. Enough that I probably won't bother with it. The whole idea feels incredibly poorly thought out if they were looking for conquest usershare from Yelp.
- mathgeek 12y agoAll I see is the Famous Stars logo. Very similar.
- uniclaude 12y agoI'm quite surprised to see the amount of negative feedback here. I find the new logo quite good looking and communicative, and this "new" Foursquare app is finally something I can see myself using. I have absolutely no interest in the whole check-in thing, but I'm not against good recommendations, so there's a good chance I'll be in the target market for this app, and I suspect I'm not alone in this case.
- ghobs91 12y agoIf it can get very smart about the recommendations it makes, when it makes them, and how frequently, it will become a big part of peoples social lives. I envision an experience where it knows my friends and I are in a new city together, and because it's early evening, we're probably trying to figure out where to go out for the night. Bam, notification letting me know the best nightlife spots based on my preferences and those of my friends.
- qeorge 12y agoI first heard of foursquare from Fred Wilson, who described getting a recommendation on a specific dish off the menu via a friend through Foursquare. That was so COOL! Much cooler than "personalized local search". Maybe they could go back to that? I can get recommendations for just a restaurant from lots of apps, but "go to this restaurant and order this dish" is currently underserved, and more useful.
- chipotle_coyote 12y agoDoesn't Yelp do a reasonably good job of this? I've certainly gotten recommendations from both tips and its "frequently talked about" algorithm (i.e., "carnitas" shows up a lot in reviews of this taqueria).
- qeorge 12y agoSounds like it does! I haven't used the Yelp app in a long time. Glad they added tips.
- dude_abides 12y agoTeam FourSquare (if you're reading this), please ask yourself this question: If "x" is how much better Facebook was than MySpace, or how much better Google was than Yahoo search, then "x" is how much better you need to be than Yelp to beat Yelp. Right now, it is debatable if you are even just better than Yelp.
- debt 12y agoFoursquare doesn't hold a candle to Yelp. I can order food, make a reservation and figure out what's going on in my neighborhood with Yelp. Foursquare has a new logo.
- achompas 12y agoI disagree. Yelp's reviews are needlessly verbose and possibly gamed or filtered according to the store's affiliation with Yelp. I don't have the same concerns re: 4sq reviews.
- debt 12y agoThen why does Yelp itself only have 2 1/2 stars on Yelp? Couldn't they just game their own name? [1]http://www.yelp.com/biz/yelp-san-francisco http://www.yelp.com/biz/yelp-san-francisco
- achompas 12y agoIf we're getting into conspiracy theories, wouldn't gaming Yelp's reviews simply provide more evidence of gamed Yelp reviews?!?! I've spoken to numerous business owners in NYC who, after having turned down Yelp's super deluxe premier service^, begin to receive negative reviews that make no sense ("terrible service!" during a night the business was closed) or reference nonexistent items ("terrible apple pie!" for a bakery that doesn't offer apple pie). ^ Not the name, but they offer analytics and other services to businesses.
- 12y ago
- canistr 12y agoThe problem with Foursquare is that it was clearly designed by New Yorkers. In other cities where the distance and density of businesses/restaurants/etc. are much lower, the results aren’t as good. The only times where I’ve had a good Foursquare recommendation experience is when I was in Manhattan or in North Beach of San Francisco. Other places, the results just plain suck. In suburbs or midtowns, it isn’t good because the “local recommendations” are a little too small and give me results of places I have no intention of ever going to. Other times, it increases the range to a radius that is far too big.
- ryanklee 12y agoYes, and if you live (actively) in any mid-tier city for any appreciable amount time, recommendations become superfluous, because you basically know every establishment in the city, what's trending, what's not, and where to go (and where not to go) to get what you want. For food, clothing and goods. Whatever. And when something new opens up, you hear it about it. Friends give you the rundown, judgements proliferate, etc. I don't have a use for Foursquare or Yelp and, as far as I know, none of my friends do either. (For size reference, I live in Baltimore, MD.) Edit: I'll add, too, that "check ins" that get posted socially seem to be viewed increasingly as self-indulgent "look at me and my lovely life" signals. There was a time that such posts, along with "pics of my delicious dinner at trendy restaurant", etc., were regular and acceptable. That time is quickly passing, I think. The analogy is talking about how much money you have, or how cultural you are, etc. This isn't really polite and most people secretly roll their eyes in response to it. It appears either calculated or in incognizantly bad taste. This is just an anecdotal observation, of course. But these kinds of things have basically disappeared from my feed, which might just be an effect of an aging list of friends rather than a broader usage pattern. I suspect it's a generally emerging standard of social media etiquette though.
- lauradhamilton 12y agoI never check into restaurants -- I don't see the point. But I regularly check yelp to see reviews of new restaurants that spring up. Then I go check out the new restaurants with good reviews. (I live in Chicago.)
- sandy12 12y agoSo if I've never used Foursquare before, which do I install? I'm not interested in having any friends on the app I just think the reviews, and customised recommendations could be quite useful.
- nathos 12y agoFoursquare is the one you want then. Swarm is where the check-ins, friend-finder, and plan-making functionality is.
- bellerocky 12y agoIt's kind of amazing that this company is still around. They got way more money than they knew what to do with at a way too high of a valuation, the result being this highly polished zombie vestige of a previous era that is too expensive to buy, has too much money to die, and whimpers along with some kind of undefined shrinking user base. It's like a smaller, never IPO'ed version of Yahoo. I don't know how this story is going to end, but I doubt it will involve more people having any of their apps on their phone tomorrow than today, at least willingly. I could see some kind of carrier deal that extends the pain until finally they fall into the arms of a remnant brand hoarding corporation like IAC for pennies.
- neona 12y agoI have to say, splitting things up makes me think of the whole Netflix-Qwikster thing - pointless brand splitting that does little more than confuse and frustrate consumers. I do like the new logo though.
- untog 12y agoThe intention was to branch off Qwikster and have it slowly die. I actually think it wasn't an awful idea, but that they did it too early. With a terrible name. I suspect Foursquare want to slowly kill off checkins in a similar way.
- natch 12y agoThough I don't use it often, I feel an uncannily strong sense of good will toward Foursquare and the company. Probably because they pioneered this stuff. And because of their other company before Foursquare, Dodgeball, which Google bought and lame-ified. I met the team once for two seconds at a conference and they were really sweet happy people.
- bckrasnow 12y agoI hate the new logo with a passion. Why keep the place icon in the bottom on of the F and have the swirl behind it if the whole point of this was to take check-in's out of the app? It's saying you're doing one thing and then doing the opposite of that thing.
- jagermo 12y agoAnd, of course, no love for BlackBerry OS 10. Foursquare had a great native integration and now just dumps all BB-Users. Why do companies do that?
- vii 12y agoFoursquare had great usage all over the world. I've traveled widely (more than ninety countries) and all over Latin America and Eastern Europe Foursquare is regularly used. For some reason, it got a lot of hate from the Bay Area tech crowd who felt its heyday passed -- despite the fact that SF airport was always swarming. The pressure to keep on growing and have viral growth and turn into a destination app means that app like Foursquare with less mainstream gamifications sadly don't get the respect they maybe deserve, and are forced to try to go viral, etc. which is not a natural path for every app, and there should be a way to fund and let these apps achieve their natural success. Foursquare location data was great (used by Uber) and it's sad they're alienating the users who provided them this value.
- wilsynet 12y agoIf Foursquare had been bought by FB, Google, Yahoo a few years ago when it had peaked, and then a few years later numbers were down, and engagement became sparse, the parent company would have either de-invested or shut it down. And then there would have been a slew of articles and criticism about how once again a big company has squandered an opportunity. Instead we get to see what really happens when the founding team executes a pivot on what is already a pretty successful product and service that has not yet fulfilled the Yelp sized aspirations of its founders, investors and employees.
- lnanek2 12y agoI kind of liked Foursquare. I don't like the looks of Swarm. And I'm kind of pissed they bug me constantly to install it. I guess they want to kick out the old Foursquare users and make it into a Yelp competitor or something. Haven't really decided what to do. They are taking away my check in functionality so maybe I'll just uninstall it. Why should I go install some new app for what I've always been using.
- ddp 12y agoThis seems like something akin to a desperation move by a company that's floundering, er, pivoting, er, failing?