3 ms·
> Lower frequency (50/60 Hz) AC is the only really useful choice for transmission on low cost long runs (think 100 km and more). To push high voltage DC on long
by dreamcompiler 12y ago
> Lower frequency (50/60 Hz) AC is the only really useful choice for transmission on low cost long runs (think 100 km and more). To push high voltage DC on long runs generally means special cables and possibly super conductors. Pushing 60 Hz AC at 230 kV goes over simple cables.
Not correct. High-voltage DC runs just fine on regular copper. (In fact, in some cases you only need a single conductor because you can use the Earth as the return. This isn't typically in the design spec, but it's sometimes used as a backup plan.) Low-voltage DC requires superconductors, because pushing low-voltage anything any distance requires superconductors.
The only reason most transmission is over AC today is Tesla (the man, not the car) didn't have power electronics to step-up or step-down voltage. We now have the technology to change the grid to DC if we want.
- jimmyswimmy 12y ago> We now have the technology to change the grid to DC if we want. True, but the cost of each endpoint is significantly higher for DC than AC, especially at high power. I would imagine the reliability and longevity of power-equivalent DC converters would also be lower than that of AC units. That is to say, a complicated electronic component with many critical parts is more likely to fail than a simple transformer.
- bradfa 12y agoCopper is quite expensive for long cable runs, but your point about pushing lower voltage DC needing super conductors is true compared to high voltage DC not needing super conductors. You can also use the earth as a return in an AC system. This is often done with more remote areas when distributing power in order to keep the cost down. It has downsides, but it works well enough.