9 ms·
The Stanford Prison Experiment was flawed
- oldmanjay 12y agoanecdotally, the people I know who pursue psychology vocationally are not the most rigorous thinkers. more than half have a serious belief in astrology, for instance. which is to say, I don't know what people expect, but I'm never surprised when I find out that any given psychology experiment is a fanciful construct of lies and half-truths.
- ryanklee 12y ago> anecdotally Yeah, I'd say. Sometimes anecdotes are useful, revealing something interesting about a person's experience in the world. Here, you've done something very unfair: extrapolate from very a very small perspective into a very large idea of what the world is like. Psychology is a rich field with diverse practitioners. Rational, data driven, empirical methods underpin psych research as anywhere in the sciences. And where this isn't true, where Freudians and Jungians, etc., hold sway, there's something interesting going on there, too. Mushy and soft and philosophical and silly as it might be. Don't discount the value of centuries of inquiry and practice because you know a half dozen idiot psychologists that believe in astrology. This is not a representative or useful sample.
- oldmanjay 12y agowell, you scooted right on by my point, which is in the second paragraph. are you a Capricorn?
- fit2rule 12y agoPsychology is a modern religion masquerading as a science. Its as much a means of social control as anything else, and is promoted by governments because it gives them a way of subverting the general will of the people, that they not have religions dogma enforced upon them by the state. Psychology is little more than cultural dogma categorized in a way that it allows application for political purposes, and anyone who disagrees with that Psychology is a true science, is of course .. "crazy" .. Just count the number of times you hear someone say "that guy is certifiably insane, he should be committed to an asylum" any time someone comes up with a non-popular point of view .. this is the government religion at work.
- DanBC 12y ago> Just count the number of times you hear someone say "that guy is certifiably insane, he should be committed to an asylum" any time someone comes up with a non-popular point of view .. this is the government religion at work. England has government spending on psychology - mostly in the form of health spending on psychological talking therapies. In England you can't easily[1] be detained under the Mental Health Act for having a "non popular point of view". There are a number of checks and balances built into the system. While the system isn't perfect it is very unlikely that a person would be detained just for an unpopular opinion. So "The Government" is not out to get you. Of course, your comment talks about the general population. Yep, you're right, many people in the general population display shocking ignorance about mental health problems and they are happy to blame mental illness when a person displays challenging behaviours or opinions. That's not the fault of government propaganda, that's the fault of ignorance about mental health problems. (EDIT: spelling)
- fit2rule 12y agoThe point is this: over the last 5 decades, since Psychology became accepted by society, as a movement it has established itself as the High Priests of society - by ingratiating itself as a subject in Law, in Civic affairs, and so on. Western governments have been more than willing to let themselves have this '3rd arm' of enforcement to apply to their protection; time and again, we hear "government-appointed psychologist says [blah]" about some figure, and whenever the psychological health of any individual is discussed, if an 'expert' (high priest) comes along with their statement that the individual has any one of the invented malladies in their bible (DSM-IV), then thats the end of that guy. Take him away! My point is this: general society hasn't noticed this infiltration of their governments, and are - at this point - perfectly okay with it. So it doesn't really matter if its a science or not - Psychology has been accepted as the official state religion, for determining just how compliant any individual is with the group-think de jour, and that's all that really matters ...
- DanBC 12y ago> time and again, we hear "government-appointed psychologist says [blah]" about some figure Please could you point to a single "government appointed psychologist" saying [blah] about some figure? Because while I'm sure they're common in oppressive regimes I haven't heard of one recently in non-oppressive regimes. > if an 'expert' (high priest) comes along with their statement that the individual has any one of the invented malladies in their bible (DSM-IV), then thats the end of that guy. Take him away! There are abuses of the various rules for detaining and treating someone against their will. I mentioned that in my first reply. But it's not as easy as you suggest and hasn't been for some years now. If you're saying that psychology had severe abuse in the system early on then we both agree.
- DanBC 12y agoThis comment is a hilarious parody. It criticises others for lack of rigorous thinking while simultaneously declaring itself to be anecdotal and based on the poster's observations.
- joeclark77 12y agoI saw "Ghostbusters" as well, but the joke's on you. All that crazy stuff they believed turned out to be true (in the movie).
- esquivalience 12y agoZach Weinersmith of SMBC put this very well in one frame and a caption: http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=3025 http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=3025
- mathattack 12y agoThis issue is true with much of social science. It would be great to see more replication (or non-replication) experiments to confirm what we think we do or don't know.
- DanBC 12y agoThe linked comic is true - there are many problems with social science studies. But, since you specifically mention replication and non-replication -- how well is this covered in the rest of science? How well is the null-hypothesis covered? (I should say that I'm not trying to suggest that physics is as sloppy as psychology sometimes appears to be.) (EDIT: spelling)
- mathattack 12y agoIt's a problem everywhere. I think Physics is somewhat spared because the gap between observation and math is less. (String theory perhaps being an exception) I think biochemistry runs into these issues more because it is harder to "prove" things with math. In general the less you can rely on supporting math or theory, the more you need to be careful about replicating experiments to come up with the truth.
- cyorir 12y agoI think this is misunderstanding the role of math in science. Math is not used to "prove" scientific results, per se. Math is used to construct models, and prove that certain results would be expected from a given model. That doesn't mean the models work in the real world; all sciences use experiments to test models to see if they describe actual observations. In this sense, you always need to be careful about replication, regardless of field. If you can't show replication, then there is no guarantee that the model will always match observations, no matter how much math went into the construction of that model. In Physics the main problem is isolating variables, and setting up appropriate conditions. The good thing about Physics is that once the environment is set up and the experiment is well designed, it is easy to re-run the experiment for more trials. With chemistry and biology, this is usually the case as long as you have clean reagents in a clean lab, but you are introducing more factors of what you have to control as the complexity of your system scales up. It is hardest to replicate results involving humans, because with humans you have a lot of complexity, so you know you can never control all influencing factors. Usually in the social sciences, it is easier to hope these factors cancel out with a large, non-homogenous sample size. The problem as these experiments like SPE demonstrate is that it is hard to build an ideal sample and, if the ethics or practicality of your methods are questioned, rerun the experiment to replicate results.
- gergles 12y agoWell, define 'flawed'. It is flawed if you attempt to interpret it as being representative of how people in the general population would behave in a setting without an active experimenter interfering, sure. It does still reveal the influence that one person can have on a group of people and how much can be changed about behavior. It would be unwise to throw away discussions of the experiment because people can't properly place the data in context or evaluate the strengths/weaknesses of the experimental design and implementation (which is what Psychology courses should be teaching you to do in the first place.)
- watwut 12y agoThe linked article criticizes text books for not covering experiments criticism. The full title is: "What the textbooks don't tell you - one of psychology's most famous experiments was seriously flawed". The title on HN have been shortened and information got lost in the process.
- ColinWright 12y agoThe title was too long, and it wasn't clear what should or should not be included. I did my best. <shrug />
- judk 12y agoNote that this is exactly what is wrong with how the experiment is discussed in text books and pop culture!
- cracell 12y agoIt's not scientific though. It's an anecdotal story. Which can be useful but shouldn't be taken anymore seriously than any other documented story about abuses of authority. But there's no good control to make scientific conclusions on why the abuses occurred.
- marincounty 12y agoIn my life, I have found at least 95% of the people I have interacted will commit immoral acts/lie/cheat/ etc; as long as it's legal? They won't Jaywalk, but will commit horrid/spineless acts in order to make a buck, or secure their financial future. It would be hard to reproduce this study because so many people know about it, but I doubt the outcome would be much different. Man is spineless. I guess if you do show conviction and stand up for what is right; you run the risk of Homelessness? To bad! Oh, and just doing the right thing when people are looking, or convenient doesn't count.
- triangleman 12y agoFirst of all, have you read the article? When you say "I doubt the outcome would be much different" are you basing that on the same prejudices that Zimbardo had when he ran the experiment the first time? Also, watch out for sloppy thinking: If people will commit immoral acts as long as it's legal, that makes them heartless, not spineless. Make sure you know what your standard is, because it will be used to judge you.
- tokenadult 12y agoArticles about issues like this have been submitted several times to Hacker News, and I'm glad to see that this article is getting some discussion. Right after I saw the submission here, I looked up articles on the replication problem in psychology, and I came back to the PsychFileDrawer.org top 20 list of studies that are nominated as needing more replication.[1] I'd like to see more replication of several of those studies myself. Another recent commentary that I don't recall seeing submitted to Hacker News is "Psychology's real replication problem: our Methods sections,"[2] which suggests (quite plausibly to me) that many publications in psychology journals describe the methods of the study so inadequately that it is hard to know whether or not the study can be replicated. A scholar of how scientific research is conducted and of statistical errors that show up in many peer-reviewed scientific publications, Uri Simonsohn, has a whole website about "p-hacking" and how to detect it.[3] Simonsohn is a professor of psychology with a better than average understanding of statistics. He and his colleagues are concerned about making scientific papers more reliable. You can use the p-curve software on that site for your own investigations into p values found in published research. Many of the interesting issues brought up by comments on the article kindly submitted here become much more clear after reading Simonsohn's various articles[4] about p values and what they mean, and other aspects of interpreting published scientific research. And I think Hacker News readers who have thought deeply about statistics will be delighted by the sense of humor while making pointed remarks about experimental methods that you can find in the papers of Simonsohn and his colleagues. Simonsohn provides an abstract (which links to a full, free download of a funny, thought-provoking paper)[5] with a "twenty-one word solution" to some of the practices most likely to make psychology research papers unreliable. He also has a paper posted on evaluating replication results[6] with more specific tips on that issue. "Abstract: "When does a replication attempt fail? The most common standard is: when it obtains p > .05. I begin here by evaluating this standard in the context of three published replication attempts, involving investigations of the embodiment of morality, the endowment effect, and weather effects on life satisfaction, concluding the standard has unacceptable problems. I then describe similarly unacceptable problems associated with standards that rely on effect-size comparisons between original and replication results. Finally, I propose a new standard: Replication attempts fail when their results indicate that the effect, if it exists at all, is too small to have been detected by the original study. This new standard (1) circumvents the problems associated with existing standards, (2) arrives at intuitively compelling interpretations of existing replication results, and (3) suggests a simple sample size requirement for replication attempts: 2.5 times the original sample." I should add that slamming the entire discipline of psychology as a discipline with sloppy methodology goes a bit too far. I have learned about most of the publications that take psychology most to task from working psychology researchers. There are whole departments of psychology[7] that largely have a scientific orientation and are trying to improve the discipline's methodology. Crap psychology abounds, but it is gradually being displaced by science-based psychology based on sound methodologies. It is of course more methodologically difficult to study the behavior of our fellow human beings than to study clouds or volcanoes or insects, but many scientifically oriented psychologists are working on the problem with good methods and sound statistical analysis. Some thoughtful psychologists have been prompted to stress careful replication by the failed studies that have come before.[8] [1] http://www.psychfiledrawer.org/top-20/ http://www.psychfiledrawer.org/top-20/ [2] http://psychsciencenotes.blogspot.com/2014/05/psychologys-real-replication-problem.html http://psychsciencenotes.blogspot.com/2014/05/psychologys-re... [3] http://www.p-curve.com/ http://www.p-curve.com/ [4] http://opim.wharton.upenn.edu/~uws/ http://opim.wharton.upenn.edu/~uws/ [5] http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2160588 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2160588 [6] http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2259879 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2259879 [7] http://www.psych.umn.edu/research/areas/pib/ http://www.psych.umn.edu/research/areas/pib/ [8] http://www.psychologicalscience.org/index.php/publications/observer/2012/february-12/psychologys-woes-and-a-partial-cure-the-value-of-replication.html http://www.psychologicalscience.org/index.php/publications/o...
- meowface 12y agoAre there any similar critiques of the Milgram experiment? edit: Also, what the hell happened to HN comments sections lately?
- unhammer 12y agoWell, there are interesting follow-ups at least: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jopy.12104/abstract http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jopy.12104/abstra... (summarised at http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-green-mind/201406/are-polite-people-more-violent-and-destructive http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-green-mind/201406/ar... ) Some nice quotes from the discussion (citations removed here for readability): As expected, Conscientiousness and Agreeableness predicted the intensity of electric shocks administered to the victim. Second, we showed that disobedience was influenced by political orientation, with left-wing political ideology being associated with decreased obedience. Third, we showed that women who were willing to participate in rebellious political activities such as going on strike or occupying a factory administered lower shocks. All these results suggest that situational context, even though a powerful determinate of behavior, does not necessarily overwhelm individual-level behavioral determinants. It is interesting to note that personality traits such as Agreeableness and Conscientiousness, which are widely related to positive outcomes such as better mental health, longevity, academic performance, parenting, reduced aggression, and prosocial behavior, may also have darker sides in that they can lead to destructive and immoral obedience.
- mathetic 12y agoTitle of the article is seriously flawed. Every textbook and every respectable course spends more time criticising Stanford Prison Experiment more than discussing its results.
- joshuahedlund 12y agoThe text of the article contains evidence which supports the title's assertion and contradicts your assertion that "every textbook" criticizes the experiment. Do you have evidence to support your assertion? > So, have the important criticisms and reinterpretations of the SPE been documented by key introductory psychology textbooks? Greggs analysed the content of 13 leading US introductory psychology textbooks, all of which have been revised in recent years, including: Discovering Psychology (Cacioppo and Freberg, 2012); Psychological Science (Gazzaniga et al, 2012); and Psychology (Schacter et al, 2011). > Of the 13 analysed texts, 11 dealt with the Stanford Prison Experiment, providing between one to seven paragraphs of coverage. Nine included photographic support for the coverage. Five provided no criticism of the SPE at all. The other six provided only cursory criticism, mostly focused on the questionable ethics of the study. Only two texts mentioned the BBC Prison Study. Only one text provided a formal scholarly reference to a critique of the SPE.
- hellodevnull 12y agoThe half-life of knowledge in psychology is thought to be one year, so by now most of the famous experiments (and their findings) in the field are considered flawed. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Half-life_of_knowledge http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Half-life_of_knowledge
- M4v3R 12y agoThe very link from Wikipedia you used says that half-life of knowledge in psychology is five years. Still, that's not very long either.
- hellodevnull 12y agoMistype. The point is don't take academic psychology seriously.
- seanflyon 12y agoSadly this extends past psychology to other scientific disciplines. There are many foods for example that have been shown to both dramatically increase and decrease you risk of cancer in well respected scientific journals. There is a strong incentive to find extreme results and too few peers actually reproduce results.
- frobozz 12y agoI vaguely recall seeing a similar thing about Milgram's Obedience experiments. The experimenters allegedly broke protocol by prompting the subjects too many times or bullying them, rather than using the prescribed neutral prompts. However, I can't remember where I heard this.
- trhway 12y ago>The experimenters allegedly broke protocol by prompting the subjects too many times or bullying them and thus showed that "prompting the subjects too many times or bullying them" still makes people to follow the prompts and deliver the shock where "prescribed neutral prompts" weren't enough.
- robg 12y agoNot flawed per se, if we see Zimbardo like Milgram as the guy in the white coat. If anything it's a case study in what "encouragement" means in the social context, like Abu Gharib or the Holocaust. No study is perfect, it can't be. By trying to control for variables, new ones are introduced and objectivity is lost and gained. No surprise there.
- mbateman 12y agoThe most surprising thing is that the textbooks haven't been updated. When I was a psych prof this was a commonplace among all my colleagues and even students. It's even common to use this "experiment" as a case study in class to discuss problematic experimental design. I'm not sure why textbooks haven't been updated, but I doubt the hypotheses mentioned in the article (ignorance, that the authors believe the study, and pressure to keep textbooks short).
- asgard1024 12y agoCan someone explain why is SPE not relevant to Abu Ghraib? While you can argue the experiment was flawed, I am not sure its results are. I am asking myself, if all the outrage about the SPE (and also Milgram) experiments being unethical (or flawed) isn't really about something that we don't want to really know about human nature.
- dmix 12y agoAgreed, especially with this part: > Zimbardo played a key role in encouraging his "guards" to behave in tyrannical fashion. How do we know that the Abu Ghraib guards weren't told to be tyrannical by the CIA or other management figures? Noone was really blaming the guards themselves for causing it to happen.
- pessimizer 12y agoWe know they were. MPE doesn't confirm the belief that cruelty spontaneously forms in previously uncruel people when they are put in charge of others - but does it claim to? If that were true, every parent would be an abuser. What it does support is that if you put people in charge of other people, and only punish the people in charge for lapses in order, and not for cruelty, then a large percentage of them will become cruel to prevent lapses in order.
- DanBC 12y agoSPE is tainted and so we should be very careful when drawing conclusions from it. This is true even if, although tainted, its conclusions are correct. Things like Abu Ghraib are really severe. They don't just apply to "terrorists"[1] in military detention. See 'WinterBourne View'. This was a hospital[3] for long term care for people with learning disability. Residents were the victims of horrible treatment from people who were supposed to care for them. See also the poor care provided by some staff at West Staffs hospital. Since our aim is to stop and reduce incidents of abuse we need good quality research to make sure that we're not making things worse. [1] Using troubling but easy shorthand. Sorry. [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winterbourne_View_hospital_abuse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winterbourne_View_hospital_abu... [3] Cultural note: It was a private hospital, but most of the people there would have had their care paid for by the state. This happens quite a lot in mental health treatment - most eating disorder in-patient beds will be private; most medium and high secure "forensic" beds will be private.
- truantbuick 12y agoSPE is an absolute mess as an experiment, and shouldn't really be regarded as science. However, you really don't even have to go far so far into the technical details to find it to be flawed. The whole premise seems absurd to me. You get some students, tell some of them to act like prison guards and the rest to act like prisoners, and then it's supposed to be surprising that they follow through on this? "Well, we didn't expect them to be so sadistic!" There's nothing I read that was more sadistic than a fairly typical hazing ritual. All participants knew this was ultimately voluntary and could quit at any time.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 12y agoThis blog article doesn't tell me that MPE was flawed, either. All of those words criticizing other sources, but nothing summarizing the factual basis for those criticisms other than links to papers that .001% of the people reading this blog entry will complete. My guess at why textbooks ignore the criticism is because it is not convincing.
- dmfdmf 12y agoWho cares? Isn't this an experiment validating a known conclusion anyway? Evil exists in the hearts of many. Give these bad people unlimited power and they will take out their frustrations on their fellow man. We see this all around us, if one is paying attention. The disgruntled Russian doorman, the lady who runs the local Home Owner's Association and likes to boss people around to sooth her psuedo-ego, the cop who shoots the non-aggressive dog or chokes out a cuffed arrestee because he can. And let's not forget the biggest experiment of all -- Nazi Germany where millions died. Now there is an experiment that went on way too long and should have been aborted. I just hope we learn the right lessons. NB: I am not saying everyone is evil.
- JulianK 12y agoI think the reason why the experiment, if true, is so fascinating is because it's about normal people put into an abnormal situation rather than inherently bad people being given power. What I take away from the experiment is that given the right situation and pressures, most people would do things they thought they would never otherwise do. More importantly, I think it's probably a mistake to think that you're the exception and are morally incorruptible.
- dmfdmf 12y agoThis is exactly the conclusion they want you to reach. Who are you to judge? Who are you to condemn anyone since you are evil too? This is the charter of liberty for evil and all evil needs to survive, even prosper. This "experiment" is the biblical tenet of Original Sin masquerading as science and I reject it. If your moral principles cannot be practiced consistently by all men then something is wrong with your principles, not human nature.
- threatofrain 12y agoThe conclusion would essentially say that some social structures are more explanatory of behavior than individual psychology. Given how much importance people place on personal idiosyncrasy or psychology, I'd say this is pretty cool if better confirmed.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y agoIt might be convenient if the Stanford Prison Experiment continued to be discredited, often and harshly. Who would want to be in charge if all the peons were constantly mumbling about how being in charge turned leaders into petty tyrants? It'd just be awkward and uncomfortable.