4 ms·
I'm not a fan of the way that argument was phrased, but the obvious difference is the physical difference between how a physical object is "stolen" and how a di
by baddox 12y ago
I'm not a fan of the way that argument was phrased, but the obvious difference is the physical difference between how a physical object is "stolen" and how a digital work is "stolen." It just comes down to property rights, which are subjective and change over time. Under my own subjective impression of property rights, someone breaking into my house and taking a sculpture I made is a violation of my rights, but if I sell a CD to someone and they give away a copy of it, I don't feel like there was a violation.
- alexqgb 12y agoWhen it comes to unauthorized copies that do not fall within the parameters of fair use, the theft - for lack of a better word - is not of the copy in question. The bone of contention is actually the money that you would have paid to the author in the case of a legal transaction, and which you "save" in the case of an illegal duplication. It's kind of like "saving" money on milk by walking out of the store without paying for it. Whether you're taking possession of a finite physical good, or increasing the legally regulated supply an intangible one, you're doing something that - by law - triggers an obligation to pay another person money. Disregarding the obligation by making a copy and retaining possession of the money which, by right, you now owe another, is where specific and definable deprivation enters the picture. When people who understand what they're talking about refer to "theft" in relation to the unauthorized duplication of intangible goods, this is what they mean.
- baddox 12y ago> The bone of contention is actually the money that you would have paid to the author in the case of a legal transaction, and which you "save" in the case of an illegal duplication. The problem with that analysis is that the amount of money you didn't give to the artist is the same regardless of whether you downloaded a copy. In fact, the vast majority of people in the world didn't pay the creator of the media. And even for physical items, compensation to the initial holder is not what's relevant. If you take a gallon of milk and sneak out of the grocery store, but leave enough cash on the shelf in its stead, I think you will still be found of shoplifting, and I personally agree with that assessment. Likewise, if someone breaks into my house and takes my sculpture and leaves a million dollars of cash, that's still theft. What constitutes theft of a physical object is precisely that the item was taken not on the terms of the property holder.
- alexqgb 12y ago"The problem with that analysis is that the amount of money you didn't give to the artist is the same regardless of whether you downloaded a copy." And yet, demand for that media was nevertheless satisfied. So all the costs in creating it were invested with no hope of return. That may have been stupid move on the part of the author, but if the money dries up, how long do you think these people are going to go on investing their own time and resources for free? "What constitutes theft of a physical object is precisely that the item was taken not on the terms of the property holder." Exactly. And the same goes for intangible property. Indeed, that's the whole point of IP law: to create a situation where it's impossible to avoid a formal negotiation with the property holder without breaking the law.
- baddox 12y ago> And yet, demand for that media was nevertheless satisfied. A quantity of one was satisfied at a price of zero. That's a pretty trivial spot on the demand curve. It tells you nothing about the demand for that same good at nonzero prices.
- alexqgb 12y agoWhat's the name of the rhetorical tactic where you avoid an argument instead of addressing it by reframing the terms to create an obviously absurd and / or non-representative case? There's a word for it, and it does not reflect well on the intellectual integrity of the people who use it. That's fair warning. Back to the topic: I was speaking in generalities, but if I were to get as specific as you just did (by assigning a specific quantity of one), I wouldn't draw any sweeping conclusions before doing the intellectually honest thing by asking what happens when the quantity = n? If, say, n = 1,000,000, then the effect is not so trivial. Moreover, the producer typically cares about the price point at which the number of sales and the value of each sale combine to produce the greatest possible revenue. While this point is not only non-obvious, it is likely to vary over time. So setting the price can be tricky. But one thing you can be sure of is that it's not zero. Moreover, all demand satisfied at the zero point is removed from the pool in which the ideal price / volume relation can be found, given that volume is a function of demand. In other words, the optimal price in a leaky will pool will invariably be lower than one in a pool that doesn't leak. And that's how demand destruction lowers the commercial potential of a property with near-zero marginal cost.