7 ms·
Do the laws prohibit private companies from installing fast internet? I don't necessarily want a city government running my internet. Cities should not be in th
by briandear 12y ago
Do the laws prohibit private companies from installing fast internet? I don't necessarily want a city government running my internet. Cities should not be in the telecommunications business. However, there SHOULD be laws promoting competition and thus restricting the de facto monopoly positions of many providers. Where I live in France, I have, in just my small town of Avignon, at least 5 high speed internet providers available -- resulting in my monthly cost for 120mbs + full cable (all the movie channels) cell phone with unlimited data, unlimited calls to over 49 countries in the world AND home phone (which I never use) for about 70 euro per month. The internet portion of that is something like 20 euro per month, the cell portion is about 15 or so (give or take 3 euro.)
Cities don't need to get in the telecoms business -- however governments do have a responsibility to promote competition. Cities getting into the internet business would be about as efficient as the Post Office getting into the letter delivery business -- a ton of public-union-related waste, bureaucratic inefficiencies as well as an inherit incentive to discourage private companies, thus reducing innovation. You also have the issue of city-run networks being subject to political pressures such as "I'll donate money to your reelection if you allow my content to have preference on the network." You also have the city having access to your usage records and they'd be nothing keeping them from using it for law enforcement purposes without a warrant or your consent. After all, you'd be using city-owned property, thus you really wouldn't have much leverage. The police would certainly leverage that. We all know that most internet traffic isn't going to be safe from NSA-types, however, there's a reasonable belief that NSA-level intercepts aren't filtering down to the local cop on the beat. Maybe it's a bit of paranoia, however based on my experiences with city governments in the US, they are some of the most power-hungry, corrupt sufferers of little-man(woman) syndrome I've ever encountered. These are the same twits that want to ban large sodas because they think they're your daddies and mommies. Yeah, count me out. Last thing anyone needs to do is give a city (or any) government more power to do anything.
- ceejayoz 12y agoCities generally have to be at least partially in the telecom business, or there'd be five independent sets of telephone poles on every street.
- ThinkingGuy 12y agoIn some areas customers can choose among competing providers to have their natural gas delivered through a single set of lines. I've often wondered how feasible it would be to have do something similar with Internet access: The government owns and manages of the physical network infrastructure, but users have a choice of private and/or non-profit ISPs to provide actual Internet service (ie, routing traffic in and out of the municipal network). Obviously there are a lot of details to be worked out, but are there any significant technical reasons this couldn't be done?
- nmrm 12y agoI think this makes a lot more sense in the case of gas/oil, where you actually need something to fill the tubes.
- necubi 12y agoThis is the norm in other industrialized nations. It's called local loop unbundling [0], and comes in several different forms. In some countries the local telco monopoly is prohibited from selling to end customers and must lease their last mile cables to other companies at regulated rates. In others they must just provide access to the cables. There's a lot of evidence that mandatory LLU reduces prices and increases speeds. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local_Loop_Unbundling http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local_Loop_Unbundling
- mseebach 12y agoIt's not a dream either. There are still plenty of places in central London you can't get decent broadband, never mind the countryside. It's also relevant to note the background for LLU: the cables were almost all installed by a government owned telco, so there's a clear argument for the infrastructure being owned by the taxpayer. LLU came into existence as government telcos were privatised in the 90s to avoid creating a private monopoly.
- dguaraglia 12y agoWhat happens in the US is that municipalities will sign exclusivity agreements with certain companies (Comcast, AT&T, TWC) to encourage them to lay down the infrastructure. Imagine you are the mayor of Podunk, Arkansas and you want your constituents to have access to high speed internet. AT&T and Comcast won't rush to lay cables to your town because there's simply not enough business for them to compete for. So, as mayor of Podunk give AT&T an exclusivity agreement for 20 years in exchange for them laying down the infrastructure today. The problem is obvious: now AT&T doesn't have any competition and they can do whatever they want with their prices. Your population is hostage to the exclusivity agreement for the next 20 years. One possible solution for this problem would be the government to build the infrastructure and then invite companies to compete for it's usage. That's what happens in UK and other countries.
- rayiner 12y agoGranting exclusive franchises for cable have been illegal under federal law since 1992.
- stonogo 12y agoWhile true, your statement is completely irrelevant, as is that section of the law to which you refer. Local governments simply switched to leasing right-of-way access; cable companies now simply pay for exclusive access to that, instead of exclusive control of a given franchise area.
- rayiner 12y agoI don't know where you're getting that from. That is explicitly prohibited by 47 U.S.C. 253(a): "No State or local statute or regulation, or other State or local legal requirement, may prohibit or have the effect of prohibiting the ability of any entity to provide any interstate or intrastate telecommunications service." See: https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&ei=KM_NU7PgFYb5oASejoDwAQ&url=http://www.ctrc.maryland.gov/articles/pdf/Effect_on_Broadband_Deployment.pdf&cd=7&ved=0CCsQFjAG&usg=AFQjCNFRz09nyLt0GFcF1V7JjkD0ynhKwQ https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&ei=KM_NU7Pg.... Section III(A). The NTIA has a 50-state survey of right of way laws here: https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&ei=KM_NU7PgFYb5oASejoDwAQ&url=http://www.ntia.doc.gov/legacy/ntiahome/staterow/statelocalrow.html&cd=2&ved=0CCEQFjAB&usg=AFQjCNF3tJ0t8xc34iXN5KMyx3jOJdpjXQ https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&ei=KM_NU7Pg...
- afterburner 12y ago"Cities should not be in the telecommunications business." You state that as if it is self-evident, and yet cities have run all sorts of utilities for a long time. Internet access is fast turning into a utility.
- MBlume 12y agoI have a lot of sympathy for this sort of argument, but I'm starting to think it might be wrong in this case. Like it or not, the project of wiring a city for broadband is going to involve a fuckton of waiting for permission from the city government. There is no "just go do it without government interference" option -- you have to deal with the existing underground architecture, get licenses to dig, get licenses to install hardware, etc. I think at the end of the day it might be simpler to just let the city do the job than to create some huge beaurocratic interface between the city and an ISP.
- SEJeff 12y agoFunny, South Korea has government managed fiber and in fact, they have some of the fastest and most pervasive broadband in the world[1]. Much more-so than the USA. [1] http://www.akamai.com/stateoftheinternet/ http://www.akamai.com/stateoftheinternet/ (check out the infographics and note the 24Mbps speeds in South Korea)
- icantthinkofone 12y agoSouth Korea is smaller than my state of Missouri. Now let's see how fast the US can provide broadband speeds if they dumped all their resources into my state alone.
- jessaustin 12y agoI doubt SK is "dumping" all the resources of the USA into its broadband infrastructure. But that's beside the point. USA telcos/cablecos have had ample opportunity to provide decent service. The whole time, they've been coddled by government regulation. When the regulators screwed up and allowed too much competition (e.g. UNE-P) the telcos squealed and the pain went away. Telcos/cablecos don't like government-run competition, because they don't like competition, full stop.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 12y agoSouth Korea has about half the per-capita GDP of the US. Why would you think the entire resources of the US would be necessary to give Missouri similar infrastructure?
- Barraketh 12y agoSo then why doesn't New Jersey do this? It is smaller than SK and has comparable population density: 1288 vs 1171 per sq mi. Or how about NYC? Or LA? People keep bringing up USA size or density statistics when talking about government run utilities, but there are plenty of places where they could work given a will to invest in public infrastructure.
- rayiner 12y ago> Do the laws prohibit private companies from installing fast internet? Effectively, yes. They can't outright ban competition, but they make it very unattractive using franchise provisions, namely build out requirements. See: http://crosscut.com/2014/03/04/business/118993/google-fiber-never-come-seattle-broadband-internet http://crosscut.com/2014/03/04/business/118993/google-fiber-... Unless you have unlimited capital, the most practical way to start a competitor to Comcast, etc, is one neighborhood at a time. Start at the high end, and pick off the local incumbent's high-margin customers. This would have a disproportionate impact on the incumbent's bottom line. However, in most cities, this is simply not allowed. You have to build out everywhere in order to be allowed to build out anywhere. Where I live, in Wilmington DE, more than a quarter of the city lives below the poverty line. Verizon refuses to build FiOS here, in competition with Comcast, because there is no point building $60+ per month fiber service to neighborhoods that can't afford it.
- xenadu02 12y agoWe don't need "innovation", we need a reliable utility. Here in the US my water and sewer are handled by the city. It's pretty cheap and effective. I don't need more "innovation" in my water delivery. My electricity is delivered by a regulated monopoly provider that answers to a Public Utility Commission and has a strictly regulated profit margin; it's purchased from one of a hundred retail providers. The supposed benefits of competition haven't materialized - we're paying the same for electricity now as we did when all electricity was a single regulated monopoly on an inflation-adjusted basis, only now no private investor will pony up for capital investment projects so we keep building cheap crappy power plants. Otherwise it's the same as before and it seems to function fairly well. Either of these would be a huge improvement and exactly what the government is best at - handling public infrastructure that is ill-suited to competition or forms a natural monopoly. In fact I'm suffering from Verizon's "innovation" right now thanks to their refusal to upgrade peering links. They're "innovating" ways to choke traffic to seek rent/extract money on my private transactions with Netflix, Crunchyroll, and others, despite the fact that I am already paying them for use of their network (and they used my private property to lay lines to the rest of the neighborhood - something for which I am not compensated). I do not have any choices; my neighborhood has congested capped cable from TW or Verizon's artificially congested FIOS. That's it. Frankly when Ma Bell/ATT was broken up I firmly believe it was done in a way to serve ATT's long-interests by keeping the retail and lines in the same ILEC box. It let the (D) government appear to be "doing something", right up until the (R)s proceeded to never meet a merger they didn't like. What we need to to break apart Verizon and ATT and turn the physical plant into a regulated delivery company (DeliveryCo) charged with running fiber to the 90% of reasonably-reachable homes in the USA. That physical infrastructure should serve us for at least 100 years - we know how to send 10Gbps/100Gbps and more down the line and the expensive part is digging up yards/streets; the boxes on either end are a pittance by comparison. I suspect it would actually serve us for 1000 years or more but it's The Future so who knows. Let anyone who wants to start an ISP do so; DeliveryCo just drops the ISP fiber/ethernet cables at whatever datacenter you like in your city and they're responsible for backhaul/transit, billing, customer service, packages, etc. Let DeliveryCo be effectively transparent with VLANs or IP/IP encapsulation so as far as my router and my ISP's router are concerned DeliveryCo doesn't exist. People can claim it doesn't work, but the regulators seem perfectly capable of demanding 60hz+/-@120V AC be reliably delivered to every home with guaranteed response/repair times (except in cases of emergencies). When my underground cable gave out and started arcing with the dirt they answered the phone and sent a truck within 2 hours and it was repaired within 5. If DeliveryCo's regulator said they had to deliver 1Gbps links I don't see why it would differ.
- rmrfrmrf 12y agoThe Internet is a public environment, so IMHO you'd be insane to think that 1) someone's not doing exactly what you're talking about already, and 2) that you're somehow safer with AT&T and/or Verizon. The situations you're describing are the exact reasons why people use TLS.
- rodgerd 12y ago> Cities should not be in the telecommunications business. Why not? If they can do it cheaper and better, they should. Any other position is religious idiocy.