2 ms·
Patents are a trade-off. In return for exclusively selling something for ten years, I spend a lot of time and money inventing something lots of people want to p
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Patents are a trade-off. In return for exclusively selling something for ten years, I spend a lot of time and money inventing something lots of people want to pay for.
Seems to me like a fair deal -- if the time limit is truly ten years, if the people who are the market are the same people who will benefit at the end of the period, and if patents are not overly-broad.
That's a lot of ifs, but it works in the U.S. The problem is that the market in the U.S. is nowhere indicative of the market in the third world, yet the drug companies want the same trade-off to apply everywhere. To this author's point, that doesn't seem to work so well.
Having said that, the answer isn't so easy either. Once you start using government force (or ignoring compliance) to appropriate other people's IP, the incentive goes away.
Of course you can argue that there are other incentives: altruism, government mandates, public-funded research. But all of those things haven't proven to be very effective, no matter how much hand-waving or yelling the supporters do.
This is not an easy problem.